What in the world is going on?
Hey there. I've been using SubmitHub to submit my latest 3 singles to playlist curators.
Apparently, the average share rate is 28%.
My success rate has been a lot worse than that for the first two singles, but for my third and latest single, only 1 out of 44 curators accepted it for sharing on their playlist. That's roughly 2%! Two percent!!
This is so confusing to me. I really thought these songs would at least perform closer to the average. I've spent years refining these songs and I'm very happy with them, but obviously all this rejection is starting to make me question everything. Clearly there's something I'm doing wrong, that's for sure.
While my music is definitely mixing genres a lot, it's still clearly fundamentally Pop-Rock, so I always try to send it to a wide mix of pop- and rock curators. I try to reach curators with an average acceptance rate between 12% - 30%.
Their feedback is frequently "nice production, nice songwriting, cool drums, nice vocals", and always really positive and complimentary, but then its either too pop or not pop enough, too energetic, or lacking energy. The vocals fill too much in the arrangement, or they're not standing out enough. It's too modern, or its too retro.
That makes me conclude it's a matter of bad fit. I must be extremely awful at figuring out which curators to send my music to. But honestly, the same names keep coming up, so I guess there's practically no curators on SubmitHub that has playlists my music fits into. I almost can't believe this.
I'm not even sure what my question is. Just desperation, I guess.
I guess it would count as self-promotion to share a link to the song, which is against the rules, so I'll not do that, but if anyone wants to take a listen and provide some feedback as to which curators, similar artists, or genres to align myself with, please feel free to reach out, and I'll send you that in a DM.