Calypso tortured Odysseus

From book 5 of the Odyssey, Everyone knows that Calypso forced Odysseus to be with her:

"the mighty slayer of Argus (Hermes) departed, and the lovely Nymph (Calypso), mindful of Zeus’ command, looked for valiant Odysseus. She found him sitting on the shore, his eyes as ever wet with tears, life’s sweetness ebbing from him in longing for his home, since the Nymph no longer pleased him. He was forced to sleep with her in the hollow cave at night, as she wished though he did not, but by day he sat among rocks or sand, tormenting himself with tears, groans and anguish, gazing with wet eyes at the restless sea."

But what a lot of people don't comment that much is that Odysseus was terrified of Calypso. Actually, in my opinion, she completely broke him; before this Odysseus was a prideful man as everyone knows, but something changes after Scylla (where he tries to fight the immortal monster against Circe words and can't, and when his men dies, he thinks that to be the most pitiful sight of his life), but especially in Calypso's Ortygia. She is forcing him to have sex, and Odysseus is terrified of her as we will see. She goes to Odysseus and say to him that he should stop crying and start building a raft to escape, but this is what he says:

"I will not trust myself to a raft when you do not wish it, unless you, goddess, give me your solemn word that you are not planning something new to harm me."

Odysseus is either acting with caution because of Calypso especifically, or because of the gods in general (earlier Hermes had told him to also be aware of Circe's schemes, for she would invite him to sex only to hurt him, and Hermes said to him that he should not refuse the sex, but first Circe had to make a oath to not hurt him). But since in that other context there was threat of violence on the part of Circe, I think there is here too: Odysseus think that Calypso will hurt him if he tries to escape, so he don't even tries unless she makes as oath to not harm him. It really remins me a little of Theon Greyjoy in Song of Ice and Fire.

Then Odysseus crafts the raft, and Calypso goes to him and tries to convince him to stay, promising him immortality with her as a god, and that she is better than Penelope. Look at Odysseus first words:

‘Great goddess, do not be angry at what I say. I know myself that wise Penelope is less than you, it’s true, in looks and stature, being a mortal, while you are immortal and ever young. Even so I yearn day after day, longing to reach home, and see the hour of my return. And if some god should strike me, out on the wine-dark sea, I will endure it, owning a heart within indured to suffering. For I have suffered much, and laboured much, in war and on the seas: add this then to the sum.’

Because she is a goddess, Odysseus cannot say that a mortal is better than her in anything, so he says thay Penelope is not as beautifil as Calypso, even through he still wants to return. But what is interesting is his first words, that Calypso should not be angry against him, as if he fears insulting her even while flattering her and she can harm him.

While in the sea, Poseidon returns from Aethiopia and is enraged that the other gods let Odysseus escape, so he summons a huge wave to destroy Odysseus raft, and while Odysseus almost drowns, Odysseus thinks: "I fear the goddess spoke true when she said I would know full measure of suffering at sea before I reached my own country: now all is coming to pass." Yep, he thinks back at Calypso, who in order to keep him with her, said he would suffer in the sea. He is almost blaming himself even through he has no blame in his current circunstance (Polyphemus was a cannibal giant and Odysseus defended himself, and Odysseus even offered a sheep to Zeus to avoid the gods' anger for hurting a son of Poseidon, but Poseidon ignored it). Like I said, Odysseus has changed from the man who shouted his name to Polyphemus, to a man who thinks that he should be dead and is to blame for everything, and he thinks of Calypso words especifically.

Leucothea, the goddess who once was the mortal Ino, has sympathy for Odysseus, so she gives him a veil and tells him to wrap the vail around his waist and abandon the raft, because he would have the strenght to swin for days without tiring until the island of the Phaeacians, and then he should return the veil to the sea. But what Odysseus thinks? : "Oh, let this not be one of the deathless ones, weaving a net for me, telling me to abandon the raft."

His spirit is so broken that he think to not trust her. He thinks is another god creating a situation for him to bring further harm to himself. After all, until this point Aeolus gave him a wing bag, he almost reached home but could not at the last moment (but Aeolus is not to blame). Later, Circe tricked the crew and tried to trick him even through they did nothing wrong. Then they were trapped in Thrinacia for one month, almost as if some god wanted them to eat Helios' cattle and perish. And of course we have Calypso, that Odysseus believed that she telling him to sail away was a trap to punish him! But since Poseidon sends another wave, Odysseus has no hope and he wrap the veil and is able to swin to the Phaeacians.

Now, in my view, Calypso kept Odysseus as a prisoner in such a way that he lost all faith that the gods except Athena could help him, believing that if a god was trying to help, it would be a trap to harm him (again, not different from Theon Greyjoy, who believes that any help offered to him is a trap to harm him). But I also understand if you think that Odysseus became such a man not because of Calypso only but simply by everything he endured plus her.

But in conclusion, Odysseus was a prideful man before Calypso who would seek the gods help all the time, but after her he became afraid of everything, of Calypso, of any gods' help, and even of escaping because what if it was another trap? No wonder when he arrived home he endured mockery and physical violence from the suitors until the end. The Odysseus from Polyphemus cave would not accept such humiliation, but this Odysseus would, because he could not accept falling in another trap again and shout his identity or commit a mistake, it was better to be cautious first. Odysseus in the storm of Poseidon prefers to suffer a little more than to imediatly accept someone offer of help and be betrayed again like so many times.

reddit.com
u/Super_Majin_Cell — 1 day ago

Zeus' thunderbolt is the most awesome thing in mythology and you can't say otherwise

Consider this post a sequel to the last one about the titans' punishments and rewards (but is not as long so don't worry), but I had to talk in its own post about how Zeus thunderbolt is meant to be a unique weapon that is outside what even the gods consider normal, and that is AWESOME. The origin of the thunderbolt is the dephts of Tartarus, a place the gods dread and fear.

The Cyclopes Arges, Brontes and Sterope not only created thunderbolts for Zeus but their very names are linked to lightning and thunder. As for their brother Briareus, his alternate name is Aegaeon, that means stormy so there is a link here. And Ouranos hated them for their power. I think is unfortunate that so many retellings of this myth has Ouranos hating them because they are "ugly", almost as if the situation is a comedy. But no, he feared what they could do.

Hesiod Theogony: "three other sons were born of Gaia and Ouranos great and doughty beyond telling, Cottus and Briareus and Gyges, presumptuous children. From their shoulders sprang an hundred arms, not to be approached, and each had fifty heads upon his shoulders on their strong limbs, and irresistible was the stubborn strength that was in their great forms. For of all the children that were born of Gaia and Ouranos, these were the most terrible, and they were hated by their own father from the first. And he used to hide them all away in a secret place of Earth so soon as each was born, and would not suffer them to come up into the light: and Ouranos rejoiced in his evil doing."

The titan children posed no threat in comparision, but according to the Orphics, Gaia gave them to Nyx to escape the evil of their father.

Orphic Fragment 129 by Otto Kern: "But from out of them all, Nyx nursed and cared for Cronus."

Cronus is tired of this so he and his mother plan Ouranos downfall. But when Cronus obtain the power, he locks his monstrous siblings again.

Apollodorus Bibliotheca: "But Gaia, grieved at the destruction of her children, who had been cast into Tartarus, persuaded the Titans to attack their father and gave Cronus an adamantine sickle. And they, all but Oceanus, attacked him, and Cronus cut off his father's genitals and threw them into the sea; and from the drops of the flowing blood were born Furies, to wit, Alecto, Tisiphone, and Megaera. And, having dethroned their father, they brought up their brethren who had been hurled down to Tartarus, and committed the sovereignty to Cronus. But he again bound and shut them up in Tartarus."

So two sky kings feared what these stormy monsters could do, why is that? Zeus, however, didn't fear them, he embraces the power of the thunderbolt. Hesiod says that Gaia had hidden the thunderbolt in Tartarus but the Cyclopes gave it to Zeus: "And they (Cyclopes) remembered to be grateful to him (Zeus) for his kindness, and gave him thunder and the glowing thunderbolt and lightening: for before that, huge Gaia had hidden these. In them Zeus trusts and rules over mortals and immortals."

