Did this bother anybody else?

Grace has a Ph.D. in molecular biology, so he knows how to study cells in a lab. Fine.

He's a middle school teacher, so his repertoire of basic science facts, like the speed of light, is broader than average. Ok.

He was heavily involved with PHM, so he maybe picked up some astronaut techniques and solar system knowledge. Vague, but plausible.

But how on Earth does he have orbital mechanics calculations memorized?? Or know how to program translation software to work with an alien language??

This didn't impact my enjoyment of the story. It's only after my 22nd rewatch that it occurred to me there's an overreliance on the "smart person knows everything" trope.

Edit: I have listened to the audiobook. Yes, there is a lot of exposition that explains what Grace is doing. Still felt like a stretch that one person could know how to do all that. Best excuse is "Stratt trained him up", which is a shortcut way of saying "he's smart, just go with it."

My examples either sucked or were described poorly. Point is, Andy clearly used the Living Encyclopedia trope to make Grace a Gary Stu, capable enough to move the story forward.

Why does this bother me? I think it sets unrealistic expectations for intelligence the same way superheroes set unrealistic expectations for strength or bravery. Perhaps more challenging because Grace is more realistic than, say, Spiderman. If you are watching this with kids, it's a great conversation starter about self-expectations.

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 11 days ago

Recommend A Fanfic With Less Than 2000 Kudos

We all know the super popular ones that get brought up in every post, but which PHM fanfics on AO3 do you think deserve more attention?

AO3 doesn't filter based on quality, only popularity. Often it's the same, but many times great fics get buried.

Share links to fanfics you adore, but have less than 2000 kudos!

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 15 days ago

What do we know about Linda?

-She dated Grace for at least 8 months.

-They dated while in college (assumed undergrad).

-She lived with Grace for the last 8 months of their relationship.

-She's a hoarder.

-Grace did all the work of moving her stuff (not sure why?)

-She thought Grace "had his head in the clouds".

-Now she's with Mark.

-The only romantic partner Grace mentions.

-The relationship was a disaster.

Is that everything?

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 1 month ago

How many Earth years did they experience on the return to Erid in the movie?

In the book, due to relativity, they experience about 3.2 Earth years, but in the movie, when Rocky gives Grace the astrophage, he says "I go home 6 years slower."

Does that mean they experience 9.2 years? Or 4.8 years? Or some different math?

Edit: Can someone better at relativistic physics calculate an estimate of how much time occupants of the Hail Mary would experience traveling the 10 light years from Tau Ceti to Erid? Thanks!

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 1 month ago

Why the hate???

To all those calling me racist on my last post for asking if the instant noodles Grace eats with chopsticks on the Hail Mary may have been originally for Yao...

A Russian, American, and Chinese go to space. We see vodka and chopsticks. We know the vodka belonged to the Russian. We saw the American eat instant noodles with a fork earlier in the movie. I think the chopsticks were intended for the Chinese man and showing them in the movie is a small detail that shows Grace is using what he's got since his crewmates died.

u/playsmartz — 2 months ago

Did Eva notice that Grace likes ramen or was that Yao's food?

Did Eva feel guilty about Grace, so at least made sure he had food he liked? If so, why no sour skittles? Since he's eating with a fork on the first image, but chopsticks in the second, maybe the ramen + chopsticks were meant for Yao?

u/playsmartz — 2 months ago

Next possessive fix?

Ripped through {On the Mountain by Riley Hart} and {Possession by Rina Saint} and I need more. Loved how the relationships developed through nonverbal cues and physical interaction progressed by a dominant character, but allowed to continue through lack of resistance.

Hard nos: nonconsent, age gap 10+, blood/scar/watersports, incest (or close family friend), feminization, on page mpreg

Bonus if it has a great narration.

I DNF {Primal by K.A. Merikan} - couldn't get past the >!LI kidnapping the MC!<

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 2 months ago
▲ 0 r/Miami

Anyplace still selling FIFA jerseys?

Looking for kid size Argentina or Spain world cup 2026 jerseys. Bonus if it has a Miami or USA host logo.

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 3 months ago

Fanfic rec?

Given that:

- Grace is lacking human contact, which is known to aid in mental health

- Rocky loves Grace and wants him to be healthy

- Rocky invents new things

- Rocky now has all patents of humanoid robotics

There's got to be a fic on AO3 of Rocky building an android or something to give Grace a hug.

