Thoughts from a longtime player
I have fond memories of playing MLB: ‘06 The Show on my PSP, back when I was a teenager (I’m now in my mid-30s). I was an Xbox guy, though, and didn’t play the console version of this franchise until 2017.
I’m a perfectly average player, and made peace with never being a more elite player.
I think my biggest gripe with this game is how unsatisfying it can be. It’s difficult to consistently hit well, and the game doesn’t reward you for a good swing nearly as much as it should.
What is the point of having Red or P5 Diamonds + Supercharged cards if good swings lead to outs? The amount of times I’d square up a ball, only for it to hang in the air for a laughably long time or line drives being consistently caught.
I swear this game punishes you for swinging at the first pitch, even if you square up on it. I’m actually going to keep track for the coming week, because I genuinely don’t think this is a coincidence.
The computer’s defense is a joke. Everyone talks about outfielders making insane dives on balls into the gap, or infielders warping to the ball, but how about all the times a pitcher will nab a line driver behind their backs?
I don’t want to invest my time, money, and energy into a game that is doing everything it can to screw me.
Diamond Dynasty feels so cluttered and unfocused, like they’re trying to please too many masters. Diamond Quest tried to blend Moments with Showdown and Conquest, Mini Seasons are not fun to grind through (and part of that is their refusal to, you know, make them feel like actual seasons), and Events have been unimaginative and too infrequent.
They want you to grind two different, yet interconnected programs, too.
It just feels unfocused, sloppy, and lazy.