Making ice cream on Chopped is so uncreative
Like cmon, imagine if someone in the breakfast round said “Im going to mash all the basket ingredients into a paste and serve it in a bowl!”
The only reason ice cream gets a positive reaction from the judges is because cold cream and sugar make everything taste good.
Any time I see someone make ice cream (so every single episode) it immediately reads to me that they couldnt come up with anything else. Part of the competition is creativity and technical skill, making ice cream demonstrates neither.