But did you know that there was another being that also used the thunderbolt? It was Campe, a monstrous nymph of Tartarus (AND I COMPLETELY FORGOT TO MENTION HER IN MY LAST POST NOOOOO). She guarded the Cyclopes and Hecatoncheries for Cronus, and the book Dionysiaca has her in another role, as a monstrous being that embodied the Thunderbolt and ravaged the Earth when she wanted.

Nonnus' Dionysiaca: "Such was manifoldshaped Campe as she rose writhing, and flew roaming about earth and air and briny deep, and flapping a couple of dusky wings, rousing tempests and arming gales, that blackwinged nymph of Tartarus: from her eyelids a flickering flame belched out far-travelling sparks. Yet heavenly Zeus your father killed that great monster, and conquered the snaky Enyo (war-goddess) of Cronus."

So you can see the difference between Cronus and Zeus. Zeus will use the power of the thunderbolt to estabilish order, but Cronus would let a mad monster use the thunderbolt to destroy everything in her path with no rhyme or reason, and remember, Cronus feared the Cyclopes and Hecatoncheries, is very likely that he feared Campe as well, this is why he let her do as she pleases. So Zeus is different from the two earlier kings. They feared the thunderbolt above all else, because it was a thing from Tartarus, the realm most feared by the gods. But Zeus unites Tartarus with the Sky: he is a Sky God that uses the thunderbolt that originated from Tartarus itself.

The thunderbolt symbolizes Zeus victory over the titans. Not only he used it to defeat all of his enemies, but when Zeus thunders on high, he scares the Titans, Typhon and the Giants.

Statius Thebaid: "The heavenly palace itself thunders [through Zeus], though no sign is given, the clouds themselves gather an the storms collect without the blast of any wind: one would think Iapetus had burst his Stygian chains."

Homer's Iliad: "The Greeks marched on, like a fire sweeping the earth, and the ground shook beneath them, as when Zeus the Thunderer in anger lashes the land of the Arimi, where they say Typhon lies prostrate."

Even Oceanus and river gods who usually supports Zeus, if they try to do anything funny, backs off because of Zeus' thunderbolt.

Homer's Iliad: "Not even (the river) Achelous vies with Zeus or the mighty and deep-flowing Oceanus, source of the rivers and the sea, the springs and the deep wells: even he fears Zeus’ lightning, when dread thunder crashes from the sky."

When Helios refused to return to his duties after Phaethon death, what forced him to return? Lucian Dialogues:

"HELIOS But he (Phaethon) has suffered for it, and my grief is punishment enough for me, Zeus.

ZEUS Punishment enough, indeed! After daring to do such a thing as that! Well, I forgive you this time. But if ever you transgress again, or send another substitute like him, I will show you how much hotter the thunderbolt is than your fire."

The thunderbolt is the titan's boogeyman. Imagine you being a child river god leaving the school and then yoy hear the thunderbolt? You would cry for your life because you will not want to see Zeus anger. This is a weapon only Zeus has, that Cronus and Ouranos foolish feared and tried to seal away instead of using its potential (or in the case of Cronus, he foolish let Campe go around destroying everything with the thunderbolt instead of using it with a higher purpose).

OBS: I use the Hades games illustrations a lot for these posts. That is because after Disney Hercules, these are my favorite depictions of the gods with some exceptions. I even like his hair here that looks like clouds so it justifie the white hair instead of the black.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 4 days ago

A list of every Titan God's punishment and reward

Most people think that gods are either Olympians or Titans, but that is completely innacurate. Olympians and Titans are gods that share domain of Heaven and Earth (because their ancestor in common is Ouranos and Gaia), so this is why they fought for the throne of Heaven, but there is other types of gods (I will not explain the Primordials since their existence is essential to the world in a a different way to the other gods):

Sea gods, born of Pontus and Gaia, are confined to the sea, who in mythology is a inferior domain: sea gods just obey the titan or olympian ruler assigned to them, so they don't even need to pick a side (but some did). The Underworld is populated by Daimons, lesser divinities that are children of Nyx. Not all Daimons are of Nyx descent, a lot are born from other gods so these live in other places, but the ones born from Nyx are in the Underworld. And just like the sea gods, they are not relevant for the conflict between Heaven and Earth, they just obey the Titan/Olympian ruler assigned to them.

Titans: the only Titans that needed to be sent to Tartarus are the ones that can be a violent threat to Zeus and have no other place to be in the world except Tartarus. If they ruled in Heaven, they had to be cast down to Tartarus, the opposite of Heaven, and this apply specially to Cronus, Iapetus, Coeus, Crius and Hyperion, who ruled Heaven before the Olympians. But other gods don't needed to be imprisoned in Tartarus depending on their level of threat and obedience, they could be imprisoned in other places, lost privileges but remain free, or just accept Zeus' rule and be fine.

Cronus and Iapetus: these two are the titans that were imprisoned in Tartarus in basically all sources with some two or three exceptions that situates Cronus in other places.

Coeus: greek sources don't mention him after the Titanomachy except as the father of Leto and Asteria. But roman sources do mention him imprisoned in Tartarus.

Menoetius: a son of Iapetus, he was sent to Erebus according to Hesiod, but Tartarus according to the Bibliotheca.

Crius and Hyperion: likely in Tartarus, altrough no surviving source say so.

Pallas: the second son of Crius, likely in Tartarus, but no surviving source says so. He was usually confused as the giant Pallas defeated and skinned alive by Athena later.

Arke: a winged sea goddess born of Thaumas, and she was Iris' sister. Iris was a messenger to the Olympians while Arke helped the Titans. Zeus took out her wings and sent her to Tartarus.

Aegaeon: a sea god, son of Gaia and Pontus, that supported the Titans and was buried by Poseidon under the island of Euboea.

Telchines: either sea goddesses, or children of Tartarus and Nemesis. According to Callimachus, they were buried under islands by Poseidon. Pindar says that they were only punished in a later context, as they made magical poison to afflict other beings, so Zeus sent them to Tartarus.

Regarding these sea gods: Aegaeon (not to be confused with Briareus), the Telchines, Arke and Iris are the only sea gods to have participated in the conflict, and as I said before, sea gods didn't need to fight anyway. I believe they fought to raise their position and gain favors from the winner, and this worked, as Iris was raised by Zeus from a sea goddess to the messenger of the gods and goddess of the rainbow. But Aegaeon, the Telchines and Arke, who were on the losing side, were punished in the sea because they were sea deities, but Arke was buried in Tartarus likely because she can also be considered a sky deity, so Tartarus it is, the inverse of the sky.

Atlas: back to the titans again. Atlas was punished for fighting in the Titanomachy against Zeus. But the Fabulae mentions a Orphic variant: only Cronus was punished at first, so later Atlas lead the titans against Zeus to restore Cronus to power, but he lost and had to hold the sky.

Perses and Asteria: Perses was the third son of Crius. Asteria was daughter of Coeus and wife of Perses. Perses would likely be in Tartarus... if it was not for Mousaios that says that Zeus is the real father of Hecate with Asteria, but then Zeus gave Hecate to Perses to raise as his daughter. So in this version, Perses is a servant of Zeus instead of being anywhere else. But in Hesiod is a different story. Hecate here is a daughter of Perses and Asteria (like most versions), but she had a share of the sky, earth and underworld during Cronus age, and Zeus kept all that for her. So I am less sure of Perses in Hesiod's Theogony, he likely was imprisoned in Tartarus. As for Asteria, she remained free so she was either not important, or supported Zeus side, but later she escaped from Zeus lust and metamorphosed into the island of Delos, and she helped her sister Leto give birth to Apollo and Artemis there.

Astraeus: Astraeus is the firstborn son of Crius. Nonnus wrote that Astraeus was a old enemy of Zeus, but also has him appear as a prophetic god living in the twilight region. I believe thus that his situation is similar to Gaia and Ouranos: he was not imprisoned, just lost some of his glory over time and became a prophetic god to help younger deities.

