I’m looking for some genuinely thoughtful advice about a situation involving a friend of mine.

I know this is going to be a long post because there are a lot of layers to the situation. I also want to make it clear from the beginning that I only know what my friend has told me. I wasn't there when these events happened, so I don't want to present his version as an unquestionable fact or turn this into a story about "good people vs bad people."

What I'm really interested in is this:

If a child has spent most of his life being raised by an extended family member and now strongly identifies that person as his parent, how can his biological parents rebuild their relationship with him without causing the child further emotional harm?

Here's the situation.

The family

My friend is 51 years old. I'll call him Saleem for privacy.

He is originally from Mumbai but has been working in Bangalore for the last six months and is expected to remain there for approximately another six months.

His family is a large joint family in Mumbai.

There are his parents, Saleem, two younger brothers, three sisters, Saleem's wife and their two sons.

The eldest sister is unmarried.

The second sister is divorced and has a son.

The youngest sister is married and has her own family.

Saleem is the eldest son and, according to him, has been the primary earning member of the family for many years. He has financially supported his parents and siblings for a very long time.

The family lives together in the same house.

Saleem, his wife and their two sons live on the ground floor. The rest of the family lives upstairs, where the main kitchen is also located.

That arrangement becomes important later.

Saleem's marriage

Saleem apparently didn't want to marry when he was younger.

He kept delaying marriage, but eventually his parents insisted that he get married.

He married a woman chosen by his parents.

He openly admits that he didn't initially feel that she was the kind of person he had imagined himself marrying. They were very different in personality.

However, they eventually had children.

Their first son was born about 11 years ago.

I'll call him A.

Their second son, B, was born roughly two years later.

What happened after A was born

According to Saleem, when A was only about a week old, his mother began taking a very active role in looking after the baby.

She told them, essentially, that they didn't need to worry because the family would take care of the baby.

Saleem didn't see anything wrong with this at the time.

In fact, he trusted his mother completely.

His reasoning was understandable in its own way:

"My mother raised me. She took care of me. Why wouldn't she take good care of my child?"

So he allowed his mother to take increasing responsibility for A.

According to Saleem, one of the early things that happened was that his wife was discouraged from breastfeeding A and the baby was instead given formula/powdered milk.

I wasn't there, so I can't independently verify exactly how this happened or why.

But Saleem now looks back at that period as the beginning of a much larger problem.

A gradually became extremely attached to his aunt

Over time, Saleem's unmarried sister became the primary person looking after A.

She was the one spending most of the day with him.

She fed him.

She put him to sleep.

She took him to school.

She brought him home.

She spent time with him.

Eventually, A became extremely attached to her.

This wasn't simply a normal bond between an aunt and nephew anymore.

According to Saleem, she became A's primary parental figure.

Saleem believes his mother may have encouraged this because his sister was unmarried and had no children of her own.

His interpretation is that his mother may have thought that A would eventually become a source of emotional and perhaps financial security for her unmarried daughter.

I don't know whether that was actually her intention.

That's only Saleem's interpretation of what happened.

But whatever the original intention was, the emotional relationship between A and his aunt became extremely strong.

Then something even more serious happened

According to Saleem, his mother and sister also began telling A negative things about his biological mother.

Again, I wasn't there, so I cannot independently verify exactly what was said.

But Saleem says that A gradually developed a very negative image of his own mother.

He started seeing his biological mother as someone unpleasant, difficult or unkind.

Meanwhile, his aunt was the person he associated with love, comfort, food, school, sleep and everyday life.

So naturally, the emotional attachment became even stronger.

By the time Saleem and his wife realized how deeply this had affected their relationship with their son, they felt it was already too late.

A doesn't really live with his parents emotionally

Today A is 11 years old.

Physically, he still lives in the same house as his parents.

But emotionally, according to Saleem, he lives upstairs with his aunt.

He eats with her.

Sleeps with her.

Spends most of his day with her.

Goes to school with her.

Comes home with her.

If he wants something, he usually goes to her.

He does speak to his biological parents, but Saleem says the interaction is often very short.

Sometimes A will spend a few minutes downstairs with his parents and then his aunt will call him back upstairs.

And he goes.

Saleem says A doesn't want to spend extended periods of time with him or his wife.

Then they had their second son

About two years later, Saleem and his wife had their second son, B.

And B grew up very differently.

Everyone in the family loves B.

His parents love him.

His grandparents love him.

His aunts love him.

A loves his younger brother as well.

B has a normal relationship with his parents.

He lives downstairs with them.

He is comfortable around everyone.

And this creates an incredibly painful contrast.

Two brothers.

Same parents.

Same house.

Same school.

But completely different relationships with their parents.

Even their school routine shows the difference

A and B attend the same school.

But A is taken to school and picked up by his aunt on her scooter.

B is taken and picked up by his mother.

So even though the brothers are going to the same school, they leave the house with different caregivers and return to different parts of the family.

It's a small detail, but Saleem says these little things make the situation very painful for him.

What about A's mother?

This is probably the most difficult part for me personally.

Saleem's wife still lives downstairs with B.

She has to go upstairs regularly because the kitchen is upstairs and she is expected to cook and handle household work.

According to Saleem, she isn't treated particularly warmly by the rest of the family.

She doesn't feel accepted by her mother-in-law or sisters-in-law.

But she hasn't left.

And apparently, one of the biggest reasons she stays is A.

She wants to see her son.

Even if she only sees him for a few minutes.

She wants to know what he's doing.

She wants to be physically close to him.

She doesn't trust the situation enough to simply move away and hope things will work out.

Saleem also admits something important here:

His wife isn't perfect.

She grew up without parents and, according to him, has her own emotional and personality issues.

He doesn't describe her as an ideal mother.

