“Gaswhistling”
I think this behavior is common enough to come up with a name for it; it was between “gaswhistling” and “doglighting” and I think the former is the better option.*
Have you ever heard someone say something that was clearly a dogwhistle but then when you call it out someone comes in and tells you you’re crazy for interpreting it that way? That’s gaswhistling.
For example I saw the other day someone saying “wealthy neighbors commit more crimes than anyone except poor neighbors” and when someone called out the dogwhistle, another person said “wow even the word ‘neighbor’ is racist now? You just completely projected your own racist mindset onto that”. Gaswhistling.
Or something I read in a YouTube comments section just now where people were talking about hippos being very violent when the context was African megafauna and someone said “how African of them”. Another person responded “I can’t believe you got even five likes for this, you’ve never read a book in your life have you” and a third person comes in saying:
“What’s crazy is they said nothing racist and you’re just applying your own subconscious racism onto their statement. Trying to destroy anything near you is very typical of African megafauna. Why would you think it means anything else?” Then doubled down with the gaswhistling in another comment about the person “projecting their own racist subconscious”. (I pointed out how it was funny that the person who said “you’ve never read a book in your life” actually never even said it was racist themselves… so if mentioning racism first is the metric then the gaswhistlers still lost.)
I think it’s good to have a term for this type of tactic because A) I have seen it used dozens of times and B) just as with terms like gishgalloping, concern-trolling and sealioning, the goal is to wear people down with endless bad faith arguments and insincere outrage, so having a term for the general behavior allows you to skip the most exhausting part and address the actual dogwhistle itself without the gaslighting about who’s actually reading too much into it.
*NB: I wish I were clever enough to come up with something more clever than a straightforward portmanteau but at the same time the meaning needs to be conveyed immediately which I think “gaswhistling” does, at least if the context is already that of a discussion about a dogwhistle. My goal however isn’t so much to push a specific word as much to identify a behavior that I think should have a name and give it one, so if another name catches on that’s great too. As long as you call it that when you see it I’m happy!