The people who say "Let villains be villains.", "Well why not redeem Ozai, he's also a victim of his parents.", or "Azula being redeemed would diminish Zuko's arc." completely miss the point.

"Let villains be villains."

I don't think anyone has a problem with her arc in the main series and her being a villain. Sure, it would have been great if someone (Mai, Ty Lee, Zuko, Iroh) had been in the position to help her, but they weren't, and that's fine by me. Her ending in a semi-ambiguous and tragic way fit well.

The problem is that the authors didn't know what to do with her afterwards and just kept her stagnant without letting her at least develop. I don't want her to "be nice" but in people's attempt to pigeonhole her into being just a "crazy bitch" they forget the positive and sympathetic qualities she does have! It's fine if she stays a villain, or better than hero or villain would be her being an anti-hero, but at least keep her (and everyone else) in line with their series characterisation.

Her world has gone down in flames, her previous relationships are gone (Azula also seems to be scared of changes in relationships, too, so that would be a big thing), and she has to confront her father's wrongdoings and the fact that he never loved her.

So, of course, she's going to change, for better or for worse. Though she can really only go up from there. What else can she do?

"Well, why not redeem Ozai? He's also a victim of his parents, too."

Ozai is also a grown-ass man and a child abuser with zero positive traits that people could see potential in. No, it's not just because Azula is a victim, a girl, or pretty/cool that people sympathise. If Aang had woken up years earlier and the Fire sibling conflict had been between a "Good" Iroh and an "Evil" Ozai as teenagers, then we could talk about a redemption arc, but people seem incapable of grasping that even different villainous characters can have different roles in the story.

"Azula being redeemed would diminish Zuko's arc."

King of redemption arcs my foot. If it can be ruined by his teenage sister also getting one it wasn't that great to begin with. I think it's a much more powerful story to say they were siblings who both had positive qualities but took different paths than to boil it down to Zuko good, Azula bad. Plus, if you must have symbolism and cautionary tales, then Iroh and Ozai or Sozin and Roku serve as perfectly good foils to Zuko and Azula.

reddit.com
u/ShadowStar_X — 5 days ago

People often talk about bland ML's or romance in otherwise great plots, but who are the MLs/couples that are the exact opposite for you?

MLs/couples that MADE the story and are the best thing about it, even if the plot might be a little cliché or otherwise lacking.

Titles are Hawar In The Winter Garden and I'm No Heroine.

u/ShadowStar_X — 1 month ago

Favorite character/s who have hair covering/partially covering an eye.

Annie Leonhart from AOT

Ray from The Promised Neverland

Astrid Hofferson from How To Train Your Dragon

Hajin Seo from The Blood Of A Butterfly

u/ShadowStar_X — 3 months ago

What love triangles did you like or dislike.

Liked:

Our Secret Alliance - It's pretty clear from early on that the FL and SML aren't exactly healthy together, and his relationship with her bff is cute.

The Devil Raises A Lady - I hate hate hate the "every plot relevant guy who's not a sibling of the FL is a suitor" trope, but for once it feels pretty natural and doesn't degrade from the story or characters for me. While it's uncertain if the Rox actually has romantic feelings for her, their relationship is so much more than that even if he does and I love their friendship.

Disliked:

Operation True Love - Pretty obvious to anyone who's read it why lol. I like all the characters well enough, but every single one of them has suffered in characterisation because of the love triangle. Still a salvageable series if the author writes the ending correctly, but the love triangle is awful. She should have given the main couple more development together and given the SML development outside the love triagle.

I'm No Heroine - Too much drama (including memory erasing shenanigans that made no sense) for me to not cringe. Loved the ML and FL together though, and it didn't completely ruin it.

u/ShadowStar_X — 3 months ago