u/lelouch_huh

The problem with unequal revelations in Abrahamic religions(or Islam and Christianity)

So, essentially, my argument entails that-

God is completely just and beloved. So, it is natural to conclude that this just and beloved God will create a world that is completely fair and just to humans. And obviously, God's judgement and "test" or revelation or right to salvation will be fair to all and equal to all.

Now another important facet about Islam and Christianity is that the non believers, pagan believers will go to hell. This is a very extreme side of things and theres usually an emotionally charged argument about how it is "unfair" for a just and kind but atheistic(or other) person will go to hell, a place of eternal damnation. Now, I dont subscribe to this because God is the source of positive and he is the one who should decide ethics and not humans.

Now, my major argument is that if salvation is fair, why is it that the prophets sent are only in a concentrated regions? India, right from the time the peninsula slammed and formed himalayas, India has been one of the most populous countries in the world and despite all of that, there was no prophet sent by the God.

This is unfair revelation, revelations or quran/bible teach us and tell us about God/Allah the afterlife and the ultimate telos of this life. But consider Islam. Islam didnt exist in India or the americas when muhammad was preaching. The system is ultimately unfair to the contemporaries as they got virtually no revelation from god.

IF god does send his prophets, he should send them to every country of that time ensuring that every human from contemporary gets the divine information about heaven/hell, creation and god.

A common counter argument is about how god will test them differently compared to others but to me, This has two problems. First is that it requires a prior belief in god that god will be just to function as a great rhetoric argument. Second is that a virtually better solution could have existed that god could send prophets to every country ensuring every person of that time, got information than send prophet to selective region and if some people didnt get the info, they will be tested differently. It gives off that God did a mistake or error with his plan of sending prophets.

Now i will say pardon me for some loose wordings. It's my first time trying writing a post like this.

reddit.com
u/lelouch_huh — 20 hours ago

A reallly important and also fact about Puranas. 18 puranas describe events from different kalpas. Here's the entire list. [From Chapter 53 of Matsya Purana]

u/lelouch_huh — 3 days ago