r/askastronomy

▲ 6 r/askastronomy+1 crossposts

If all black holes are singularities, what makes them ‘small’ or ‘massive’ or ‘supermassive’?

At singularity does any mass exist?

Is it inevitable that a black hole keeps going up in size over ‘time’ as it keeps gobbling up its surroundings? (I couldn’t help use ‘time’ in the sense we understand it, and I don’t know what time means to a black hole).

If it is all due to mass, isn’t there a limit for density? If not, what chemical element would the mass be?

If we were to get inside the event horizon would everything around us look bright or dark?

reddit.com
u/voldy234 — 13 hours ago

Do black holes have solid surfaces, or are they like our gas giants?

I’ve been wondering this for a while. Added picture of my own drawing of a black holes. I know it’s not accurate but it looks cool

u/Whaaaaa4321 — 18 hours ago

How do you pronounce Uranus?

Do you pronounce it “Yoo-ranus” or “Your-anus”? Or do you pronounce it in some other niche way?

u/Whaaaaa4321 — 19 hours ago

What are these moving lights?

Hi I'm in Kensington Victoria and I saw these lights in the sky? Maybe there's a light show in the city? It's 7 15 PM

u/Odd-Cranberry1330 — 14 hours ago

What is this massive white star?

Took this photo a while back in the Lake District UK, I understand the cluster of blue stars is the pleiades cluster, but the massive white object to the left I have no idea.

u/QueasyStatistician33 — 15 hours ago

Can there be non-spinning black hole?

I know that most if not all of the singularities of black holes are spinning becouse the star that turn into black hole have initial rotation and that rotation is maintained.

Is it in theory possible for a black hole to not spin?
If yes, would that black hole still have event horizon in the form of disc? Or would it be a sphere?

How would that affect the image of black hole, would it just be completly dark w/o acretion disc?

reddit.com
u/Wisniaksiadz — 16 hours ago

Tracing our orbital path onto a photo

Jupiter and Venus were bright tonight in Chicago. I got to wondering, would it be possible to trace our three dimensional orbital path on this two dimensional photo? Venus is closer to the sun and Jupiter is farther. We (Earth and the moon) should split the difference between the paths traced by the two planets here, right? What does that path look like projected onto this photo?

u/tpn211 — 21 hours ago

Can a planet be tidally locked to its moon AND have a second orbiting moon?

Wierd phrasing, as the moon its tidally locked to would be orbiting the planet WAY faster than the other one (at the speed the planet spins around it’s axis = 1 orbit[month] pre day).

From what I’ve gathered, a planet can be tidally locked to its moon (not entirely sure about Earth-like planets though). But could the system have a third body, which orbits the planet at a slower pace, and thus appears from the surface like our moon does: rising and falling during the day? I would assume the tidal force of the “orbiting” moon would interfere with the tidally locked one, but also that the tidal force of the planet would be greater, so idk. What would be the requirements for this to work? (sizes/distances of the moons etc.) Google isn’t helping.

This is for a worldbuilding project, so assume the planet is habitable. I was experimenting with a planet having a “secret moon” that always stays in place and thus is only visible from one hemisphere.

Any insights you might have are welcome. Thanks!

reddit.com
u/HermitArcana — 1 day ago
▲ 913 r/askastronomy+1 crossposts

Jupiter,moon and venus conjunction on 18-20 may

A Venus–Jupiter–Moon conjunction is an astronomical event where the Moon, Venus, and Jupiter appear close together in the sky from Earth’s point of view. People are telling that this conjunction is going to happen between 18 to 20 may is it real or just a rumour.

Let us know your pov

u/Flame_vision0 — 3 days ago

Since the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) is the light just after roughly 400000 years after the Big Bang, would it have been possible to see the 'edge' of the universe with Modern day telescopes if life on earth and this modern day technology had come 500000 years earlier?

reddit.com
u/AsherMon26 — 2 days ago

The Ultimate Cosmic Symmetry! 🌌

Remember my last video where we learned that distance isn’t just space, it’s time? Now, let’s look at the absolute beauty of physics from BOTH sides! 🪐✨
Here is the hidden truth: If an observer from a distant system (8.6 light-years away) looks at Earth, and we look back at them... we both experience a perfectly mirrored reality. We each see the other not as they are "now," but as a perfectly delayed snapshot from 8.6 years ago! 🕒
No one is "older" or "newer" in this cosmic mirror game. The delay is identical (8.6 years). We are literally exchanging historical postcards across the fabric of spacetime. 🗺️💫
Check out the full diagram to see how Einstein’s light cones lock us into this flawless cosmic harmony!
#Cosmos #Astrophysics #Spacetime #Astronomy #PhysicsLovers

u/Daryos-am — 1 day ago

What is this???

