r/JewishCooking

Burnt Cholent

Burnt Cholent

Hi everyone!

Today I tried making cholent for the first time. My recipe was the following: first, without any oil, brown the meat so that all the foam comes out. Remove the meat, add oil to the pot, and fry the onions until golden. Return the meat to the pot and let it brown together with the onions, making sure the meat sits on top of the onions. Then add the beans, potatoes, pearl barley, honey, spices, and eggs. Pour in the broth, bring everything to a boil, then reduce the heat to the absolute minimum and let it simmer for 12–18 hours.

Since this was my first attempt, I decided to start early in the morning so it would be finished by night. I didn’t want to leave it cooking overnight for Shabbat, as is traditionally done, because I was worried about possible accidents. I followed the instructions carefully. At one point I had to add more water because the liquid was thickening too quickly.

About five hours after I had reduced the heat, I noticed a burning smell. I ran a spoon along the bottom of the pot and realized that the entire bottom had burned. I immediately stopped cooking, transferred everything I could salvage into another bowl, and discovered a layer of burnt residue almost 3 cm thick on the bottom of the pot. It took me an hour and a half to scrape it all off.

The cholent itself ended up with a noticeable burnt flavor, although I actually liked the individual ingredients. I didn’t throw it away for the reason that I didn’t want to think of my health but rather to make sure I don’t die from hunger, so I decided to live with the smoky taste, which I compare to coffee. So now I’m calling it my “coffee cholent.”

Anyway, I’d like to learn from my mistakes so this doesn’t happen again. What could have caused it? Why does a cholent burn in the first place? It was simmering over very low heat (2 out of 9 on an electric stove), and there always seemed to be enough liquid. Is it possible that the pearl barley settled to the bottom and started burning? Or maybe the onions, which were supposed to form a protective layer, were the culprit? How can I prevent this from happening next time? For the reason of me being a poor student that embarrassingly
still doesn’t control the world‘s economy, I don’t own a slow cooker or any fancy equipment, just a regular pot with a regular lid.

u/b_bonderson — 20 hours ago

Gonna Dive In

Since I am recuperating from surgery and will be home a few weeks, I will finally have time to blow up my kitchen.

I’m a prospective convert and I know nothing about making challah bread or any bread for that matter. I’ve just good at cookies and cakes. I’m also hoping to learn to make a babka since I had that a lot because my grandmother was a 1st generation Polish-American.

Soooooo, while I look around this sub more (great recipes in general!), do you have any tips for beginners and then nights on what you wish you knew when you were first learning? Also, what do you do with all your mess-ups so you don’t waste anything?

reddit.com
u/pilotpenpoet — 20 hours ago

Accidental Challah Sandwich Loaf

Wanted to try the King Arthur Big Book of Bread challah recipe!

When I went to braid it though I kind of accidentally made really long strands and so I knew the end result would be a really long skinny loaf of bread. So I doubled it up and put it in a loaf pan to bake it more like a Babka. Here’s the final product!

u/SkinnyPete16 — 3 days ago

Cookbook recommendations

Hello! I'm looking for cookbook recommendations, ideally shtetl or early kibbutz cooking, anything that offers insight to the transition of culture through food, but any great cookbook for Shabbat will be appreciated.

reddit.com
u/nyc1282 — 2 days ago

Lentil, Mango, and Pea Salad

I adapted this salad from Adeena Sussman's cookbook "Zariv" by substituting some ingredients. This lentil, mango, and pea salad is greater than the sum of its parts and is quite tasty--a very refreshing dish during these hot summer days. Make sure to use black beluga lentils, which stay firm even after being cooked.

I am in the United States and so it is hard to find ripe mangos. But you can ripen them more quickly by putting an unripe mango in a brown paper bag with a banana or apple, for a couple of days. A ripe mango should give slightly when you squeeze it.

1.25 cups black beluga lentils, rinsed

12 oz green peas

6 tablespoons freshly squeezed lemon juice

1/4 cup olive oil

1 tablespoon honey

1 tablespoon Dijon mustard

1 tablespoon harissa

1 teaspoon salt

1/4 teaspoon black pepper

1 ripe mango, cut into small cubes

1 red bell pepper, diced

1/2 cup diced onion

1 cup mint leaves, thinly sliced

  1. Fill a pot halfway with generously salted water and bring to a boil over high heat. Add the lentils and cook until al dente, about 15 minutes.

  2. Add the peas, return the pot to a boil, and cook for 1-2 minutes until they are tender. Drain and rinse the lentils and peas, and let cool for 5 minutes.

