r/SherlockHolmes

▲ 9 r/SherlockHolmes+1 crossposts

Murders in the Rue Morgue

Going back to my childhood days (60s) there was a series of Basil Rathbone movies where he played Sherlock Holmes. I can swear that one of those movies was based on the Edgar Allan Poe book, Murders in the Rue Morgue. About a man who used a gorilla to kill his enemies. But I cannot find anything that shows me that Basil Rathbone was in this movie, in fact its the other way around! Does anyone remember ever watching this?

reddit.com
u/bilgsmf — 3 hours ago

Audiobook recommendation

I have a medical condition that make reading difficult for me, so audiobooks are now the main way I can still enjoy books.

I already have bought and greatly enjoyed "The Complete BBC Collection" with Clive Merrison.

I am also podcasting the Noiser adaptation with Hugh Bonneville. I love it and if I could buy it, I would. But since it's not available except in streaming, I wish I could find another version.

Among the Sherlock Holmes audiobooks I already have in my wish list, are those narrated by Kyle Hayes, Zacharias Prewett and Stephen Scalon, but I'm still on the fence.

I guess I'm a bit fussy. I strongly prefer unabridged versions and readers that are "acting" the text.

All that to say that I would really appreciate if you have any recommendations to help me make a choice! Thank you!

reddit.com
u/M4713H — 2 days ago

I think it's kind of funny how the bbc series made Mycroft into a more authentic Sherlock.

I always got the feeling that Mycroft in this series feels like a more classic Sherlock aside from a few throwaway lines about not having enough interest to do legwork in cases and his government role. The classic victorian like outfit with the watch chain and walking stick, the mannerisms.

I think Benedict Cumberbatch could make a more likeable Sherlock if given a script that respects the source material more without wanting to subvert and invert it.

If there was a episode where they removed the few Mycroft characteristics in Mark Gatiss's Mycroft and added just a little more eccentricity to his portrayal i think he would play a great Sherlock.

I don't like the more mean, cold and many times pretentious reinterpretation of Cumberbatch Sherlock, but it's funny to see that right there in the same exact show there is a better, more classic option walking around as another character.

u/martin__26 — 4 days ago

Some screengrabs from the Grenada series

I love the muted colours of these films as they appear on YouTube. Here are a few of my favourites.

u/FlapjacksOfArugula — 4 days ago

Valley of Fear

Having recently read The Return of Sherlock Holmes and finding some of the stories really exciting page turners I’m struggling with Valley of Fear. Pacing seems slow and can’t get into it. Anyone else have the same experience?

reddit.com
u/Able_Arm7411 — 5 days ago

I mapped where Sherlock Holmes secretly travelled during the two years everyone thought he was dead

I plotted the travel route, the flight across the Channel (London → Newhaven → Dieppe → Strasbourg) to Reichenbach, then the two years in Tibet in Lhasa and the head Lama, travelling under the name Sigerson through Persia, Mecca, a visit to the Khalifa at Khartoum and then months in a lab in Montpellier in the south of France before he finally walks back into Baker Street.

u/Dxsrespectful — 7 days ago

Granada Series, Question

I'm searching for the episode in which Sherlock and Watson travel to a country estate. In this story, Holmes is fighting a cold and is lethargic and bundled under a blanket as they travel in an open carriage. He is even more surley and short than usual. Can someone help identify the title?

reddit.com
u/Indiana_ECI — 5 days ago

Il Mio Libro apocrifo su Sherlock Holmes

Ciao amici lettori!

è uscito il mio primo libro apocrifo su due dei personaggi da me più amati: Sherlock Holmes e il Dottor Watson. Spero possa piacervi e sono interessato ai vostre feedback.

Un breve incipit sul libro:
Sherlock Holmes lascia Londra per inseguire un enigma tra le nebbie e i riflessi del Lido di Venezia.

Accanto al fedele dottor Watson, il celebre detective dovrà affrontare omicidi, segreti e un sentimento capace di corrompere anche gli animi più lucidi: la vendetta.

Sherlock Holmes – Omicidi e misteri al Lido di Venezia
di Andrea Di Molfetta
pubblicato da Delos Digital

Un nuovo mistero disponibile per tutti gli amanti di Sherlock Holmes e delle indagini dal fascino senza tempo.