But he doesn't believe she is a bad mother either.

And he feels that regardless of her shortcomings, she should have been given the opportunity to develop a normal relationship with her first child.

Saleem himself is also conflicted

This is the part that makes the entire situation difficult to reduce to a simple "cut them off" answer.

Saleem is angry with his mother.

He is angry with his sister.

He has had serious fights with them.

He has stopped speaking completely with his sister.

But he still financially supports them.

Why?

Because he remembers what his parents did for him.

He told me that his father took loans from different people to fund his education.

His mother supported him throughout his childhood.

He says he wasn't always an ideal son, but he remembers the sacrifices his parents made.

So despite everything that has happened, he feels that he cannot simply abandon them.

He essentially sees two truths existing at the same time:

His parents did a lot for him.

And:

He believes they seriously damaged his relationship with his first child.

He can't erase either truth.

He also continues to support his sister

This makes things even more complicated.

The unmarried sister who is raising A is still financially supported by Saleem.

He says he does this because, whatever happened between them, she is still his sister — and she is also raising his son.

So he hasn't completely cut her off.

At the same time, he feels deeply betrayed by her.

He believes that his own family took advantage of his trust when he was a young father who didn't understand what was happening.

Why hasn't he simply taken A back?

This is the question I initially asked him too.

But when you think about the child's perspective, it's not that simple.

A is 11.

For most of his life, his aunt has been the person he considers his mother figure.

Imagine suddenly telling an 11-year-old:

"The person you've always thought of as your mother isn't your mother. You need to start living with your biological parents now."

Even if the adults believe this is the correct thing to do, the child may experience it as another form of abandonment.

From A's perspective, his aunt is probably the person who actually raised him.

She was there when he was sick.

She fed him.

She took him to school.

She comforted him.

She was there every day.

So I don't think it would be emotionally healthy to simply drag him downstairs and tell him that everything he has believed about his family is wrong.

That could potentially create another trauma.

And this has been going on for 11 years

That's the part I can't get out of my head.

Eleven years.

Saleem is 51.

His son is 11.

For essentially the entire life of his first child, Saleem has been watching his son grow up while feeling like he isn't really allowed to be his father.

And the child is still living in the same house.

It's not like the son lives in another city.

He's upstairs.

His father is downstairs.

They can hear each other.

They see each other.

They go to the same house every day.

But emotionally, there is a huge distance between them.

Now Saleem is worried that time is running out

Because A is no longer a toddler.

He's entering adolescence.

And Saleem is becoming increasingly worried that if nothing changes now, the relationship may become almost impossible to repair later.

He doesn't want to spend another 5–10 years hoping things will somehow fix themselves.

At the same time, he doesn't want to forcibly remove A from his aunt.

He doesn't want A to hate his aunt.

He doesn't want A to feel that he has to choose between two people he loves.

He doesn't want a police case unless absolutely necessary.

He doesn't want the entire family destroyed.

And he doesn't want his son to become collateral damage in an adult family conflict.

What he wants is basically this:

He wants to become his son's father again.

And he wants his wife to have a chance to rebuild her relationship with her son.

I don't know what the right solution is

After hearing everything, I initially thought the answer was obvious.

But the more I thought about it, the less obvious it became.

If Saleem's account is accurate, there may have been serious manipulation by the adults.

But A is also an 11-year-old child who has spent most of his life forming genuine emotional attachments.

So even if the adults did something wrong, the child shouldn't be punished for it.

I don't think the solution is simply:

"Take the child away."

And I don't think the solution is:

"Leave things as they are because the child is comfortable."

Both seem problematic.

Maybe the answer is a very gradual process.

Perhaps Saleem needs to rebuild his relationship with A first, without immediately trying to change where A lives.

Maybe they need individual and family therapy.

Maybe A needs a neutral child psychologist who can understand his feelings without telling him which adult he is supposed to love.

Maybe Saleem's wife also needs help rebuilding trust and communication with A.

Maybe the aunt needs to remain part of A's life rather than being treated as an enemy.

Maybe, eventually, the living arrangement can change — but only after A has developed enough trust with his biological parents to feel safe doing so.

I genuinely don't know.

So I'm asking Indian men and women here:

If you were in Saleem's situation, what would you do?

More specifically:

How can a biological father rebuild a relationship with an 11-year-old son who has been primarily raised by his aunt?
Should Saleem first focus entirely on rebuilding trust with A rather than trying to change his living arrangement?
How can A be helped to understand the situation without making him feel that he has to choose between his biological mother and the aunt who raised him?
Is family therapy/child counselling something that could realistically help in a situation like this?
Has anyone seen or experienced something similar in an Indian joint-family setting? If so, what actually helped?

I'm not looking for a "men vs women" argument, nor am I looking for people to simply declare Saleem's mother or sister evil.

I'm also not looking for legal advice unless someone genuinely believes there is an immediate child-safety issue.

I'm primarily interested in the emotional and practical side of this.

If this were your family, how would you try to repair the relationship while keeping the child's mental and emotional wellbeing at the center?

Because after hearing Saleem's story, the thing that stayed with me wasn't really the conflict between the adults.

It was this:

An 11-year-old boy has grown up in the same house as his biological parents, but somehow ended up feeling that they aren't really his parents.

And now everyone has to figure out how to undo eleven years of that without hurting him even more.

u/luckyvicky10

Good place for Tiramisu in Ahmedabad?

Damnn Feeling good about the Biceps! (Beginner)

Mosquitoes only bites me....what can be done about it?

Is this Erectile Dysfunction?

Best way to spend ₹90 in Ahmedabad? (Food related)

Realistically How Much Would You Pay for this?

How can a father rebuild a relationship with his 11-year-old son after the child was raised by his aunt?