Typhon, Echidna and Giants: they were not titans and fought Zeus as a reaction to the Titanomachy, but were not part of it. Typhon was imprisoned in Tartarus under mount Aetna, everyone knows this. As for these earlier giants that attacked Zeus, their king was Ophion according to the d scholia to the Iliad, but they lost and were imprisoned in Tartarus, and Zeus made Cronus the king of the giants in Tartarus. This Ophion also appears in another context. He and his wife Eurynome were the first rulers of Heaven, but Cronus and Rhea defeated them, Ophion was thrown either in Tartarus or Oceanus, while Eurynome was imprisoned in Tartarus. Echidna, the wife of Typhon, was either assigned to a underground location or Tartarus if she is immortal; or otherwise she was a mortal monster and thus killed by Apollo later.

TITAN GODS WHO SUPPORTED ZEUS I talked about every enemy of Zeus, including giants and monsters, or that are in a tricky position (Astraeus), or that maybe changed sides but is not clear (Perses). Now for the other ones that supported Zeus from the beginning, or we are sure of when they switched sides.

Oceanus, Tethys, Metis, Styx (and her four children): all of these gods supported Zeus. Oceanus didn't helped Cronus overthrown Ouranos like the other titans. So the domain of Oceanus and Tethys were lower to that of Cronus and Rhea (according to the orphics). Ocean gave his support to Zeus by sending Styx and her children to his side. Metis also helped Zeus by giving him a regurgitant that made Cronus vomit his children. But Oceanus likely didn't helped all that much himself since he was kept in the same position as before. But Styx and Metis were raised to a more powerful position: Metis became the first queen of the gods and she shares Zeus' wisdom quite literaly. Styx became the goddess of Oaths and was given one tenth of Oceanus' waters to rule in the Underworld; and Styx's four children became the gods most close to Zeus' throne and his personal guardians.

Four Winds, Harpies, Xanthus and Balius: The four winds are sons of Astraeus and Eos, while Xanthus and Balius are immortal horses born of Zephyrus and Podarge the Harpy. Diodorus Siculus wrote that Xanthus and Balius were born as gods, but they betrayed the titans to join the Olympians but were ashamed, so they asked Zeus and Poseidon to turn them into horses so the titans could not recognize them, and this was granted to them. So these sons of Zephyrus and Podarge were on the side of the titans originally as if the family of Crius supporting the titans is to be expected. But we know the four winds and the four Harpies are definility on the side of Zeus too, since the winds continued freed with their own domains and even pulled Zeus chariot in horse form. While the Harpies are monstrous winds that serve Zeus.

Iris and Hecate: I already talked about these two, but they supported Zeus and either kept their privilege (Hecate) or were even raised to a higher position than the one they had before (Iris).

Leto: remained free but we don't much about her in these earlier times, but contrary to her sister Asteria that turned into a island, Leto became a respected goddess in the Olympian order by becoming the mother of Apollo and Artemis with Zeus.

Helios, Selene and Eos: Diodorus Siculus says that Zeus before going to war made offerings to the Sky, Earth and Sun to gain their help. That Ouranos and Gaia supported Zeus we know from Hesiod's Theogony. But this text also explains how Helios became Zeus supporter. Pindar wrote that Helios would have taken a share of the world when the world was being divided, but he arrived late and was content with just receiving the island of Rhodes. As for Selene and Eos, they are show fighting against the giants here and there, and everything suggest they didn't lost anything with Zeus rule.

Cyclopes and Hecatoncheiries: Cronus would gain their support if he was not stupid and imprisoned them again after freeing them. Is very likely that he did this because the Cyclopes could forge weapons and the Hecatoncheries could give their strenght to Cronus enemies, but no reason is ever given. Zeus helped them and they did exactly that, they forged the olympians' weapons and the Hecatoncheries helped them defeat the titans. But they continued living close to Tartarus regardless: the Cyclopes received forges while Cottus and Gyges would each guard one of the doors of Tartarus, but Briareus received the bottom of the Aegean Sea, where he married a daughter of Poseidon and he became Zeus personal guard in case other gods rebel against him.

Rhea, Themis, Mnemosyne, Theia and Phoebe: the first two obviously supported Zeus from the beginning and gained positions of privilege, as Rhea was the reason he escaped Cronus hands. Rhea lives in Olympus but also received some things to rule over. Themis teached Zeus law before the war. She became one of Zeus wives, the mother of several important goddesses, and became the deity of laws. No source says who Mnemosyne, Theia and Phoebe supported, but they still had some privilege even in Zeus rule: Mnemosyne resides in Boetia and was the mother of the Muses by Zeus; Theia resides in the East where Helios rules; Phoebe resides in Delphi. Is interesting that these goddesses continued freed, but they also lost something. Rhea has her privileges, but the real queen now is Hera; and both Phoebe and Themis lost of some of their prophetic authority to Apollo, altrough with their consent.

Prometheus and Epimetheus: Prometheus was the herald of the titans at first, but Prometheus, according to himself (in the play by Aeschylus), says that he supported Cronus until Themis (who always supported Zeus) said to him that the Titans would lose because they only used brute force. Prometheus tried to convince them to change, but they didn't, so he fled to Zeus side. Epimetheus likely joined him, since both remained unpunished, until later that is, for Prometheus is chained and has his liver devoured by a eagle until Heracles sets him free; while Epimetheus receives Pandora as his wife and he dooms mankind when she opens the jar of evils.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 6 days ago

Why is only Selene erased in favour of Artemis, but not Hecate?

This is a genuine question to people who know more about this topic regarding Diana. I am not asking about what the greeks and romans actual believed since polytheists syncretize gods all the time, but just the modern interpretation of these gods, where Selene is the one that loses the most. I saw a post earlier about this (about the """triple-goddess""") and it lead me to this want to know about this.

Basically, with exception of the franchise Hades (that I can think of now), people are familiar with the syncretism between these goddesses but they always use that to justifie Selene/Luna removal, but not Hecate (just to make my point clear I don't want any deity to be removed, Hecate is very cool). So for example, who knows what Selene is doing in Percy Jackson and Blood of Zeus, but both have Artemis and Hecate just fine; in Blood of Zeus Artemis is the moon goddess, while Hecate from what I saw don't seem to share the moon atributes, but she is there. In Disney Hercules Artemis has a moon crest (but nothing more related to the moon), Hecate is there but not with moon atributes, and Selene? Who knows...

Then, even outside media depictions, just in general conversations around people will often say "bruh who cares, Selene was replaced/absorbed by Artemis just deal with it", but they never apply this rule to Hecate, even through it falls all in the same logic, a lot of authors would confuse the parentage of all three, connect Iphigenia with both Artemis and Hecate, have Diana as a name of any of the three, etc.

But with very few exceptions, people use this to remove Selene from their stories or summaries of the myths, but not Hecate. Is because you need to have a goddess of magic? Well there is a lot more goddesses of magic, so why not remove or syncretize some of them, because is not cool to remove deities? But then why is fine to not have Selene? Is because Hecate is cool and strange? Well so is Selene with her bull horns and her magical blood. Is because Selene don't has many myths and is mostly a cameo in other stories? Well guess what about Hecate... But what are your views on it.

reddit.com
u/Super_Majin_Cell — 7 days ago

Gods with similar domains that are misunderstood today

I will not talk about Helios and Apollo and Selene and Artemis since I talked a lot about them in the past. But about other gods who have a similar thing going on regarding similar domains.

Oceanus and Poseidon: A lot of people today makes Oceanus a replaced titan. Even Percy Jackson, where Oceanus didn't supported Cronus, for some reason supports him in the present? The thing about these two is that their domains were completely different. Oceanus was the world encircling river, he was related to fresh water, the limits of the world, and the cycle of the stars that arose from his waters. Later writers knew the world to be round so they named the open salt seas as Oceanus because it was still the same waters as Oceanus, just more scientific accurate. In Ovid, Oceanus is the salt seas and he receives Neptune in his palace. So this god was never considered a past/replaced god. Actually the real syncretism was between Oceanus and Pontus (Sea).