wtf is this??? I know I kept moving but to be fair I was hella nervous I had just gotten done smoking a one hitter and suddenly got this urge to look at the stars and after a few seconds I saw two “stars” move towards each other do a half circle then go in the opposite direction the other “star” came. I tried to see where the iss was and it showed nowhere near where I live(west Texas south plains in a small town near Lubbock texas) then I tried to open the US statistics and it wouldn’t show up. I’ll try to post an animation of what I saw.

u/Immediate-Simple-391 — 2 days ago

Moving object in night sky

can anyone explain this? thought it was a satellite then started moving erratically around the sky. Majorca 19.05.2026

u/Classic_Annual_7543 — 2 days ago
▲ 8 r/askastronomy+1 crossposts

Hundreds of moving lights in night sky

Time: between 11:30 pm-3 am (when I finally went to sleep - and they could have started sooner but that’s when I was looking). Night of May 16-morning of May 17
Location: just south of Santa Fe, NM

I almost continuously saw small moving lights (like satellites) emerging from one fairly small region in the sky — northern direction — and moving slowly and steadily for 10-30 seconds ish in an eastern direction until they disappeared. It was a fairly steady stream for hours. There had to have been hundreds over the course of that time. These were sometimes fairly close to the horizon but sometimes further up.

Sometimes one would emerge, sometimes a couple at different nearby points, sometimes several. They all traveled at generally the same pace and the same direction until they disappeared.

Sometimes they were more faint and sometimes they glowed brighter. Once there were a cluster of 5 that emerged at the same time. After a few seconds they appeared to line up vertically, three in a row, then one off to the side left, and the fifth back in the vertical line. They glowed brighter once aligned and then moved out of formation and then disappeared. A few times I saw two emerge close together and they appeared to get closer and when they were right next to each other one or both glowed super bright.

As the night went on, the emergence and disappearance areas remained the same except they shifted eastward due do earth’s rotation.

Could these have been satellites? The sheer continuous volume over the course of hours has me questioning…

reddit.com
u/alaskayla — 2 days ago

Big weird vertical dark line and dark bottom of stars/planets

Hi everyone,
Newbie here!
I just started
Me and my friend bought the following gear:

Celestron 130slt mount
Qhy5iii715c camera- 8mpx and 1.45 upixel sensor size
Startravel 120 telescope ( 120 aperture and 600mm focal)

As you can see it the photo when zoomed out/out of focus

Some dark vertical line appears
And the bottom of the planet/star is becomes dark

I tried using air to clean my camera sensor and my focuser

And when i zoom in/focus well i get the vertical and horizontal lights!

Is This normal? Something wrong? Or needs cleaning?

Please help i couldn’t find a proper solution/explication

Thanks all in advanced

u/Fooad4444 — 3 days ago
▲ 110 r/askastronomy+2 crossposts

What fact about the universe amazes you the most?

What is that one thing which you found out about the laws of physics or how universe behaves that has left you startled?

reddit.com
u/Dazzling-Degree-3258 — 3 days ago

If I keep adding mass to a planet will I eventually get a star?

Say I could magically keep adding mass to an asteroid, I imagine I could eventually get a planet sized object, but what about beyond that? Would I eventually get something like a gas giant or eventually a star, then different kinds of stars? What happens if I keep going?

reddit.com
u/Odd-Information8607 — 3 days ago

Why does the Moon require the word "the" before its name but no other satellite does?

Why is it that it must be called the Moon rather than just Moon? For any other satellite, you would say "Io orbits Jupiter" and not "the Io orbits Jupiter" but for some reason you cannot say "Moon orbits Earth". It has to be "the Moon orbits Earth". The same thing also applies to the Sun where it has to be the Sun rather than just Sun. Why is this?

reddit.com
u/Easy-Explorer-6403 — 3 days ago
▲ 25 r/askastronomy+1 crossposts

Did I capture Holmberg IX?

2 hrs integration Seestar s30 processed in GIMP and Siril, 20 sec frames

u/GoatEither6623 — 3 days ago