My baby's grandparents want to go by the same nickname. My husband disagrees with me and he says it shouldn't be a big deal - AIO?
TLDR; My dad and my MIL want to go by the same grandparent name. It's a unique one and my dad has wanted it forever, before me having kids was even a thought in anyone's mind. MIL doesn't seem to want to give it up and my husband is defending her, saying they can both just have the same nickname. He says the only compromises are that or I pick a name and assign it to her which I know she would be against. AIO?
Disclaimer: I know grandparents usually end up just going by what the kid wants to call them anyway. But let's put that aside for the sake of this dilemma.
It's kind of a silly name but my dad has wanted to go by "Coach" as a grandpa and he's talked about it since I was like 13 (I'm currently 30). He's coached/refereed sports his whole adult life and his brother gave him this nickname in the past. I guess that's where it stems from, not totally sure, but he's always talked about wanting it.
My mother in law all of a sudden also wants to be called Coach. She's never coached anything besides my SIL's (26) little league, and it's completely random for her. I have no idea where she got the idea besides maybe overhearing the fact my dad wants it.
My husband says kids have grandparents of the same name all the time. His example was a kid having two "Grandpas" or two "Grandmas" - I feel like this is obviously very different considering those are very traditional names.
My dad doesn't have a lot. He and my mom divorced when I was really little and she died back in 2011. He's single and doing grandparenthood by himself (he and my in laws are not close). He's got a complicated relationship with my sister who's currently battling addiction. Things have been very difficult and lonely for him. I don't think it's an absurd request to let him have the name he's wanted since before me having a baby was even a thought in anyone's mind to himself.
My husband is being very difficult and telling me that if I don't want her to go by Coach I have to pick something out and assign it to her, which I know she is against. I find this super dismissive and just him not wanting to set a boundary with his mom. It's one name out of thousands that's off limits, am I really the bad guy?
ETA: yall I wish this was fake. I wish this was written by a bot. I'm 8 months pregnant do you think I want to be dealing with this shit 😩😂