Son's high school graduation
▲ 2 r/AdoptiveParents+2 crossposts

Son's high school graduation

The last few weeks, I've been writing about our somewhat estranged son's recent (and unexpected) graduation from high school.

My story might be a bit of a mismatch here--we adopted our son and his sister from foster care, and then, years later, in 2023, they opted to move in with their dysfunctional biological aunt and kinda sorta stopped talking to us. Still, I hope it might resonate with someone here, especially given the challenges of big days like graduation for alienated parents.

[Note that this is a super condensed version that I adapted for this Reddit post; if you're interested in the full thing, I'll post a link at the bottom]

In church a month ago, we handed out quilts to graduating seniors.

That morning I happened to sit by myself in the back row of the upper balcony. The patterns of fabric rolled over the pews before me like waves, small hummocks of color and care.

The congregation raised our hands in prayer over the quilts and the teenagers and the people from other lands who would receive the remaining quilts as gifts.

I saw the nervous excitement of the teens up front as they shared their upcoming plans with the pastor, and I felt the congregation smile back with mirth and pride.

I watched as the students draped the fabric around their shoulders and drew it tight, as we agreed to support them in prayer and deed.

I felt a sense of that joy and the gravity of commitment.

And I felt an absence.

Our adopted son was also a senior, but on that Sunday there was no quilt for him there.

It had been two-and-a-half years since he left that place—there one Sunday, gone the next—so it would have been awkward and jarring if one had been set aside for him. That quilt would still be there now.

From my perch above, I thought of the careful work of the quilting volunteers, of the time and creativity they had invested. I imagined clouds of batting settled into place with pins and rulers, the quiet backstory that we forget when we nuzzle into the warmth and hue of a good thing

....I wondered whether there was a possible present in which he would have stood there in the chancel and charmed us with his future plans.

I wondered whether other ghosts haunt other congregants and how the church might serve us in our haunting.

With the back of my hand, I wiped at my eyes.

* * *

....Our son never appeared before my church community that Sunday.

He didn’t slink out of from the vestry and upstage the usual order of things. There was no fattened calf to celebrate a return.

We raised our arms in blessing, someone said Amen, and I exited out the back without speaking to a soul.

But somehow he did graduate.

Somehow my wife and I found ourselves on a grassy hill outside the high school football field, and we watched as row after row of blue gowns proceeded to the stage and then back to their seats.

We sat there on a blanket and tried to put words on a card we had purchased the day before when we learned he would walk and that we were invited to come.

Or I suppose I should say that my wife wrote something on the card and I signed it because I could not condense all of this into a single sentiment. I could not contain my surprise or find the safe words to convey longing and felicitation.

I did not know how to tell him he had done an ordinary thing that was extraordinary.

Thank you for reading.

Here's the full story: https://the17pointscale.substack.com/p/the-haunting

And my first attempt to write about the graduation is here: https://the17pointscale.substack.com/p/collecting-pictures-from-a-flood?r=195lr

u/The17pointscale — 3 days ago

How often do you message other Substackers?

I know that engaging in the community and networking is one of the keys to growing one’s Substack, and I’ve attempted that by commenting on other writers’ posts or sharing their work in Notes.

I’m curious, though, how often you include direct messages as part of your growth strategy?

I’ve never sent a direct message to someone on Substack, but I could see how that might increase the chances of collaboration with other writers or make your new subscribers feel welcome and more engaged.

Thoughts?

reddit.com
u/The17pointscale — 13 days ago

Should I change my Substack publication name?

TL/DR - After a year and 40ish posts, should I change my title?

When I started my Substack about a year ago, I opted to use my ancient blog title, mostly because I really like the old name.

The old name (the17pointscale) was somewhat mysterious while also relating to an actual function of the old blog (I would sometimes rank books and movies on, yes, a 17-point scale).

However, my Substack doesn’t do that. I may still talk about books or movies, but the genre’s a bit different (creative nonfiction/personal essays/poetic ruminations).

Now I’m more interested in growing than in maintaining that sentimental connection with my old writing haunts, and I’ve read several people in this subreddit talk about the importance of having a sensible and meaningful publication title, something that better conveys what I write about (ordinary life and being a biological, adoptive, and somewhat estranged father).

I’m wondering whether it feels too late to change or whether it might still be worth it.

For context, I have about 100 subscribers, including 12 paid subscribers, and an open rate of about 50 percent, but I’m growing verrrrrrry slowly.

Thoughts?

reddit.com
u/The17pointscale — 17 days ago
▲ 73 r/ParentalAlienation+2 crossposts

"Youth" hits me differently fifteen years later

I remember loving the haunting beauty and delicious sadness and honesty of "Youth" when I first heard it years and years ago. I had recently gone through a break-up, and experiencing the lyrics was kinda like having someone peering in through your window and narrating your feelings to you.

Eventually, I got over the girl, stumbled into love with a girl who was an even better match for me, got married, and had kids. Somewhere in that journey I put this song on a playlist for my wife but then forgot about it.

And now, fifteen years later, I've been trying to write about an entirely different experience--we adopted two tweens from foster care and then several years later, they went back to live with their biological family. Then, there was a moment at our son's graduation last week that felt so beautiful, bewildering, and sad that I couldn't find the right words, but I tried, and as I finished the essay, "Youth" came back into my head, still haunting, still beautiful, and somehow attached to different meanings for me.

I love how a good song can do that, how it can bend and reach us at different times with different meanings.

Anyway, here's my piece, just in case you're interested: https://the17pointscale.substack.com/p/collecting-pictures-from-a-flood

u/The17pointscale — 18 days ago

I attribute the traffic on my two most read Substack posts mostly to links I shared on Reddit.

Usually I don’t post links here because many subreddits don’t permit it and because my subject matter and style is more personal and literary than topical. The two popular posts were in my same style, but they connected directly to controversial topics (ed tech and job loss due to the present administration) and seemed fitting to share in the relevant subreddits.

What I noticed is that the links drove a ton of traffic to my Substack—the most ever—and i think they generated likes. But, contrary to Facebook or LinkedIn or Substack itself, it seemed that few of those readers stuck around to subscribe.

The spike in readers looks nice, but I’m wondering whether you’ve had similar observations and whether it seems worth looking for opportunities to share post links on Reddit if they don’t translate to subscribers.

Thoughts?

FWIW I write about the intersection of ordinary life, fatherhood, politics, progressive politics, and adoption. My hallmarks are likely poetic prose and vulnerability—not exactly marketable stuff.

reddit.com
u/The17pointscale — 2 months ago