
r/Backloggd Community Top 250 NOMINATIONS THREAD
r/Backloggd Community Top 250 ANNOUNCEMENT POST
Hello again everyone! As I had already announced a few days prior, I am posting the nominations thread for this year’s community top 250 list of favorite games of this subreddit. I will be reposting the rules in this post and I will post my ballot in the comments which will act as a template ballot for you all to follow.
The rules are as follows below:
How this will work is that each of you can nominate up to ten different games to be nominated for the list. Your ballots will be based on a points based voting system where the number one game you vote for will receive ten votes, then the number of votes lessens as the list goes on. I will post an example ballot in the nominations thread so you can all see what it looks like.
If you nominate a game that is an expanded game or a “complete” edition of a previously released game, then your vote will go towards the original base game by default. For example, if you nominate Persona 5: Royal and/or Cyberpunk 2077: Ultimate Edition, your vote will go towards the original Persona 5 and Cyberpunk 2077 by default. This is to make sure there’s not a single game taking up multiple spots on a list and other games have a chance to be represented.
Remakes will be counted as standalone titles, but any votes going towards remasters will just go towards the original, base game. I am counting remakes as games that are made entirely new from the ground up, but keep the same story/characters from the original. Remasters are games that keep the original design and mechanics of the original game intact, but just give it a new code of paint for “modern” standards. For example, a vote towards Silent Hill 2 Remake would go towards that game, but a vote for Metroid Prime: Remastered would just default back to the original Metroid Prime.
“Expandalone” games would count as individual entries, but DLCs that are only playable through their original base game would not count. For example, Uncharted: The Lost Legacy would be eligible for voting, but Elden Ring: Shadow Of The Erdtree would not.
If you vote for an entire series on a single spot, then your vote will automatically default to the highest rated game in that series. For example, if you just put “Mass Effect trilogy” on your ballot as one of your picks, your vote will default towards Mass Effect 2.
Just like last year, I have decided to exclude any games released in the current calendar year - 2026 - from being nominated for the list. I want this community list to be made up of predominantly games that you have really spent a lot of time with and to help combat recency bias. Anything released before 2026 would be eligible though!
I will keep this thread open for nominations for as long as it stays active. Last year’s winner was ELDEN RING with 291 votes. Let’s see if it gets dethroned this year!