Chronos and Cronus: this might be the most popular case of a god being absorbed by another god. Cronus, the father of Zeus, was the king of sky before becoming a Underworld god (ruler of the titans of Tartarus; ward of Elysium; or even god of reincarnation), with some agriculture aspects like his scythe altrough this aspect is not expanded in myth. Cicero is the only ancient famous writer to say that Saturn in greek is Cronus, "time", confusing his name with Chronos, the real world for time. But what he meant by that is that Cronus, by dominating Ouranos, estabilished the cycle of the stars, turning the sky into a giant clock to mark time (a thing we don't even realise since we can barely see the stars in the night sky). But today, people give him time powers and refer to time as his main thing, with Hades II being the main example, literaly calling him Chronos and time personified. The original Chronos was a primordial time serpent that is a ancestor of the titan god Cronus in Orphism (Chronos>Phanes>Nyx>Ouranos>Cronus), not the same as him.

Themis and Dike: these goddesses do similar things, all related to justice. Dike was Justice itself, daughter of Zeus and Themis, but she is non-existent today as people often refer to Themis as "lady Justice" and don't even know the role the daughter of Zeus played. But even Themis gets sidelined in favour of Nemesis, who is quite popular today more than she was in the past.

Cyclops and Hephaestus: there is a bizarre story where Zeus kills the Cyclops to have the thunderbolt just for himself, and another similar story where Apollo kills them, even through they are supposed to be imortal, so Pherycedes explained that their mortal sons were killed instead. And a few times, like in Percy Jackson, they use this to justifie how Hapheastus took over the business of making thunderbolts, but then Riordan has other cyclops helping Hephaestus anyway? I don't see the point in removing these cyclops but then have other cyclops helping. Now, I don't remember any myth where Hephaestus or Vulcan forges Zeus bolts, definility never with Hephaestus. The Cyclops were not associated with him until some time later, were they started working on the same forge, but they each had their role, with Hephaestus not making the bolts. But modern media often removes or even villanizes the Cyclops and has Hephaestus just make everything for the gods.

Rhea, Hera, Eileithya, Artemis and Selene: all of these goddesses had a thing in common: childbirth. Now, I never saw any media that depicts a goddess in this role, but usually in discussions, I have see people have a hard time trying to understand these goddesses, often believing that Rhea retired or things like that. And this is not because they want to reduce gods in their own projects, is just a thing they arrive naturally, as if gods can't share domains. As for Rhea I have seem some people even say she was trapped in Tartarus? How they dare to say that? Once again titan prejudice attacks, putting everyone in Tartarus.

Athena and Ares: I left the best for last. This is the only case were two greek gods with similar domains were able to survive intact in modern culture. As a result, there is so much discussion trying to find differences between the two. But there is not any... the Homeric Hymm to Athena says that she "delights in the works of Ares", and loves bloodshed and the cries of war. She is not the goddess of war strategy exclusivily, the side of Ares also had strategy. She was not the goddess of defensive war, or of "good war" (whanever that means), or of kings while Ares represents soldiers. They literaly shared all domains when is about war. The Iliad does make Ares weaker and dumber, but everything else has Ares as a respected war god of victory and courage (just like Athena and Zeus too), and even fighting with Athena to a tie, with Zeus having to intervene. The only thing that differentiate these two is that war have at least two sides, and it would be weird for one god to support both sides, so poetry will make Athena and Ares often clash because each support opposing sides, but that is it, but people can't accept that, they want to make both different to justifie their inclusion, instead of just having both? And the same applies to every god I cited above.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 9 days ago

The most underrated daughter of Zeus

Who do you think is the most underrated daughter of Zeus? Is Athena, Persephone, Artemis, Aphrodite, Calliope?

Well, I think it is JUSTICE. Yes, Justice herself is a daughter of Zeus. Her greek name is Dike, but by saying Justice you will understand her idea better. She is part of the Horae, daughters of Zeus and Themis. But while the other daughters of Zeus do their own thing, Justice is especifically connected to Zeus in a fundamental level. This is what Hesiod tells about her:

"And there is virgin Justice, the daughter of Zeus, who is honoured and reverenced among the gods who dwell on Olympus, and whenever anyone hurts her with lying slander, she sits beside her father, Zeus the son of Cronos, and tells him of men's wicked heart, until the people pay for the mad folly of their princes who, evilly minded, pervert judgement and give sentence crookedly. Keep watch against this, you princes, and make straight your judgements, you who devour bribes; put crooked judgements altogether from your thoughts... For whoever knows the right and is ready to speak it, far-seeing Zeus gives him prosperity; but whoever deliberately lies in his witness and forswears himself, and so hurts Justice and sins beyond repair, that man's generation is left obscure thereafter."

So she is literaly Zeus most protected daughter. When someones commits injustice, it hurts her, so she goes to Zeus to say to her father that people have hurt her, and Zeus then smith the evil doers. And Zeus is the father you don't want to mess with. Honestly, the way people talk about Athena and Zeus actually apply to Justice and Zeus, Zeus hates seeing his dear daughter hurt.

Also, the idea that Justice is the daughter of Zeus is a concept modern society can't even accept because you know how they treat this situation. But yes, no Justice existed before Zeus, this is what the mythology says. Zeus had a daughter whose role is to keep watch on humanity to report their evil deeds, and this is what allows Zeus to destroy the wicked. So why underrated? Well she is often conflated with her mother Themis today and ceases to exist as result, and Zeus usually uses other gods or he watches things himself, instead of his daughter doing this job for him. Heck even Themis herself barely appears in modern adaptations even through she was immensely important, so imagine her daughter.

This is what bothers me a lot. People only reuses the same 10 gods, reuses the same tropes (how many times we have to see again Arachne and Medusa to show that Athena is super duper evil?), and then uses these few gods and few tropes to say all the gods are bad and evil, but ignore goddesses such as Justice herself, because even if you want to think some Olympians are bad, there a hundred more gods that are definility good and chill and could be explored in interesting ways. Well Justice is not chill since she wants all evil doers destroyed, but well, that is impartial Justice.

reddit.com
u/Super_Majin_Cell — 12 days ago

I need your headcanon about these background gods in Hercules

I will make a post about the gods and monsters family tree but using the characters from Hercules movie and cartoon. There is a lot of background gods in the movie, a lot of which was already identified by a lot of people so they are not here in this post. These gods don't have names but the artists had to taken to inspiration from somewhere. So why not use headcanon to find these gods anyway?

As for my own opinion, the first god I think should be Hypnos, and the second I think is Selene, because she is close to Artemis on this part of the movie besides having his silvery glow. But you can give our opinion. But the god can't be one that are named and are actual in the show or movie obviously. They can't be Primordials either because Gaia appears and so we have an idea of how they should look in this universe, and is not human-sized.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 15 days ago

A desing choice that I like here

Is not about the color choosen for them. Their color being purple still don't fit them, and is not like they could not be completely golden since Hera and Aphrodite are completely pink, both the color of their skin and their clothes.

So in my last posts about Helios, some people brought up that Helios do in fact appear in Disney Hercules. I decided to watch werothegreat "Which Gods are in Hercules" video, and they also come to the conclusion that Helios is this background god. And yes it can only be him, altrough Apollo is quite explicity the sun god in this universe, the very first episode of the tv show is even a parody of the Phaethon story but with Apollo.

But there is a design choice that I really like here (and also in Red's drawings of Helios and Apollo in her videos in Overly Sarcastic Productions), and that is Helios having the sun crown in his head, while Apollo has the sun symbol in his clothes. This gives the idea that Apollo canalizes the sun energy without being the sun himself, and it also don't replace Apollo laurel crown with the sun crown as his main symbol (altrough in Disney he has a helmet for some reason).

