Warner in S9E5 “Harm”
Warner is my favourite all the time but in this episode specifically, I genuinely think she’s amazing.
She’s canonically a combat veteran, served in Desert Storm, but takes a very staunch stance against torture, or “advanced interrogation”, as a tactic to gain information even when people are telling her why it’s necessary.
I also love the way she said that the Hippocratic Oath is really that simple, because it is. The whole episode is full of justification but I love how upset she is at a doctor of all people doing this.
I like this episode for how it handles advanced interrogation anyway, especially the scene where it is literally just people describing it directly into the camera. I think it’s one of those topics we should never use euphemisms for. But Warner is the character who gets upset at Huang for suggesting it’s not that simple, pushes for the doctor to be put on trial, and right at the end, still works with that doctor anyway in the interest of the man having a heart attack.
Media in general has a habit of justifyingtorture when the “good guys” are doing it (and yes, that includes Stabler getting physicalwith people), but the way this episode treats it all, to the point of showing actual pictures from Abu Ghraib, has got to be one of the best commentaries on torture as a tactic I’ve watched, especially considering when it was first aired.
I love Warner, and I love how she makes absolutely no justification for “the greater good” in any way. She’s very insistent about it right from the start, which I really like.
(By the way, torture is literally never an effective information gathering tactic, because anyone will say anything to make the pain stop).