Did more ex-kid choir people experience this?
I was in a pretty highly praised national youth choir as a kid (ages 7-9), and they disbanded a couple years ago. Eventually quit because I dreaded every rehearsal so much as a result of things that happened. I thought they were normal, but when I was talking about this with some (non-choir) friends, they told me it wasn't. Did other ex-kid choir people experience any of this? Or was this just our choir?
First of all, to get our attention, we were never told to quiet down. From the very first moment we walked in, our directors would whistle on their fingers in a microphone or hit the keys of the piano. This was like 30 kids ages 7-15 in a classroom type of room. We weren't super rowdy or loud, but I can understand that maybe they had prior experiences that made them want to be strict?
Whilst singing songs for the first time, we would stand in lines. Everyone who didn't sing well enough were asked to stand in front of everyone and one by one sing again what we did wrong until we got it right.
And I think this is the most normal one; obvious favoritism. In our case it was the kids who were good enough to be on the official recordings. They were let off the hook a lot more; didn't get shit when they had to miss due to illness or other private circumstances, were put apart from the rest of the group during concerts, although this served no purpose.
And just a bunch of things that made you wonder if these people should really work with kids. Like sending off a girl who was crying because her uncle was passing away, or brushing off a kid who was struggling to sing with an allergic reaction (not fatal, just annoying, I was this kid lol).
It's been almost a decade since I left it there. Just wondering if other people have similar stories? And how did it affect you/how did you deal with the effects?