r/mutualfunds

1 year Clear winner 🏆 Quant flexi

1 year Clear winner 🏆 Quant flexi

I know I know... 1 year is too short to judge anything let alone long term investment such as MF.

But here my argument is Last 1 year been nightmare for fund manager's in india. Shouldn't we evaluate the performance of fund's in this tough phase rather than gunho phase happened in indian market like 2023-2024?

Another area of concern is PPFCF aum reaching mammoth size compared to Quant, which is under 7k crore. That is more manageable and easy to work with.

Ignore my investment amount since i was testing out.

For new SIPer, which one will be your choice based on above arguments only? So one can start SIP on that

Thanks

u/Acrobatic_Milk786 — 9 hours ago

Portfolio Review: Starting a ₹1.76L/Month SIP + ₹7L Lump Sum. Thoughts on this structure?

Hey everyone,

I'm just starting my investment journey at 31, and would really appreciate a review of my current portfolio.

I'm not married and I own a house, so I don't need to worry about rent and stuff. Coming from a middle class family, I also don't spend a lot on other random stuff unless necessary. I'm wondering if I can aggresively build wealth with this portfolio. I'm looking at a 30 year horizon with a moderate to high risk tolerance.

Debt: ₹0

Emergency Fund: ₹7L (Savings Account)

Salary: ₹2.15L/month

Expenses: ~₹15k/month

Savings: ~₹25k/month

Investments: ~₹1.76L/month

Investment Breakdown:

UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund: ₹40k/month

HDFC Flexi Cap Fund: ₹25k/month

Parag Parikh Flexi Cap: ₹25k/month + ₹2L Lumpsum

Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund: ₹25k/month + ₹1L Lumpsum

Nippon India Small Cap Fund: 25k/month

UTI Nifty Next 50 Index Fund: ₹15k/month

Axis Liquid Fund: ₹10k/month

Edelweiss US Technology Equity FoF: ₹5k/month

Edelweiss US Value Equity Offshore: ₹5k/month

Nippon India Gold Savings Fund: ₹1k/week

Nippon India Nifty 50 Value 20 Index Fund: ₹3L Lumpsum

S&P500 (US): ₹1L Lumpsum

Now, is holding both HDFC and Parag Parikh Flexi Cap redundant? Should I consolidate it into just one of the two? Also, I'm doing a 1k/week SIP for the gold investment since it seems to be at an all time high now.

I'd appreciate any constructive criticism, portfolio optimization ideas, or red flags you guys can spot. Thanks in advance!

reddit.com
u/Funny_Negotiation_29 — 7 hours ago
▲ 3 r/mutualfunds+1 crossposts

Just started investing, review and suggestions please

Risk appetite: Moderate

Goal: Wealth creation

Horizon: 10-12

App used: Groww

Allocation : 2500 monthly sip into PPFC, 2000 monthly sip into nifty next 50index, 3000 lumpsum into ICICI prudential Bharat 22 FOF

age 19, please review my portfolio and advice

also, can I have a second goal along? I'm a bachelor but would plan for a car/trip/education in 5 years.. living with parents and no big expense as such for now.

u/aunaprendiz — 14 hours ago
▲ 6 r/mutualfunds+1 crossposts

Messed up portfolio - Please advice.

Risk appetite: Moderate

Goal: Wealth creationism

Horizon: 8-10 years

Allocation: Inserted in the picture

App used: Groww

Hey everybody,

I know my portfolio is real messy as I started investing not through proper research but random suggestions from people around me.

The biggest mistake here is two regular SIPs, I want to convert, however I am worried about deductions as the first SIP has crossed 1.5 Lac returns while the second one has only made 11.5 K, I want to relocate my funds into better MF before its too late. I was new to MF back then, I have started to understand it now however there's still a lot to learn..

Please guide me through this.

Anybody who can advice, big thanks to you!

u/aunaprendiz — 20 hours ago

Do not rate my portfolio

I started investing in July - September 2024 (right at the TOP of the Bull Market).

And I’ve been investing randomly since last two years. As soon as one of my FD expires, I put it into my portfolio of 50% PPFAS and 50% US equity.

I know PPFAS also have 10% exposure to US equity. And that’s exactly what I want and I’m OK with overweighting those mega tech companies.

Give Me a advice

Hello I am 23yr old and currently i have 3 lakh in lump sum and I am going to join a job from july and i am going to have 50k after rental and food expenses and iam planning to do 25k sip. As iam young I am in plan of investing 10k in small cap and 10k in midcap and 5k foreign exposure for 5-6 yrs.

As I am new to mutual funds give me good financial advice out of your experience

reddit.com
u/narasegowdabm — 14 hours ago

Please review my SIPs , beginner investor

Also , if I want to double my investments 30k (current) to 60k (later) , what would you suggest , should I just double all the SIPs I have currently?

Investment Horizon - 5 years

Medium Risk

u/Bright-Profession874 — 20 hours ago

22, planning for gold etf, or sip in general.. please suggest

I get 2k as my pocket money, pls be kind and open for giving advice....thank you in advance

u/vanillawcoffee — 21 hours ago

Rate my portfolio

Should I stop this liquid fund ? I am just a student so please don't judge my amount 😭 🙏.

Investment horizon - long term

Risk - moderate

u/No_Paratha — 1 day ago

Rate my portfolio (21 just started job)

21, just started my first job and recently began investing through SIPs of ₹5k/month.