  3. In a bowl, whisk together the lemon juice, olive oil, honey, mustard, harissa, salt, and pepper until everything is well combined. Add the lentils, peas, mango, bell pepper, onion, and mint and stir so the salad is coated with the dressing. Enjoy!

u/Hezekiah_the_Judean — 4 days ago

Challah Challenge: Itty Bitty Bread

Shalom! I hope everyone's week has been treating them well so far. Some of my gentile loved ones have taken me up on my offer to join me for Sabbath dinner, so I wanted to try my hand at some extra special itty bitty challahs. Any tips, tricks or critiques would be much appreciated, please. Toda Raba!

EDIT: Recipe is here

u/sorryimtheworst — 7 days ago

Coconut Chocolate Chip Rum Challah French Toast Casserole

I made the challah in advance (sub coconut water for regular water, add chocolate chips, and use rum simple syrup instead of an egg wash in your preferred challah recipe).

I added fresh bananas to the cubed challah and covered the baking dish with tin foil for the first 25 minutes per suggestions on the original recipe (see comment below). Greased the baking dish with coconut oil.

Recipe tastes like a cross between eggy French toast and bread pudding. Made about 12 servings.

Maple syrup isn’t necessary, but it’s decadently welcome.

u/AshkiHoneyCake — 9 days ago
▲ 413 r/JewishCooking+1 crossposts

I love soupless Matzo balls with minimal salt/pepper and I'm not afraid to admit it

I just like the texture and they're deceptively filling

u/ArtificialSatellites — 11 days ago

Accidentally invited too many people over for Rosh Hashanah dinner and now freaking out 😩 give me tips!!

I have 32 people coming over for Rosh. I’m freaking out. Normally I have 20-24 people and it’s ALOT. My mom makes chicken and brisket but she can’t make enough for 32 people this year. I might also make some extra brisket.

My MIL is making 1 kugel and charred broccolini. I’m gonna make string beans, Ruhama’s cabbage and quinoa salad (day before), Jeweled rice (day of). I’ll set up the tables the night before - we’ll have lots of folding tables and chairs. But give me your tips!!!

I have a 14 month old and luckily have child care all day Friday the day before we host the dinner

reddit.com
u/YofiTofi_ — 11 days ago

First time making challah!

My girlfriend and her family are Jewish so I wanted to make a good impression with this challah. After lots of lurking here trying to find a foolproof recipe, it worked out pretty well! Buzzing 🤩

u/bessj — 10 days ago
▲ 100 r/JewishCooking+1 crossposts

I NEED MATZA BALL HELP STAT

I live with my goyfriend (his words) and I’m the household cook. I often go grocery shopping on Saturday evening, so I was talking over next week’s dinners with him. Poor fella is sick, so he asked me to make chicken noodle soup. No problem! Then he asked if I could make Matza balls.

i tried to make matza balls one (1) whole time in my life, and the end result was so disastrous that I gave up on trying ever again without supervision. They fall apart in my fingers! I told the goyfriend that I couldn’t make matza balls. he teased, ”It’s like I’m dating a goy!”

Now, we tease each other about our ethnicities all the time. But this? This is a bridge too far!! This is a matter of Jewish honor!!!!! It is ABSOLUTELY VITAL that I learn how to make knock-your-socks-off matza balls in the next 24-48 hours. Help me, Reddit! What recipe should I use? What advice do you have?

reddit.com
u/nopingmywayout — 12 days ago

Challah advice?

Made my first challah! My partner is Jewish and I’d like to teach myself to prepare a few Jewish dishes that he doesn’t typically cook. I tried to make a challah for the first time and it turned out denser than I’d hoped. Any advice on how to get the lighter, airier texture? Thanks!

u/bonnaroojulia — 11 days ago

Jewish Cooks and Chefs You Recommend?

Over the last few years I have learning more about Jewish food and gradually teaching myself how to cook. A whole bunch of Jewish chefs have been immensely helpful--I've flipped through their cookbooks, tried a whole bunch of recipes, and listened to them explain Jewish cuisine and history. But there are so many great people out there, and I feel like I am missing a lot of them.

What Jewish chefs/cooks do you recommend, especially people who should be better known or who are up-and-coming? So far I have really learned from the following chefs:

Gil Marks

Leah Koenig

Adeena Sussman

Michael Twitty

Thank you and Shabbat Shalom!

reddit.com
u/Hezekiah_the_Judean — 14 days ago

Lung blintz?

I was talking to my 85 year old father and he told me he really misses his aunt jenny's "famous" lung blintz. I'd like to try and make it for him. Anybody have an old recipe? Is it even possible to buy lung meat? My father's side of the family were from Vitebsk, Belarus.

reddit.com
u/New_Background_9823 — 14 days ago

What was challah like before yeast was commercially available?

Maybe a good question for r/askfoodhistorians but I'm weary of asking about Jewish history related things in non-Jewish subs.

I have only made challah with instant or active dry yeast from the store. How was challah made before yeast was available like this? Was it more of a sourdough style with a starter?

Does anyone have any old challah recipes? I would love to try different ones out.

reddit.com
u/bitrog — 14 days ago