

The most love one authors And most overrated one
The most loved one:
Gu Zhen Ren (蛊真人) — Reverend Insanity
Er Gen (耳根) — Renegade Immortal, I Shall Seal the Heavens, A Will Eternal
Cuttlefish That Loves Diving (爱潜水的乌贼) — Lord of Mysteries
Chen Dong (辰东) — Shrouding the Heavens, Perfect World
I Eat Tomatoes (我吃西红柿) — Coiling Dragon, Stellar Transformations
Wang Yu (忘语) — A Record of a Mortal’s Journey to Immortality
Tian Can Tu Dou (天蚕土豆) — Battle Through the Heavens, The Great Ruler
Fang Xiang (方想) — World of Cultivation, The Legend of the Supreme Soldier
The most overrated one:
Tian Can Tu Dou (天蚕土豆) — popular and influential, but some readers find his later stories repetitive.
I Eat Tomatoes (我吃西红柿) — hugely successful, though critics sometimes find his protagonists and progression formulas predictable.
Tang Jia San Shao (唐家三少) — extremely prolific and commercially successful, but his writing style doesn't appeal to everyone.
Er Gen (耳根) — highly respected, but some readers feel his novels can become repetitive or overly long.
Mad Snail (乱世狂刀 / various works depending on title) — sometimes criticized for pacing and formulaic elements.
Bro is so handsome that the jade beauties are dying for living with him😭🙏 Well it's not a slop novel 🐐
Does anyone know about Destiny Of Immortality ?
​
Currently on the TikTok this novel went viral. But on the web novel there is only 5 chapters.
Is that in outside of time has better romance than previous novels?
This novel is the latest novel. so I want to know. is he improved the romance in the latest novel?
For Readers Who Didn't Enjoy Er Gen's Novels: What Would You Change?
​
Er Gen is one of the most influential xianxia authors, and many readers consider his works to be among the best in the genre. However, no author is perfect, and every writer has strengths and weaknesses.
This question is especially for those who didn't enjoy his novels or felt disappointed by them.
- What aspects of his writing didn't work for you?
- What do you think he could improve?
- Was it the pacing, repetitive arcs, romance, side characters, power system, endings, or something else?
- If you could give Er Gen one piece of constructive advice, what would it be?
Please keep the discussion respectful. The goal isn't to hate on the author or his fans, but to have an honest conversation about his writing.
Constructive criticism can be just as valuable as praise. Explaining why something didn't work for you can lead to interesting discussions and help others understand different perspectives.
Whether you loved his novels, disliked them, or have mixed feelings, I'd like to hear your thoughts. What changes do you think would make Er Gen's future novels even better?