So Helios in greek mythology is the god with the sun crown, while Apollo uses golden clothes and has other golden imagenary, clearly a sun association, but he don't need to replace (how much I dislike this word in this context!) Helios to have these associations like so many modern adaptations tries to do. Actually in the future I have to make a post about other gods that share domains but are also misunderstood today because some authors are obessed with the idea that there can be only one god of anything.

As for Disney Hercules. Altrough I would prefer Helios to be the god in the Phaethon episode, or at least be named (instead of just being on the background unnamed like many others), is cool to see him coexisting with Apollo instead of being replaced, dead or non-existent, but both being chill in the present. And as for the desing I already talked about it. But yeah until recently I never realised the many gods in the background in the first scene, so that is cool, I had never paid any attention to them.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 16 days ago

Odysseus didn't suffer alone

Since the Odyssey is the most famous part, a lot of people think only Odysseus suffered. But most greek leaders were screwed during their Return. After the greeks burned Troy and divided the spoils among themselves, they quickly realised that Athena was wrathful, so Agamemnon and Menelaus started a fight but Agamemnon decided to stay to make a offering to the gods. Nestor, Diomedes and Menelaus went first, but only Nestor would arrive quickly in his home. After that the second voyage had Calchas, Amphilochus, Leonteus and a few more, some returned, others got lost and died.

Then the third voyage included everyone else, and there it was, Ajax the Lesser. Athena threw a freaking thunderbolt at his ship and sent a storm to punish all the greeks, this storm even caught Menelaus who had sailed earlier and he lost a bunch of ships and got trapped in Egypt with Helen. Ajax said not even the gods could kill him so Poseidon finished the job by destroying the rock where he was. Agamemnon according to Diodorus Siculus lost four ships, Odysseus fleet ended up in Ismarus and almost all of the other greek leaders ended up in several locations like Lybia, Cyprus and Italy and other lands, and they never returned, but had to conquer these places and estabilished themselves there.

Teucer returned but his father Telamon banished him since he didn't stopped his brother Ajax the Great (this is not the same Ajax that I mentioned earlier) suicide, so Teucer ended up in Cyprus. Very unfair since how could he stop his brother from killing himself?

The most difficult part of this meme was to decide how to make Odysseus and Menelaus because I wanted to insert both. Odysseus returned after 10 years without his crew and killed a bunch of suitors and had to be tricked by Penelope to reunite with her. Menelaus, however, stayed in Egypt for 8 years with Helen because of the winds, he caught the sea god Proteus who revealed to him the fate of other characters, and then allowed him to finally sail to Sparta.

Then we have the topic of wives. Like, Penelope is meant to be exceptional in the Odyssey, not the norm. The book mentions Clytemnestra as her opposite but not other wives. Diomedes wife Aegiale betrayed him (because Aphrodite wanted revenge against Diomedes) and then banished him. Idomeneus (my last post about Talos also covered him) was similary banished. While Agamemnon was imediatly killed by his wife and her lover Aegisthus. So Odysseus return was not as bad as most of these other heroes in my opinion.

The Returns of the achaean leaders is among my favorite parts of the greek mythology, for it you have to read Proclus Summary of the Returns, Apollodorus Bibliotheca Epitome, and Tzetzes on Lycophron, for the full thing, plus some other sources. The greeks were victorious in the trojan war but they would not get out scott free for their crimes, and in the end the war was completely hollow since most of them either died with their lineage or had to live without seeing their homes again. Others were killed or exiled imediatly after their return. So yeah, the very bleak ending of the heroic saga.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 18 days ago

Talos had a son!

In the endless pursuit of every single story about greek mythology, sometimes I find things that I didn't even think was possible. One of them is that Talos had a son!

The guy is called Leucus, and the story only exist in Tzetzes scholia on Lycophron. He is also mentioned by the Bibliotheca, but not as a son of Talos, just as a random person. Leucus was adopted by Idomeneus, the king of Crete and grandson of king Minos (maybe because Talos was dead? Talos is defeated by the Argonauts during the reing of king Deucalion, son of Minos). Idomeneus also promised that Leucus would marry his daughter Cleisithera after Idomeneus returned from the Trojan War.

During the war, Nauplius decided to avenge the death of Palamedes by Odysseus. So he united the wives of some kings with suitors. In Crete, Leucus married Meda, wife of Idomeneus. But Leucus then killed Meda and all of Idomeneus children (including Cleisisthera his bribe), and took the island for himself and destroyed ten cities that rebelled. When Idomeneus returned, Leucus banished him, and that is it for Idomeneus, who died exiled from his island by his adopted son.

According to other sources Idomeneus returned home safely. But in this version about Leucus, this is where Crete ends in greek mythology. The lineage of Minos is destroyed, ten cretan cities are destroyed, and Leucus continued to rule until his death apperantly.

But what is most interesting is how Leucus is the son of Talos, the bronze giant as described by Tzetzes (so is not another Talos in case you are wondering). The Bibliotheca when mentioning Talos said he was either a automaton made by Hephaestus, or the last man of the bronze race (who here is interpreted as men made of literal bronze!). If we interpret Talos only as Hephaestus automanon, then he was somehow able to reproduce, but that is one of the greek mythology mysteries.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 19 days ago

You can't do anything without the help of the gods

I think one of the biggest problems in how modern society view greek gods (and gods from any other mythology and religion) is that they view gods as magic users who intervenes in parallel with nature, and that the gods usually intervene to screw with mortals but rarely to help them.

But gods are not magic users twisting nature to their purposes. They are the source of everything. There is two examples that I seen more often being discussed: Aphrodite and Helen, and Apollo and Paris. Usually people say thay Helen was magically induced by Aphrodite to fall in love with Paris. But this is not how it works, because Aphrodite unites everyone in love, EVEN ZEUS HIMSELF:

"But of all others there is nothing among the blessed gods or among mortal men that has escaped Aphrodite. Even the heart of Zeus, who delights in thunder, is led astray by her; though he is greatest of all and has the lot of highest majesty, she beguiles even his wise heart whensoever she pleases, and mates him with mortal women, unknown to Hera, his sister and his wife, the grandest far in beauty among the deathless goddesses." First Homeric Hymm to Aphrodite.

Aphrodite is the one given the lot of uniting everyone. And she don't care if people are married or not, for example, according to a story recorded in Hesiod's Fragments, Aphrodite decided to punish Tyndareus for failing to worship her, by making all of his daughters unfaithful to their husbands (Clytemnestra, Timandra and Helen). So if Aphrodite desires, she can disrupt the marriages she herself estabilished as punishment. Aphrodite also don't care if one don't want to have sex, like Hippolytus, who made a vow to Artemis to be forever a virgin, and since he resisted Aphrodite, she decided to make his step-mother Phaedra fall in love with him. In Nonnus Dionysiaca, there is a short tale where Aphrodite decides to weave, and neglect her original work, and the entire world stopping feeling sexual desire, even animals and gods. Had she not returned to her duties the world would perish.

As for Paris killing Achilles with Apollo's help, a lot of people say Paris only accomplished this because the god helped... but that is the point of these stories! You can't be a archer without being blessed by the likes of Apollo and Artemis. Perseus can't kill Medusa without Athena and Hermes guiding Perseus hand until the very moment. Odysseus can't return home despite Poseidon without the aproval of Zeus and the other gods. You can't take the walls of Troy without aproval (Patroclus and Achilles tried at different moments to enter Troy only to die by Apollo intervention; but Epeius and Odysseus had sucess with the trojan horse when Athena gave her aproval). You can't claim your ability don't comes from the gods (Arachne) or that you can live despite the gods (Ajax the Lesser) or that you can conquer a city even if Zeus himself opposes it (Capaneus).

Mortals who try to do things against the wishes of the gods revealed in oracles; or mortals who claim to do things by themselves, without the gods, are hubristic, this is what hubris is. Without Apollo, or Athena, or any other god, no one would be able to do anything, because these gods inspire mortals. Pious mortals like Perseus, Hector and Odysseus are considered beloved by the gods because they don't challenge the gods. Hubristic mortals are hated by the gods and are a cautionary tale to not repeat the same mistake, because mortals can't rise above their station.

