I Love Pogo Pins 🤷
I actually love the pogo connector on the X3 and X4 Pro. On a tiny e-reader, it makes a lot of sense. Here are my 5 points:
1. Thin, light and space-efficient: Pogo needs less depth and device-side hardware than a USB-C receptacle. On a device this small, I'd much rather see that precious internal space used for things that directly improve the product: a larger battery, or even a larger display while maintaining the same outer dimensions. That's a much better engineering trade-off to me than dedicating that space to a relatively bulky port.
2. More durable and safer mechanically: USB-C puts a socket, internal tongue and contacts inside the device, exposed to repeated insertion, wear and sideways cable forces. Pogo leaves simple contacts on the reader and moves more of the mechanical parts to the replaceable cable. If the cable gets caught, it breaks away instead of becoming a lever on the port or pulling the reader with it. I'd rather replace a cable than repair a charging port.
3. Better outdoors, especially if you read at the beach: Sand, dust, dirt and pocket lint can get trapped deep inside a USB-C socket. Pogo has no deep port: the contacts are exposed, visible and easy to brush or wipe clean. That's exactly what I want on something I'll throw in a bag, carry in a pocket and read at the beach.
4. Better economics: A simpler device-side connector can mean fewer parts, less assembly complexity and lower manufacturing cost. On a device this small, I'd rather see that cost and engineering budget go into the battery, display, frontlight, or other things I actually use.
5. Simple and well suited to a micro/mini e-reader: It snaps on magnetically, breaks away safely and provides what a small battery actually needs. It's a simple charging interface for a simple, low-power device.
Regarding the concerns:
(A) Cable Universality: Pogo isn't as universally interchangeable as USB-C, so you may need another cable. But this isn't a phone that needs charging every day; with e-ink battery life, the cable spends most of its time at home anyway. For portable charging, the tiny pogo dongle is actually useful: throw it in your bag and use your existing USB-C cable.
(B) Connector Stability: while connection stability is a fair criticism of the dongle, a dedicated charging cable with the pogo head built directly into it is significantly more stable, with less rigid mass and leverage pulling on the magnetic connection.
My advice to XTEINK: Bring back the dedicated pogo cable that came with the X3, or even better, include both the cable and dongle in the package. The dedicated cable gives you the more stable everyday charging experience, while the tiny dongle is perfect for travel because it works with the USB-C cable you're already carrying. They complement each other rather than one replacing the other.
For an ultra-small e-reader, thinness, lower weight, dimensions, better use of internal space, device-side durability, breakaway protection, outdoor friendliness and easy cleaning make pogo a design I genuinely like and I wish Xteink won't replace it in future versions. ❤️