Soccer Tech Platform Idea Stress Test
I'm building a sports tech platform in Canada and I want honest feedback, even if it's harsh.
The idea and vision: a networking platform for soccer (with the idea to scale to other sports eventually), basically LinkedIn meets Transfermarkt. Players (10+ with parental control from ages 10-15), coaches, agents, and organizations (agencies, media, clubs, etc.) all have vetted profiles. The focus isn't necessarily about going pro, it's about helping players get to the next level, whatever that looks like for them.
Right now if you're a talented kid grinding in a lower rep league trying to move up, there's no real system connecting you to the people who could actually help; you're relying on your club and limited existing network to get trial opportunities at the next level (domestic and abroad). You've got scattered highlight videos, maybe a Hudl or Veo account, an instagram, etc. Nothing ties it together or puts it in front of the right people. There's many platforms in North America that focus on solely college recruiting but nothing beyond that.
Our angle is being the all in one platform. Instead of jumping between five different apps and services (stats tracking, video, agent contacts, networking), it's all in one place, built specifically for soccer with vetted profiles for each user type with the ability to showcase yourself, connect with others for opportunities, and post about yourself and opportunities.
I want to know where this falls apart. Is "all in one" actually a real advantage or does it just mean we do everything a little worse than apps built for one specific thing?
Would a player at a no name club actually get real value from something like this, or is that just not how player development works in reality? Tell me why this fails.
Ask follow up questions to get better understanding of the vision if needed as well!