r/cookiedecorating

How long do you leave your cookies out for?

I bake my cookies on one day, and decorate the next. I will then leave them out to dry overnight before packaging them in a sealed bag.
Sometimes I just don’t get around to finish decorating them all in one day though and that’s when I start getting nervous they’ll dry out and taste stale - they never did, but I also never went past that second day.
It gives me great anxiety and I can’t stop thinking and hearing the clock ticking in my ear, reminding me the cookies are sitting out and getting stale by the second 🥲
How long do you feel comfortable leaving your cookies out? How long does it usually take you on average to complete a set (of say a dozen) of cookies? Am I panicking for no reason? Any trick to help prevent them from getting hardened/stale?

reddit.com
u/jbishop2110 — 8 hours ago

Granddaughter's birthday

Cookies for my granddaughter's 3rd birthday this weekend! It's a bubbles and water games party. I forgot to take pictures of the small round bubble cookies I also made before putting them in the freezer. LOL

u/EducationalRule1425 — 19 hours ago

Fourth time doing cookies - kudos to all you people who do it full time! This almost broke me 😅

I was originally asked to do 30 cookies but the customer upped it to 50. Logos are HARD. How is this a profitable line of work?! I do cakes and cupcakes mainly which are quite profitable but my husband advised I never take another cookie order again. Any tips? I’m pretty sure my consistency was wrong about 80% of the time so that’s something I need to work on.

u/nycleigh — 1 day ago

Total beginner 😢

I work as a cake decorator for a grocery store, and recently my manager threw 120 baby shower cookies at me and my team who know next to nothing about decorating sugar cookies.

At my work we use Brill White & Glossy icing to frost the cookies, and normally we just heat the icing and dip the cookies and that’s that. The past couple days I’ve been trying to treat the w&g like it’s royal icing, haven’t heated it up, and put it into piping bags and tried my best to work with decorating on top of a base layer of icing my coworkers did before I started in on them.

My problem is that I can’t stop getting bubbles even after popping them all (photos 1&2).Today I put away a tray of bear cookies and when I came back later to look at them, all the eyes had holes in them? My other colors of icing had the same issue, bubbles popping and making holes in my otherwise okay first attempt at decorating.

I did “helicopter” my bags and it helped a bit but it did not eliminate the issue.

Another issue is the discoloration of the icing on the base layer and on some of my outlines as well (photo 3). Does anyone know why or how this happens? It lightens the color and looks maybe like it’s crystallizing.

Is there any advice you wish you’d had when you started decorating cookies? Has anyone else had to use Brill White & Glossy to ice cookies before? Any tips would be appreciated.

u/_alienchild_ — 1 day ago

Earlier this week I made a Mario cookie topper. I used the leftovers for pizza cookies

My favourite project yet. Leftover dough and icing. I grated the white chocolate leftover from another project, and while trying to melt it, it kinda browned like real cheese- a happy accident. The gummy 'pepperoni' are cherry candies I cut up because my friend (these are for her birthday) loves a gummy❤️

u/jsundin — 1 day ago

I have a Pride market coming up, what would you love to see represented? (not my image)

As stated above, what would you love to see represented? Yes I can go with the generic rainbows, but I want to get to create something that is more personal to people. That will make people feel they are represented in a more personal way. So what would you love to see more of!

▲ 125 r/cookiedecorating+1 crossposts

DISCLAIMER: Not a professional! Just make cookies for the grandkids’ events.

All my grandkids have birthdays in the summer, so they don’t get to celebrate at school, so I bake cookies for them to take for the last week of school. This is just a fun “art project” for me, so be kind! 😀

u/SassyFace1919 — 2 days ago

I made a 3D cookie bouquet. Yes, the vase is a cookie too!

This is the most ambitious thing I’ve ever made. I didn’t think it was possible and lots of flowers/stems broke in the process, but I’m obsessed with it. Honestly, I’m surprised with how well it turned out and it’s opened up possibilities for some new ideas!

u/futuremrscjl — 4 days ago

Cookie topper for my kid's birthday cake

Cookies are huge - about 6" wide and 8" tall. I hope they stay standing lol.

u/jsundin — 4 days ago