In modern media, the gods opposition to certain heroes is kept, but not their help. No wonder people tend to think they are a bunch of assholes, since their help to the heroes is often removed. As for the other thing I said, Zeus causes every rain, Aphrodite causes desire in everything, Poseidon decides what happens to every single ship, Apollo and Artemis blesses every archer, etc.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 20 days ago

Crius just wants to chill

There is one billion gods and heroes that we know nothing about so Crius is not the only one. But for such a earlier figure, is bothers me so such he don't do anything aaaaa.

The lame answer is: "dude these titan gods are just genealogical links, get over it", but the cool answer is trying to think where they come from. A lot of these figures just survives in patronymic contexts. For example Cronus has a lot about him, but even if we had nothing he would still appear a lot just for being the father of Zeus, Poseidon and Hera who are called son of Cronus/daughter of Cronus all the time. In a similar manner, Hyperion is usually named in connection with Helios and Coeus with Leto, and Iapetus with Prometheus and Atlas.

But Hyperion is a allie of Cronus and he is also a name for the greek Sun God. Iapetus is named as a allie of Cronus quite often and his name is sinonymous with the titanomachy. Coeus like Iapetus is said to be imprisoned in Tartarus in sources here and there, and Ovid actually notices how Coeus is a nobody so even that is something.

But Crius? He don't even appear in a patronymic context, because his sons Atreus, Pallas and Perses are also obscure figures, so is rare to see them and even more rare to see they being named as son of Crius. He don't appear in any other context except as the name of a village Pausanias visited and believe to be in honor of Crius. The Bibliotheca says that all Cronus brothers except Oceanus helped him defeat Ouranos so that is something.

Crius name can also mean Ram, and since his descendants include wind and star gods, and also the goddess Hecate, he maybe be connected to the constelation of the Ram, but who knows. Percy Jackson makes him a god connected to stars, while Hercules Legendary Journeys connect him to winds because who knows? He is a jack of all trades at this point.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 23 days ago

Modern media depictions of Helios and Apollo; this post is not meant as a tierlist

I decided to look the media where Helios and Apollo appear and separate them on how they choose to depict these two (the post is not meant to be a tierlist, I just had no idea what other graphic to use). Now, there is way more greek mythology adaptations that is not included either because I don't remember, I don't know or because it don't feature these two. Or it may feature Apollo as a background character but is not clear if he meant to be the sun god or not.

In Percy Jackson, Helios was technically not imprisoned by anyone, but he is confined to a place he can't leave. What is that if not a prison? And Blood of Zeus, Lore Olympus and Hercules Legendary Journeys depict Helios as a defeated titan god. That is pure titan prejudice, since Helios was one of the allies of Zeus, but just because he is a titan people put him in Tartarus. Heck Blood of Zeus even include Themis and Mnemosyne in Tartarus. You know, Justice and Memory? I think that whenever someone tries to adapt the titan gods they never do their research. Even Percy Jackson who is more accurate than most things insist that titans are not gods for example.

As for the media on the middle, they are right too, since when ancient authors talked about Apollo as the sun, he was meant to be the sun since always, not a god that replaced another, altrough this does leads to a chronological problem if your gods are meant to be more physical instead of philosophical. And it also leads to Apollo losing his chariot pulled by griffins.

But now I see how sad I am when is about me with modern media of mythology. Because Helios was always my favorite god but I never cared or even realised this whole thing about the two. But today I get immensely frustrated when Helios is relegated to the margins of myth in a adaptation (Selene too, altrough I don't see Artemis as the moon goddess as often as Apollo is the sun god, Selene appears even less than Helios but at the same time Artemis as a huntress goddess is above her status as a moon goddess in people's minds. Just look at Disney Hercules and Hades for example, in the first Artemis is not once said to be a moon goddess even through there is no Selene, while in the second she and Selene are different enough, while Apollo and Helios overlap so there was no need for the two in the same game. Same goes for Gow, where Helios is the sun god, but weapons and items involving Apollo is about fire or light so they were too close in overlapping, while Artemis is just a huntress goddess in Gow).

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 26 days ago

The main villains are the first to be defeated

One thing that often happens in greek mythology is for the main villain to be defeated first and then be replaced by another villain or by his entire group, and I can think of four examples. One is Paris. He was killed by Philoctetes even before the trojan horse was built. Then his even worse brother Deiphobus became the villain in his place (while Helen loved Paris, she was forced to marry Deiphobus, who Quintus Smyrnaeus described as woman-obsessed), and Deiphobus was the last kill of the trojan war, killed by Menelaus, who killed him while Deiphobus was drunk and Menelaus wished he was killing Paris instead.

Another example is Antinous, the more loud of the suitor and the one with the plan to kill Telemachus, and the first to be killed by Odysseus... With the last enemy being Melanthius, one of Odysseus' slaves who took the side of the suitors.

Another example are Porphyrion and Alcyoneus, the kings of the Giants, and by the way that is told in the Bibliotheca, the first giants to be defeated. Later Heracles had to defeat the other remaining giants with the help of the gods.

Another example is the centauromachy described by Ovid. Where the worst centaur who started the whole mess, Eurytus, is the first to be killed by Pirithous, and the other centaurs have to be dealt with later.

Now if you know of more examples, please tell in the comments. And I think there is one more example, but is not as explicit as the cases above, and that is Cronus, but only in Hesiod Theogony, and the Orphics.

Now, according to Hesiod Theogony, Zeus defeated Cronus in the following manner: "great Cronus the wily was beguiled by the deep suggestions of Gaia, and brought up again his offspring, vanquished by the arts and might of his own son." So Gaia did something to help Zeus, while Zeus "vanquished" Cronus to free his siblings that had been swallowed by Cronus. And that is it, this is the last moment we see of Cronus in Hesiod Theogony. He is only named later with the titans imprisoned in Tartarus while Zeus fights Typhon.

In Orphism, Cronus is definility the first to be defeated. Zeus with the help of Nyx gives Cronus a potion that makes him regurgitate his siblings, and then he castrates Cronus (just like Cronus did with Ouranos) and throws Cronus into Tartarus. Later the Titans try to attack Zeus and baby Zagreus/Dionysus and Zeus destroys them with his thunderbolt.

Returning to Hesiod. If we suppose Cronus was defeated in the moment Zeus rescued his siblings, then who was the leader of the titans in his place? It was either Iapetus or Atlas. In Orphism above, it was definility Atlas as said by the Fabulae of "Hyginus". But Iapetus can be a candidate too. This titan god is often synonymous with the titan war as a whole (I already made a post about this once so I will avoid repeat here the things I already said), in Nonnus Dionysiaca, Zeus will name either Cronus or Iapetus as his greatest foes. And while Crius, Hyperion and Coeus are never mentioned again or only appear in specific circunstances, Iapetus appears often on the side of Cronus (Hesiod ask the Muse to sing about many things, including Iapetus and Cronus; and the Iliad names only these two in Tartarus, almost as if they are inseparable brothers, or Iapetus was Cronus right hand man).

Originally this post was gonna be only about Cronus, but since Apollodorus Bibliotheca and Aeschylus names Cronus as the king of the titans in the war itself, I realise this is not a strong argument as I first believed, since this only apply to the Orphics, and as I argue, maybe Hesiod, and maybe some lost work about the Titanomachy for the importance of Iapetus all things considered, as if either he or Atlas was the titan leader in Cronus absence (in the case he was indeed defeated first, something that cannot be confirmed with exception of the Orphics myths).

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 27 days ago

Polyphemus is not stupid or a mindless beast

Most of you already know about what the title says, but you may not know that Polyphemus is actually very clever as I will show. Because people think of him as a monster, it can be easy to think there is nothing more to him. However, that is not the case. In my opinion, monsters are everything that is not a animal, human or a god/divine being, that is, a monster is usually a mix of all of these. So we have things like the Nemean Lion, who behaved... like a lion. On the other side of the spectrum we have the Harpies and Sirens, divine monsters that serve the gods and are human-like; or the giants and gorgons, also human-like monsters who are close to the gods and are their kin.

