
Protonated enone resonance contributors
Whilst tutoring a student, I wasn't able to give this a good explanation for this.
The question asked which is the most and which is the least significant resonance contributor among these three:
My understanding is that C contributes the most because everything has a full octet. No issue there.
But the response indicated that A is the least contributing. Is there any good reason why B is better than A? I would have guessed that it is worse because oxygen is electron withdrawing through induction. Yes, oxygen is electron donating through resonance, but I don't think it is correct to use structure C to explain why B is better. Am I just forgetting my fundamentals? Does hyperconjugation contribute?