Frozen cooked vs raw for cats
I’ve been using Smalls for almost 2 years but I’m looking at other options right now mainly to try and save money. I know Smalls isn’t raw, it’s cooked, but I still feel like my cats have been healthier on it than any canned (or kibble of course). I’m nervous about switching from cooked to raw because my older cat has a sensitive stomach and my younger one can be a bit picky. They also have always done amazingly on Smalls when it comes to coat health and scentless poops (anytime I’ve given canned as a treat or backup their poops get bad lol). Are there any solid cooked fresh options that might be cheaper? Can anyone ease my worries about raw for a cat with a sensitive stomach? She also has been hacking up massive hairballs lately and I’m trying to figure out how to manage that.
My cats are both girls, both about 10lbs, 2yrs and 5yrs, I aim to feed 180-200cal each per day (vet approved). Smalls packets are about 90% of their diet then they get a tiny bit of Dr Elsey’s kibble and various treats (the younger one would kill me in my sleep if she didn’t get some dry food, I was using Ziwi Peak and Vital Essentials but that became too expensive). I am currently spending about $185/month on Smalls and about $30/month on kibble/treats.
From my research on this sub, BJ’s Raw looks to be possibly the cheapest raw option for my situation, but I saw someone mention that the 80/10/10 formula is not truly complete. It’s also a combined protein formula so they wouldn’t have variety. I don’t want to have to cycle through a bunch of different options to find one that works because I know that will upset my sensitive girl.
I am in the US but possibly moving cities very soon so a local pet store is not really an option right now. I’d like to find something with good shipping standards. Unfortunately it’s not feasible for me to make my own food at this time. Thanks for your help!