Risk tolerance: Medium
Investment horizon: 5+ years

Trying to build a solid long term mutual fund portfolio while learning along the way. Would appreciate direct and honest suggestions on fund selection, allocation, overlap, or anything I should improve as a beginner investor.

u/yeetlord1217 — 1 day ago

Advice and Suggestions Needed

Hi Everyone!

After studying, searching and going through various posts in this sub. I have finalized the above mentioned Portfolio.

Monthly SIP Amount: 25000

Annual Step Up: 10%

Investment Horizon: 20-25 years.

Risk Appetite/Tolerance - Aggressive

Reason for selecting funds- Mentioned in Snapshot

Please Review this portfolio and give your valuable feedback!

u/are_nhi_yaar — 1 day ago

Pls answer

I was thinking of investing 40% into bandhan Bank small cap, 10% into hdfc midcap and 50% in flexicap(of my total lumpsum) how is this

PS: I am a newbie, kindly advice. Also this is my current portfolio but I have done arbitrary investments and want to straighten out. This was my idea on how to invest my lumpsum. Pls advice. Horizon-3 to 4 years

u/freebeeAK — 1 day ago

Rate my portfolio, advice and feedback welcome

20 Years, 2nd year college student

Horizon : 5+ years

Risk appetite : Low-medium

I've been investing for 3 months now, just added PPFCP yesterday.

Any advice or feedback is welcome, as I am just beginning.

u/MeowtorSportz — 1 day ago

Debt fund doubt

I have some money parked in hdfc ultra short term debt fund , from which daily stp is ongoing to equity fund . I am observing this for few days that when market is in positive then my debt fund is giving negative returns and when market is in negative it is giving positive returns. Can anyone tell why this is happening.

reddit.com
u/Pitiful-Grass5692 — 1 day ago
▲ 24 r/mutualfunds+1 crossposts

What's going wrong 😭 Shall I continue?

Age: 29

Investment Goal: Wealth creation

Risk Appetite: Moderate

Investment Horizon: 15-20 years

Platform: Coin

Monthly SIP: ₹27500

Allocation:

Quant large cap - 32%

HDFC Multi cap - 24%

Bandhan Small Cap - 20%

ICICI prudential flexi cap - 24%

HDFC NIFTY LargeMidcap 250 Index fund - 1L lumpsum

Reasoning:

I chose these funds based on past 3-5 years performance only. There is one lump sum NFO that was suggested by someone that I bought.

IDK what's right or wrong is the market like it my funds are not performing. It has just been a year so shall I wait for a couple more years or so?

Also want to know if I add a new fund or replace existing with a different fund after 3-4 years then I would lose the compounding momentum for this duration? Am I thinking correct? How to handle this? Basically how to restructure a portfolio?

Why is my XIRR -13%, is that legit?

u/Miserable-Feed-5134 — 2 days ago

Please rate and give suggestions on my portfolio!

Risk Appetite: Moderate to aggressive 📈

Goal: Wealth creation 🤑

Horizon: 10-15 years 🗓️

Allocation: Rs.35000 per month SIP 🏦

  • Nippon large cap - 4000
  • Edelweiss mid cap - 6000
  • Invesco small cap - 5000
  • HDFC Flexi cap - 3500
  • Kotak multi cap - 2500
  • ICICI Multi asset allocation fund - 4000
  • ICICI short term debt fund - 6500
  • SBI Gold - 2500
  • Axis silver Fof - 1000

App used: Grow 📱

Why these funds: 🤔

I created this portfolio to align with my risk appetite, trying to use one fund each from Flexi, Multi, Large, Mid and Small caps. I added Multi asset allocation fund for its balanced approach (I have my doubts about the utility of this fund in my portfolio). Short term debt fund for stability. And commodities as hedge. Allocation across asset classes comes out to:

  • Equity - 60%
  • Hybrid - 11.4%
  • Debt - 18.6%
  • Commodities - 10%

And equity allocation across market caps comes out to around:

  • Large cap - 41%
  • Mid cap - 34%
  • Small cap - 23%

I picked the funds based on Valueresearch and Morningstar ratings, rolling returns and expense ratios, to the best of my ability.

reddit.com
u/Awkward_Pick_4911 — 1 day ago
▲ 4 r/mutualfunds+1 crossposts

Feedback on MF portfolio

Please give your honest feedback on this portfolio

Risk profile : Aggressive

Time Horizon : 10 years.

u/Fire_Ind_hope — 2 days ago
▲ 0 r/mutualfunds+1 crossposts

Sip recommendation

Hi, I am a working professional.
I want to invest 45k per month via sip in mutual funds.

I am an aggressive investor. Long term horizon.
Open to indian as well as global markets.

Please suggest which funds shall i invest in and how much?

reddit.com
u/FrontAutomatic1272 — 1 day ago

Portfolio Review

Hi, I am 32 having a 7L portfolio in MF already and starting a SIP - 60k step up 10% yearly with below every month now. I am open to invest in diversified portfolio, newly added Midcap, Gold, Silver(12k SIP) and Foreign

I want suggestions on the diversified allocation and the funds that I need to select.

Risk Profile - Moderate
Investment Goal - Wealth Creation and Children
Investment Horizon - 13-15 years
Allocation Details- as attached below
Why these funds- Been investing in
PPFlexi - didn’t fell even when Nifty fell
UTI Nifty 50 - Index
Invesco and Nippon Small caps - small cap

Which app do you use? - Coin

u/everBeliever — 1 day ago