Polyphemus is more like these last ones. And the most interesting thing about his episode is that this intelligent being just decides to eat people. That is not very interesting if he is just a monster like the Nemean Lion.

Besides the Odyssey, Polyphemus features in several pastoral songs about how he tried to have the love of Galatea, a Nereid of the Sea, but she often refused him. Polyphemus even played musical instruments to impress her and all that. In the Odyssey itself he is a shepherd, can make cheese, knows there are gods, and he had a conversation with a seer named Telemus, who warned him that he would be blinded by a man named Odysseus, but he dismissed it and forget about it. The only thing he and his tribe don't have is agriculture, because they feed on the fruits that grow thanks to the rain of Zeus. And he also lacks the respect for things sacred, since he eats people and he says in his own words that the cyclops are more poweful than the gods, so he don't care about the gods even through he knows that they exist.

Then he actually tries to trick Odysseus multiple times, and I think any other could fall for these tricks, but Odysseus is more clever. First he says this: "... But tell me, now, where you moored your fine ship, when you landed. Was it somewhere nearby, or further off?" Odysseus responds that all of the ships were destroyed by Poseidon and only they survived. So Polyphemus tried to trick Odysseus in revealing crucial information, but it didn't work as Odysseus told another lie.

Later, he asks Odysseus his name in order to give him a gift in exchange for the wine, and Odysseus says Nobody. Polyphemus then says that he will eat Nobody last. So here once again he believed he was outsmarting Odysseus by telling this joke, altrough he didn't realise that Odysseus tricked him already.

Later, when he learns of Odysseus real name as Odysseus is escaping, he remembers the prophecy that he would be blinded by some Odysseus, and then he calls Odysseus and says this: "Come here, Odysseus, nevertheless, so that I might grant you guests gifts, and urge the great Earth-Shaker (Poseidon) to see you home, since I am his son, and he says he is my father, and he, of his will, can heal me, where no other of the blessed gods or men can." Odysseus responds by saying that he wished he could kill Polyphemus, so that Poseidon could not heal him (and judging by Virgil's Aeneid, Polyphemus was not healed by Poseidon).

So in this last case he tried to bring Odysseus to this land by promising he would not call upon Poseidon's curse, and would give him gifts. But Odysseus cleverly knew that it was a trick just to take his life. So yes, the great horror of Polyphemus is that he is very clever, but decided to eat people because he has no respect for anyone or anything.

reddit.com
u/Super_Majin_Cell — 29 days ago

This settles the debate about Helios

From time to time I see people still talking about if the sun god mentioned in Mutiny is Apollo or Helios. But the only reference to it by Jay clearly shows is Helios, this comes from one of the clips of thunder bringer that you can easily find in youtube.

As for why his name is not said in the music, is likely that is because he could not fit his name in the song, or there was no need to mention it. Tiresias and Anticleia name are also never said in the songs, we just known it is because is obvious, but only with Helios people don't think is obvious for some reason.

Also it don't help that in the Odyssey movie released just now they say Apollo as the name of the sun god, once more causing confusion about this. I hope at least that when people read the Odyssey they know is Helios, even if is just called the Sun God, he is the Son of Hyperion so that distinguish him from Apollo, called son of Zeus in the poem.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 29 days ago

Helios can't catch a break

Minor spoilers for the Odyssey movie (and some other related greek mythology media).

Well well, once again Helios is replaced by Apollo even in a story that is about Helios. Like, the movie could just use the words Sun God as they often use in Odyssey translations. But nope, someone inserted the word Apollo there once. Is such a minor change that even the Mythology Guy noted in his review that it is a pointless change, since these gods don't appear anyway.

Some time ago I made a post about how Helios was villanized in Blood of Zeus season 3 as a defeated titan, because that is what is left to Helios nowdays. Either people put Apollo in his place and forgot about him, or he is a defeated "titan" that was replaced, forgotten or enslaved. Or he is a evil father like in Madeline Miller's Circe.

I don't have a problem with depicting Apollo as the sun god since that is not innacurate. But I do have a problem in putting Apollo in place of a Helios story like this movie, and I do have a problem when people want to have their cake and eat it too, making Apollo the sun god but also wanting to have Helios, so they will invent that one replaced the other, and this is innacurate (they say a similar thing in regards to Oceanus and Poseidon, forgotting that both sets of gods can coexist as they do in mythology). But in this case, why? Why say Apollo? But I know what happened. They read Sun God in their Odyssey translation, didn't think of Helios but Apollo, and that is it.

Now is already ruined, a new generation of people will think that Helios don't even exist in greek mythology, and unless they read the Odyssey, will now depict the Sun cows as Apollo in this story. If you think that is not the case, just remember how much Percy Jackson influenced the idea that Apollo replaced Helios as if that happened in mythology, instead of both coexisting.

Obs: explaining a joke defeats the point but the title is also a joke about how Helios literaly has to work everyday.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 1 month ago

Yes, the Trojan War is about Helen

I know that is a coincidence for this to be posted right after the Odyssey movie, but I mainly basing this argument in the movie "Troy" and some things I saw people commenting. A lot of people seems to think that the Trojan War was about the imperial ambition of Agamemnon, not because of Helen, and she was just a pretext for the war. But that is not true in a lot of the main greek sources for the event (Proclus summary of the epic Cycle; Homer's Iliad; Odyssey; Quintus Smyrnaeus; the Bibliotheca, etc). It was indeed because of Helen.

Paris went to Sparta (usually it was because Aphrodite herself guided him there to give him the love of the most beautiful woman in the world). Her brothers and Menelaus all accepted him as a guest, but Menelaus went to Crete and said to his wife Helen to make Paris feel like home, while Castor and Polydeuces went to fight Idas and Lynceus and lets say that they didn't return home. So Helen was alone with Paris and he was a very charming guy apperantly since she fell in love with him (she is never taken by force, at least not in the sources I listed), and she helps Paris steal some treasure and then went with him. Menelaus returns and discovers the guy he gave hospitality went away with his wife and treasure. Menelaus would not even think Helen had fall in love with Paris, after all he was clearly a thief, so why not a kidnapper? Menelaus is offended by this, and he goes to his brother Agamemnon. Now, a lot of people think Agamemnon is pure evil and just wanted to expand his empire. That is not the case, because there was no empire. Mycenea grows in the mythology to be the most important city of the Achaeans, but is not a empire, other cities didn't own anything to them. And Agamemnon don't use any imperial decree to call the other kings, he brings the Oath they all sweared to protect Helen and her marriage, or he promises glory and spoils, almost as if he is calling mercenaries. Yes, Agamemmon is far from being great in a lot of things, but he is not completely evil devoid of emotions, it surprises me seeing adults in the XXI century thinking characters have either to be good or evil, but not in between. And Agamemnon is the escape goat now for everything bad that happens, just like people in the medieval and modern period made Helen the escape goat. The guilty one is and will always be Paris.

But the greeks not even attack Troy at first. Menelaus and Odysseus go to Troy to ask for Helen. Now, the Trojans often discuss to give her back, but Paris always shuts down any discussion. Paris had a lot of political power, and king Priam cared for him, so no one could do anything. Hector desired Paris to be dead or not even born, but he will not kill his brother. The other trojans can't kill their prince either. So Paris is imune to assassination unless a greek kills him, and he don't want to return Helen, so there is nothing to do except the greeks going to war. This is why Paris is characterized by Homer as basically the ""villain"" of the Iliad even if he don't appear that much, since Homer gives the focus to Hector. Paris only argument in his defense is that he can't deny the gift Aphrodite gave him, and that is it. He don't care if people are going to die, he will not return Helen as long as he lives, he even says he will give back the treasure he stole, but not Helen.