📖 Amazon: https://www.amazon.it/dp/B0H6W42W41/
🔎 Delos Digital: http://dburl.it/D5598

u/Suspicious-Hyena-809 — 5 days ago

Ever wished the Guy Ritchie Sherlock had a tv series? The 2013 russian series 'Sherlock Holmes' does just that in it's 8 episodes

This series is inspired stylistically by the Guy Ritchie films. Though it has it's own flair, the mannerisms and character of Sherlock and Watson feel similar enough to the movies to where it feels like it could be a prequel series in a way to the movies, focusing more on classic mysteries than the action movie style of the Guy Ritchie films.

It loosely adapts remixed versions of the book stories.

It feels like a cross between the soviet 'the adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Watson' and the movies. What i appreciate is that though it's faithful enough to the style of the books it gives it's own fresh flair to the mannerisms and behaviour of Holmes and Watson.

A detail i enjoyed in the movies is that they make Mrs. Hudson younger, the series also does this. She's more involved and more of a character in some ways in this series. There is a good bit of Russian humor and charm throughout the series.

I'm on episode five right now and as someone who doesn't know russian i still find the series very charming and lovable. It gives Watson more of a spur on the story and more personality without departing from the good hearted, nice personality of the books.

It's a charming remix of events and characteristics from the books that i would reccomend to Holmes fans.

u/martin__26 — 7 days ago

Granada Dancing Men Fanart

Hey everyone!

A few weeks ago, I did a collage illustration based off of Granada's adaptation of A Scandal in Bohemia, and I decided to continue that idea and move on to the next episode, The Dancing Men. I don't know if I will do this with every single episode or just my favorite ones, but so far the two categories are one and the same, so I can put off that decision for a while yet. Anyway, hope you like it!

u/noodalie-saloon — 8 days ago
▲ 628 r/SherlockHolmes+1 crossposts

The most terrifying art of the Hound I’ve ever come across.

Longtime fan of the Holmes canon, introduced to it by a ladybird children’s tape and book adaptation (I still have the tape, but not the book) when I was 7 years old, I’m 50 now. I still read The Hound of the Baskervilles at least once a year and the rest of the canon approx every 3-4 years. I’ve seen every film or tv version of HOUN that I can conceivably get hold of and the thing that always bothered me is that the ‘star’ of the book, the Hound, was never scary enough. Some adaptions did better than others, but none have really nailed it the way Conan Doyle wrote it.

This image I found several years ago but I have no idea where it is from, this is my idea of the Hound, something to keep you awake at night, like poor Sir Charles. If someone knows who the artist is or if this is from some adaption please comment.

First post on this sub, hope I’ve stuck to the community rules.

u/5norkleh3r0 — 11 days ago

What cases/stories have you deduced before the reveal?

Recently I have come across the Sherlock Holmes short stories presented by Noiser on Spotify and they've been fantastic since I rarely get time to read the stories as often as I'd like. As I have been going through them there have been only 3 that I have been able to deduced the criminal and actions before Sherlock's reveal: The Adventure of Thor Bridge, A Case of Identity, and The Adventure of the Sussex Vampire. So I figured I'd ask my fellow Sherlock enjoyers if they have done the same for other stories and what ones?

reddit.com
u/DWedge — 9 days ago

Wells/Conan Doyle collab

Hi all, great to find this sub. As well as Holmes, Im also a huge War of the Worlds fan, and I was thinking recently what Holmes and Watson would have made of the Martian invasion.

It could make a great story!

In the meantime, I’ve been working on a card game engine with a standard pack of cards, and the first two implementations of it have been fit WotW and the Holmes canon. But now I’m thinking of combining the two: Holmes vs the Martians. Maybe Holmes and Moriarty join forces to beat them.

reddit.com
u/philgooch — 7 days ago

Sherlock and the rise of modern London

One of the reasons Holmes still feels modern is that he arrives at exactly the moment London is becoming a modern city.

The Holmes stories are full of new technology and institutions. Railways, the Underground, telegraphs, newspapers, forensic science and an increasingly professional police force all shape the way Holmes works. He isn’t solving crimes in Dickens’s London. He’s navigating a fast-moving city where information, people and criminals can disappear almost overnight.

Holmes himself seems perfectly suited to that world. He gathers data, tests evidence, builds networks of informants and adapts to change. In many ways, he’s as much a product of modern London as Baker Street itself.

It makes me wonder whether Holmes could have existed fifty years earlier. Strip away the growing city, the communications network and the pace of Victorian London, and would the consulting detective have been possible at all?

I’m curious what others think. Did Doyle create Holmes, or did modern London create the need for someone like Holmes?

reddit.com
u/apeel09 — 8 days ago