r/NancyGuthrieCase

Does anybody think this case will ever be successfully prosecuted? I don’t see them ever finding her body and it’s hard to have a successful case without a body especially without a motive. While I wish they would find Nancy that chance is nonexistent at this point. The detectives and FBI have lost their chance.

This post may not even be allowed because of some of the horrible possibilities mentioned in it...but it's based on the thoughts I've had since the very beginning of Mrs Guthrie's case. I tried posting it on the other thread, but haven't heard anything back from the mods. Am I allowed to submit the same post on different threads? I'm not sure how that works.

While following Mrs Guthrie's case daily on Reddit and other SM, I've read literally countless posts and comments suspecting family members of being responsible for the disappearance of Mrs Guthrie - most, if not all of them, focused on the motive of money.

Yet, from the beginning I've thought that (IMO) there would have been many simpler methods to "remove" Mrs Guthrie from the picture in order to acquire her money/estate/what have you (if that's what the goal was, by a member of the family). I apologize for how appalling this sounds: but in theory even a small planned push, a fall, a pillow, a little too much medicine (or the wrong type), an "accidental" cut or wound while on blood thinners, a slippery floor, tampering with a walking cane or car, etc, would provide the predators with the means to the end they were trying for, plus a convenient alibi. Mrs Guthrie's unfortunate accidental death. It would sound plausible for a distraught family member to tell LE "Oh I can't believe she tripped on the rug like that! She was only walking alone for a moment! We saw her start to fall on the steps, but we just couldn't reach her in time, and she hit her head!"

I don't have any answers to what DID happen or why, but imo it wasn't her family. I know that isn't a very popular take with many people. I'm only stating what I have come to feel regarding the case, so please don't attack me! But if it was/is a family member or members, why fabricate the entire intruder/ransom/porch loser mystery at all? Once again I apologize for the horrible possibilities I mentioned. These are all simply things I've wondered about.

My heart absolutely breaks for the entire Guthrie family and all the others close to Mrs Guthrie, and I only hope and pray this case is able to be solved and justice delivered.

Thoughts? Potential issues? Am I missing something incredibly obvious? Lol.

Guys stop caring about her she's a goddamn human being
Why do you care about a person who doesn't even know you
For example what happens when she's found what are you going to do

I hope this is allowed, my mom had a couple dreams about Nancy Guthrie and she thought maybe it meant something and I was wondering if a local could check a certain area.

In the first dream she was holding three feathers, I think she said one was brown, one was red and one was grey and she thought maybe it meant something. In the second dream she saw Nancy in a restaurant parking lot sitting under a telephone pole and she was alive.

I kind of wondered if the empty restaurant at 3 points (possible connection to the 3 feathers?) was what she saw in her dream. I showed her a picture of the restaurant and she said it did look like what she saw in her dream. I told a Youtuber about the dream but he only drove by the front of the restaurant to look.

Are any locals willing to go to the restaurant and look around the parking lot, especially around the telephone poles?

(If I broke any sub rules please just delete my post so I don't get banned)

Edit: my mom doesn't claim to be psychic or anything like that, she just felt the dream meant something, it probably was just a dream but it couldn't hurt to look there right?

I am deeply disturbed by the work history of sheriff Nanos, and frankly, I don’t know how he still has this job. I don’t feel he is trustworthy.

I also feel he’s incompetent. The house was just given a cursory search before it was returned to the family. I just knew this was premature and wrong. Didn’t anyone learn anything from the JonBenét Ramsey case?

After following this case from the beginning, I am beginning to think Nancy did not leave her home alive.

As to who her abductor was, I think that it’s a good possibility he had at one time done work around Nancy’s property. Either a small handyman job, or maybe he was part of a larger work crew, and Nancy didn’t know him specifically, but he thought she might be a good target for ransom.

I believe if she was killed accidentally, the abductor, realizing he now had no leverage for ransom, took the body to Mexico. There is plenty of desert land in Mexico where a body could be left, and wild animals will scavenge the body and eliminate evidence. There is so much remote territory to cover there that the likelihood of finding a body is slim to none. If the abductor also killed himself, the trail kind of ends there, and since efforts have been focused in Arizona, it makes sense that there has been no progress.

I hope that I am wrong, but I think this may be a case that forever goes unsolved.

I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again. This case will not be solved without a deathbed confession.

Why not?

1. Intelligent people are involved. This was very VERY well planned.
2. Nancy Guthrie was despised. Whoever did it knew this case would be scrutinized. Unfortunately, this is how the police work. If it’s a regular person, regular investigation. If it’s a high profile case they pull out all the stops.
3. She was not kidnapped, she was disappeared. Her body will not be found. See #1.

Miracle of miracles, bring Nancy Guthrie home to her family. It is Mother’s Day. Whoever you are - make a miracle happen. 🙏🏻