Does writing a master's thesis, as opposed to doing a final project, significantly improve your chances of getting into a PhD program?
So, I've just started a master's program in interdisciplinary studies with a concentration in philosophy and theory and would like to later go onto to get a PhD in philosophy. As per the master's program, you can either finish with a thesis or by doing a final project.
Originally, I was dead set on doing a thesis, as I'd assumed that it would look better on my academic resume and was mistaken in my belief that the project was just like a thesis, only with a smaller page requirement.
Having discovered the creative potential of the project, I have become very much so taken with my idea for it, which is to write a work of experimental literature, billed as an epic poem, which is one part concrete poetry, one part philosophical essay, and one part political manifesto. It is to be largely a meditation on Giorgio Agamben's interpretation of Walter Benjamin's notion of messianic time, though is somewhat deceptive in that the author of the text, as I plan to publish it under a pseudonym, drifts in and out of polemics such that the work can also be seen as deconstruction, as there is a way in which the character is also engaged within a political crusade.
In this way, it's sort of like Notes from the Underground, where the narrator isn't so much as "dishonest" as they may or may not be reflective of the author's, in this case, Dostovesky's, actual beliefs.
I'm also working on publishing a book of poetry at the moment and, it seems possible, if not even likely, that I could convince my editor to publish what becomes of this project, anywhere between two and four years from now.
My idea for the project is not so much as relevant as is my inquiry as per having a thesis whenever I apply to a doctoral program, as I obviously don't want to put myself at a significant disadvantage as per not having done a thesis.
I've applied to doctoral programs already, and, so, do understand that I will need a writing sample, of which, given the nature of my project, I would not be able to use, but, aside from having to additionally generate a writing sample, for the admissions committee, would it look significantly better to have done a thesis, as opposed to a creative project?