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 3 months ago

Rainbows symbolize hope - but not for Earth

I've seen several theories about the prolific use of rainbows as a hope motif throughout the movie. In Christian lore, a rainbow appears after God destroyed the Earth to symbolize a promise of rebirth and the cessation of destruction. So it's easy to assume the rainbow represents hope for Earth. But I think it's actually hope for Ryland Grace.

The rainbow only appears when he's around. The main light rainbows are when Eva and Grace first meet, when Grace sees Rocky's ship, and when Grace is forced on the mission. The final scene with Eva Stratt watching the videos and giving the order to use the beetles is the most hope Earth has had in decades, yet no rainbows. Also, the final outfit Grace wears - after Earth (and Erid) are already saved - has a rainbow. The rainbow isn't about Earth; it's about Grace's character arc.

I think the rainbows are about hope for Grace - that he will learn to love himself, find a place he feels accepted, and make inner peace. This is the message of the movie and what gives it the overall hopeful feeling.

Taking this one step further...the audience relates to Grace's loneliness and in watching this self-isolated person grow into himself and find peace and acceptance, it gives us hope for ourselves. This is why the title also has a rainbow in it. The movie isn't about astrophage or science or aliens - it's about coming out of our comfort zone to build a life of love.

u/playsmartz — 3 months ago

"It's the Rocky movie. It's always the Rocky movie."

Had PHM playing on my phone for background while my 4 year old and I did Legos together at the table.

The 7 year old comes in and asks "what ch'ya watchin'?"

Without missing a beat or looking up from his Legos, the 4 year old answers "It's the Rocky movie. It's always the Rocky movie."

I think I might be watching it too much 😅

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

Bakery that can print edible pictures?

Huntsville/Madison preferred

Are there any bakeries that will make a cake and decorate with an editable picture we send them?

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

How does Rocky "recognize this"?

Echolocation wouldn't see that the stuff in the vial is black. How did Rocky know this was astrophage?

Or is this a "it's a movie, just go with it" moment?

u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

Why did movie Grace try to help Rocky with a heat lamp?

Did I miss something? Even without the book context that Xenonite is an excellent insulator, we know two things based on earlier scenes in the movie: 1) Rocky's environment is very hot; 2) Grace can touch Xenonite that is touching Rocky's atmosphere.

So why would a heat lamp do anything?? He's not a lizard in a glass terrarium 😅

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

Engineer vs Mechanic

Anybody know why the movie referred to Rocky as a mechanic instead of the engineer that he is?

A mechanic is a skilled tradesperson who builds, maintains, and repairs machinery, engines, and tools.

An engineer is a professional who applies scientific, mathematical, and practical principles to design, build, and maintain structures, machines, systems, or processes.

Edit: reasons why this bothers me: 1) Rocky is referred to as an engineer in the book, why change that? It doesn't add or subtract anything from the movie, it's like they're deliberately being different for no reason; 2) Grace is referred to as Dr., his qualifications and expertise are specifically called out, but all Rocky gets is "he's a mechanic, I think". To a human audience, this puts Rocky on a lower intellectual level than Grace when he's arguably smarter; 3) this is a STEM story, not a STMM, story - one of the goals of Andy Weir's books is to encourage kids to become scientists and engineers, so it seems like a miss to make the character kids most relate to not be called an engineer.

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

Cancer fanfic rec?

Looking to read a fic, preferably on AO3, about Grace developing cancer while living on Erid and explaining to Rocky that the treatment is...radiation. Rocky has feels. Happy or sad ending.

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

Ah! The Element of Surprise

I need that shirt from the movie. But I'm confused about the 117 - what's the significance of Tennessine?

Also, has anyone found that exact shirt design, with an added bonus of PHM call-out on the back?

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 4 months ago

Help! Where was that scene?

Which episode was the scene where Arthur dresses himself, Merlin arrives late and is surprised Arthur can dress himself, to which Arthur snarks something like "of course I can dress myself, I'm not an imbecile", but then he turns and we see he didn't fix the back of his shirt, which is sticking awkwardly in his pants and Merlin has to bite back a laugh?

reddit.com
u/playsmartz — 5 months ago