Can I request a replace in kind settlement from the other driver's insurance?
I was recently in an accident where the other driver's Allstate insurance accepted full responsibility.
After taking the car to a local collision shop, it has been declared totalled, and Allstate is offering me several thousand dollars less than what I would need in order to purchase the same vehicle with the same mileage.
Is it possible to get them to do some sort of "replace in kind" arrangement where they pay for the same vehicle with the same mileage and similar condition if I can find one?
Edit: I am in New Jersey. My own insurance, Progressive has been entirely unhelpful because I agreed to file through Allstate.
Edit 2: Ok, I've got it. ACV is the only option.