r/academia

▲ 1 r/academia+1 crossposts

Feeling disillusioned with publishing and research in general

Honestly, I'm getting pretty disillusioned with publishing, and I'm feeling like giving up.

I've had multiple rejections recently, with little to no feedback, and I'm starting to question what the long-term payoff is supposed to be. You can spend days or weeks working on a paper, submit it, get rejected, rework it for another journal, and then potentially go through the whole thing again.

I enjoy research, but I'm finding it hard to justify the amount of time and effort that goes into publishing when there's no guarantee it'll actually lead anywhere. Also, reading posts about how journals can be biased, focused on profit margins, or even political doesn't really help. Anyway.

Being a woman in engineering is another part of this. I often get really awful looks in my workplace and feel deeply unwelcome. I know this isn't always the case, and things are changing, but it's still a very hard thing to deal with day to day.

I don't know. I'm just getting tired of putting so much into this without being able to see where it's going.

Has anyone else been at this point? Particularly women in engineering or related fields, or people who've taken a less conventional path through research. Did things eventually start to make more sense?

reddit.com
u/Suncitydweller — 3 days ago
▲ 193 r/academia

DID I WIN THE JACKPOT????

Just got my reviewers reports' back and both the reviewers recommended accept!! This was the first report!

Reviewer 2 wrote and I quote "An interesting, well written essay. I don’t think it had dawned on me before the #*the main thesis of my paper*. I enjoyed the essay and felt I learnt a lot about things I conceptually had not considered before. I would urge the author to publish this work in #*the journal name.*"

I'M ON THE NINTH CLOUD NOW OH MY GODDESS!! The reviewer actually said that s/he had learnt something new from my paper!!

Yayy!

(Posted this on /AskAcademia too. Too happy not to share this with other researchers! :) )

reddit.com
u/calliope_carcosa — 11 days ago

Inside the Enrollment Cliff Hitting US Colleges | Bloomberg

>America’s college-age population is shrinking, putting pressure on universities with high fixed costs and fewer students to fill their campuses. Schools like Bowling Green State are responding by adding career-focused programs and trying to stand out in a crowded market, while institutions that fail to adapt are facing cuts, closures and economic fallout for the towns that depend on them.

youtube.com
u/PopCultureNerd — 11 days ago

Which is better: Pregnant or recently postpartum on job market?

I’m a postdoc and will be looking for assistant professor jobs next cycle. Simultaneously, my partner and I are ready to start the journey toward our first child. Assuming we are able to time things out (which, I realize, is a big assumption), which would be preferable: being pregnant or having an infant on the job market?

Please help a wannabe mom pretend like I have some semblance of control over this situation! Thank you!!

reddit.com
u/midwestmedusa — 10 days ago