
Discrepancy: Robin + Ted’s Kids
Ted says that Robin went on to be featured in a lot of his kids’ drawings. He refers to her as Aunt Robin. Yet, when they run into Ted and Penny in the last episode, Penny doesn’t know her. Robin is “bus lady.” More generally, it’s a fact that Robin isn’t around.
Those are formative years - it’s hard to become “Aunt” if you miss a lot of childhood.
How do we think she ended up becoming Aunt Robin and in those drawings clearly drawn by children? Do we think she returned shortly thereafter and started being a big part of their lives?
ETA: a kind Redditor pointed me to this deleted scene which explains that Robin moved back to NYC shortly after the bus lady scene.