And Agamemnon never shuts down any negotioations that could end the war earlier; in book III of the Iliad he is actually in favor of Menelaus dueling Paris and the winner gets Helen and the war ends. Aphrodite takes Paris from the battlefield to save him. Agamemnon then argues that Menelaus had won, but Athena convinces the trojan Pandarus to shot a arrow at Menelaus, starting the war once again. Also, Paris dies even before the idea of the Trojan Horse, and then his brother Deiphobus marries Helen, and he, contrary to Paris, does marry her by force according to a some sources. In others she is given to him for some reason, but she never loved him and now she indeed wanted to return to home. He is considered by the sources to be lustful too, and in a few sources Menelaus and Odysseus encounter him during the fall of Troy drunk with wine. So yeah another douchbag.

Finally, we also have the fact that Menelaus is only king because of Helen. According to the Bibliotheca, after Castor and Polydeuces died/turned into gods, Tyndareus in his old age gave the throne to Menelaus because Menelaus was married to his daughter, so Tyndareus trusted the kingdom to him. So even if you want to go the political route, Helen is still the key piece because she is what justifies Menelaus claim to the throne of Sparta. This is one of the stupid changes made in the movie Troy: Helen says she was given to Sparta without choice! When is the total opposite, she was born in Sparta, and even if her father is Zeus she still grew up in Tyndareus palace as his daughter, is Menelaus who went to Sparta for her, not her for him, I don't know what the movie was doing here.

reddit.com
u/Super_Majin_Cell — 1 month ago

Odysseus carried the trojan war by the end

I am not one to defend Odysseus, but I will give this to him, after Achilles died, Odysseus basically speedrun the Trojan War to its conclusion.

For ten years, excluding only the last weeks, Achilles carried the Trojan War. He killed or defeated every single leader on the trojan side. He killed or defeated Poemander, Telephus, Tennes, Cycnus, Aeneas, conquered a hundred cities, then defeated Aeneas again, a bunch of other trojans, pissed off the river Scamander, then killed Hector, then defeated and killed Penthesileia the Amazon and Memmon the Aethiopian. And even Achilles death, according to Quintus, was basically deus ex machina: Apollo is tired of the hero hubris so he kills him with a arrow.

Then imediatly after that, Odysseus and Ajax the Great compete for Achilles armour. Odysseus wins in his arguments so Ajax kills himself after going mad.

So the greeks lost two of their biggest powerhouses, what now? When Achilles was alive, Odysseus purpose was to use tricks for the greeks advantage. Odysseus and Palamedes were the ones who used clever solutions. Now most people just know about Palamedes in relation to Odysseus, but if you scan a lot of sources, Palamedes was important in a lot of stories and he was even better than Odysseus. In the end, however, Odysseus is jealous and is able to trick the army that Palamedes is a traitor, or he and Diomedes just straight up drown Palamedes. In Fabulae, Odysseus reason to want him dead is because Palamedes had threatened Telemachus earlier to force Odysseus to go to the war.

After Achilles and Ajax dies, there is no one to guide the greeks. Agamemnon had been humbled when he realised how much they needed Achilles in the Iliad, and Menelaus was always a reserved guy. There is no more Palamedes either. So Odysseus decides to solve everything.

He captures the trojan seer Helenus and discover from him the things needed to take Troy. And then he goes and grabs all of them: He brings the bones of Pelops, he goes to Lemnos to convince Philoctetes to return to the army, and he goes to Skyros to recruit Neoptolemus. Then Philoctetes shoots his poison arrows at Paris, and Neoptolemus defeats the trojan allie Eurypylus. Then Odysseus again uses tricks to enter Troy as a wounded beggar and steal the statue of the Palladium.

Now the only thing he needs to do is to make sure the army enters in Troy and the Trojans will have nothing to save them. So he thinks of the Trojan Horse. Epeius builts it while Sinon convinces the trojans that the horse is a gift to Athena of the defeated greeks, while Odysseus, Menelaus and others are inside it. Then they open the gates of Troy while the trojans are asleep after the feast and Troy is sacked, with Odysseus and Menelaus killing Deiphobus and rescuing Helen.

So yeah Odysseus basically did everything important in these last weeks of the war.

u/Super_Majin_Cell — 1 month ago

The problem with Hades

Obviously there is no problem with the god Hades. The problem is that today people can only think of Hades in extremes, and there is actually three extremes that Hades exists in, with no in-between. In one extreme, he is like Satan, no need to discuss this since you all know about it. In the other extreme, people decided to make him the opposite of the "Satan Hades" so much they made him a paragon of goodness and virtue. Across the internet these people will say things like "he is the best god among the olympians", "he is the only god faithful to his wife", "he was cheated by Zeus". Literaly all three are wrong. In this view we have things like Lore Olympus, where Hades is horrible and even has dead humans as slaves, but the story treats him as a good person! Like, the story will point out bad things and just ignore it. And in Blood of Zeus season 2, they say that Hades never did anything wrong and the real villain is Demeter... I don't even need to explain this.

But then we have another extreme, a third one, and one that I just see here. That of Hades being useless. He was not doing anything, other gods or spirits did everything in the Underworld, etc. Ignoring he was king and that not even Zeus did everything in Heaven, Zeus is not piloting the sun chariot or crafting his thunderbolts for example. Zeus has his daughter Justice overseeing the world. If Zeus is not useless for that, why some say Hades is useless for having others working in the Underworld?

Now of the popular gods, no one exist in this situation, of either being completely evil, good, or useless. This is why even through I don't care much about this god, I also don't like any Hades in any adaptation, because they are all in a extreme or the other.

For the "pagans", gods are nature given a personality, and for them the world don't exist in a binary of good and evil. But the pagan writers were not like George Martin. Martin sits down and say "now I will write grey characters". A ancient greek would sit down and say "now I will write a character". They were not trying to make a point about morality, or trying to be this or that. In the case of human characters, like the heroes, they act just like warriors and kings acted, this is why they did a bunch of horrible things. In the case of gods, they acted as if nature was given a mind, and nature is not binary, and we can hardly judge nature. Would you blame a storm for existing?

Hades is thus the god of everything related to the dead. So he is "hated", "without pity" and "dreadful". Some of these epithets is also shared by Persephone. But they don't mean that Hades is hated personally. Only Demeter is show to be antagonistic towards him for obvious reasons, but the other gods treat him well. But he still has this unpleasent aura. Hades will go to Olympus to talk with Zeus, but Zeus will not go to Hades to talk with him, because Zeus don't want to be associated with the Underworld.

As the god of the dead, Hades will not grant the desire most humans have: to ressurect their loved ones. Most of us don't care about that because we see Hades as a literary character, not as a real god. But for the ancient greeks and also modern pagans he is/was a real god. We judge fiction differently from reality; if Hades is merely fiction, then we can feel sympathy for him. But if is real, and has the power to ressurect the dead, but don't grant that? What is that if not a god without mercy? Compare with Zeus that brings rain when people pray, or Demeter that gives crops. This is why the ancient greeks feared Hades, he was real, but he didn't granted most prayers.

Except he did! Of course, only to heroes who entered the Underworld. But this shows that like any god, Hades is both "good" and "evil". Just like Apollo heals and caused plagues, Hades keeps the dead but also ressurects them. But this was only possible in the age of heroes.

Finally, as for his personality. One thing Hades does constantly is that he wants people either to die or remain dead. In the Orphic Hymm to Hygeia, is said that Hades is a enemy of Hygenie (daughter of Asclepius) itself. He also wanted Asclepius dead for his healing powers. But this is a aspect completely absent from modern portrayals, where the lord of the dead concerns with about a bunch of stuff, except about the dead.

But yes, Hades is the concept of death given a personality (yes, I know Thanatos exist). The greeks saw him as cold hearted because he didn't granted a lot of prayers, but that is meant to be neutral, not as completely Satanic or useless. But no need either to whitewash Hades and claim he is morally better than the others, because he is not.

reddit.com
u/Super_Majin_Cell — 1 month ago