24M, in my first relationship with 22F and having urges to experience other people — what do I do?
I’m 24 and have been in my first relationship for just over a year. We had our one-year anniversary last month, and honestly, the relationship is great. My girlfriend is genuinely a great partner, and I have no complaints about the relationship.
The problem is that I’ve started feeling an urge to cheat. I want to be clear that I don’t plan to cheat. I’ve never arranged anything, pursued anyone, or made plans to do it. But the urge is there, and I feel guilty just for having it.
After doing some “introspection”, I think part of it comes from feeling like I missed out on an experimental/fun phase when I was younger. I was extremely introverted for most of my youth and didn’t really come out of my shell until later. My girlfriend was the first person I ever dated, and she was also my first sexual experience.
I’m also bisexual, and I’ve never actually been with a man. That’s another experience I find myself thinking about a lot. Overall, I have this feeling that I want to experience new people, new situations, settling down.
And that’s where I feel conflicted. On one hand, I feel like I’d be stupid to leave a relationship that is genuinely good just because I have these urges. On the other hand, I feel guilty staying with her when part of me is wondering what I’m missing.
I’m also scared of committing so young and potentially reaching old age having only ever been with one person, wondering what my life would have been like if I had explored more. At the same time, I don’t want to throw away a great relationship over a feeling that might eventually pass.
So I guess I’m asking: Has anyone else experienced this? How do you distinguish between normal curiosity/FOMO and a genuine desire to leave a relationship?
I don’t want to cheat on her. I also don’t want to make a huge decision based purely on anxiety or fear of missing out. I just genuinely don’t know whether these feelings are something I should work through while staying in the relationship, or a sign that I’m not ready to commit to one person yet.