'A World Without Gold' - Content that feels out of place that almost ruined Edward Kenway for me. Honest opinion
I had seen a lot of posts about this additional content, and now that ive finished it myself, I completely get what people were on about.
I don't mind the story thats told here, even though its painfully obvious that both the cutscenes and the writing don't come close to the original work. The point in the story that this quest appears doable is just honestly ridiculous. We have a character thats just gone through Mary read dieing in prison and coming to the realisation on what effect being obsessed with gold and finding the observatory was having on him. Then I play a world without gold and see Edward repeating the same mistakes again resulting in Maynard tricking him twice with the same trick of seeking gold and this time almost losing both his ship again and his 3 officers. I can understand edward being tricked once since yes it can be difficult to get over old habits, but twice just makes him look pathetic.
If this whole sequence took place before Edward finds the observatory and went to prison, it would have made a ton more sense for Edwards character development. Having this happen just after he's made amends and joined the Assassins comes very close to just ruining Edward for me entirely. A good point to place this is just after the mission where Roberts requests Edwards aid a couple months after the principe sequence allowing a good amount of time.
I also really have to comment on the ending... because its honestly terrible. Edward bests Maynard in combat, yet somehow he magically gets away after throwing the key in the ocean, Edward grabs it and suddenly we are back at the hideout. No additional gameplay to save them or fend off more british, just a fade to black. This feels extremely lazy and rushed and doesn't really feel like we've "avenged blackbeard" in any way other than making Edward look like a fool the entire questline.
This hasn't ruined the game overall for me, but i am disappointed at how this new content has been handled to the point where it felt unofficial. I'd rather it just not exist or just moved to a point in the main story where it actually made sense.