r/DynastyBaseball

Be sure to join us on the Dynasty Baseball Discord Server!

Welcome to the r/DynastyBaseball Team Help + Trade Thread - Please post your Dynasty trade or valuation questions here, and please see the rules below:

Effective April 1, 2025, all specific trade questions should be posted in this weekly thread

Rules & Guidelines:

1. It is highly recommended you respond to other posts before posting your own to help make this as successful as possible.
2. It is not necessary to post your entire team, but roster context may help
3. Trade posts (trades) should be in the following format:

• Number of Teams:
• League settings (H2H Cat, H2H Points, Roto, etc)
• I give:
• I get:
• Question:

If requesting a price check on a player or a "what would it take?" type question, please try to be as descriptive as possible. Talk about the player you want to trade or acquire and pieces you're considering going the other way. From there, hopefully, the community can assist you in developing a fair trade offer.

rank these 4 outfielders: Lara, Hartshorn, Veen, and Antonacci​

Who would you like to have straight up for their career? I think i can only keep one of the above. It's a head-to-head 16-team categories league with 12 keepers. I need to have my keepers set for the playoffs that begin at midnight ET.

My keepers right now are: C William Contreras 1b Ben Rice 2b Ketel Marte 3b Jose Ramirez SS Konnor Griffin LF Yordan Alvarez CF Wyatt Langford RF
UTL Juan Soto (should lose RF eligibility)

SP Tarik Skubal SP Chris Sale SP Parker Messick SP Bryan Woo

I don't think i have any keeper worthy SPs beyond that, but let me know if I'm wrong. No teams really keep RP: Trevor Rodgers Jacob Lopez Landon Roup Cody Bradford Robbie Ray Joey Cantillo

It’s a throwback to the mid-80s rap scene today, or a mid-June turnaround. Your choice. As always, there’s new news, notes, and rankings in the Top 100 Starting Pitchers today. Enjoy and Happy Monday!

Have him on all three of my dynasty teams. Today made me levitate.

Just insane. What a performance by someone people were writing off because of k rate etc. Murakami is the new mold - you have to respect huge power in the minors, it plays.

Not even saying he’s going to forever be good but there’s definitely a top 10 prospect in there and people having him outside his top 50 is just crazy. Power like that is different

37 home runs halfway through August

Is this who he is now? Does he get back to who he was? I'm thinking about selling. 30 team dynasty H2H Cat.

It feels like selling low but what if it's selling high?

I got offered 3 1st Rd picks. 2027 pick would be low and the two 2028 picks would be one low one mid. It's not enough for me but it got me thinking about selling. What's a reasonable value?

What are your thoughts on rodriguez in dynasty? What’s his ceiling offensively?

How are you guys valuing Triston Casas at this point?

He played 132 games in his breakout 2023 season, then 63 in 2024, 29 in 2025, and will now miss all of 2026 after the patellar tendon injury and wrist surgery. He’ll turn 27 before next season.

I still believe in the offensive talent, but at what point does the injury history outweigh the upside? Is he still a hold in a 10-team dynasty?

Been holding on to guys like McDougal and Waldrep in the minors but I’m thinking about dropping them to add guys like Ramon Marquez and Caden Hunter or someone like Francisco Renteria and Angeibel Gomez.

League set-up: 10 teams, h2h points, 30 keepers. Free league, just for fun and trash talking

We have had our league since 2015, with mostly the same crew intact most of the time, with 1 or 2 teams having a rotating owners the first 4 years before locking them down.

Recently, we have had 1 team come forward and say they are not rejoining the league next year. We are going to boot out one guy who hasnt paid attention at all this year (our first 0 win season) and had checked out halfway last year. We had another guy who has complained every year, and technically left but came back and has caused issues the last few weeks. And we know his buddy will leave when this owner isn't invited back.

Normally on those 1 off teams that leave, we cut the keepers down to 20 and reset the draft pool a bit. We were pretty democratic with this decision and had a vote on how to proceed. But it was unanimously voted yes for that system.

This time, with 4 teams leaving, I am wondering if we reset the league in full. We have some guys interested in coming in, but hard to pick who gets the 0 win team who really has players with low to no trade value and no prospects, who gets the stacked team, and who gets the middle of the road team with one or two good moves being competitive.

I have half my guys who will be left including the co-commish that want to keep things as is as they just got out of rebuilds, and i got the other 2 plus me who think this might be the time to reboot everyones team and start fresh. It is tough as after 12 seasons of history, we have never had a full redraft before and i also like my team and how stacked it is.

Just curious what other people in this community would do and how they would move forward in this situation

Which prospect site do you feel does the best at ETAs for prospects? My league is a keeper league, not dynasty per se. And how quickly a prospect is called up is in some ways more important than how good they will ultimately be.

I've see anywhere from Rotowire (2027) to MLB Pipeline (2029) for Vahn Lackey. Although this question isn't specifically about him, for example in my league if he makes the majors next year he would be very valuable to draft. If it takes him until 2029 than it would be almost pointless to draft him.

Between Baseball America, Rotowire, Fangraphs, MLB Pipeline...any others I'm missing?

Basic question. What made your league fail? Loss of members ? Lack of support from the commissioner ?
Lack of activity?

I’ve been in a few leagues for a few years. Seeing a decline in activity. Sort of frustrating when you spend a few years building a team and then the league kinda fails.

I’ve considered starting my own league and trying to find active members but haven’t decided on it yet. So I guess if you’re looking for a super active league let me know.