r/piratesofthecaribbean

So after watching all of the movies again for like the 10th time, imo what ever they do with potc 6 its not worth watching now that barbossa is gone.

What im hoping for is that the producers do a plot twist and have barbossa alive but only because he is cursed in some way or saved by calypso

Did it grow back in his chest while he was sailing under the sea on the Dutchmen, or is he still a heartless man just no longer bound by the rules set by Calypso?

The dead guys all came back intact and alive, despite being dead for ages, and supposedly the crew of the Dutchmen reverted to normal again when the Trident was broken…but Will had his heart cut out and stuck into a chest. And his heart was stabbed when he had it cut out. So shouldn’t he have died if the curses being undone meant you got back to default before the curse?

In "At World's End" Jack Sparrow is about to stab Davy Jones's heart when Davy Jones stabs Will Turner, so they have Will Turner stab Davy Jones's heart so he will live as the new ferry man of souls.

But if Jack stabbed Davy Jones's heart then Jack would be the ferry man and wouldn't Jack, as the ferry man, have the authority to free Will's soul from death?

Will would have died at sea and Jack would now be in a position to determine where Will's soul goes. Davy Jones often uses his power to force people to be his crew, and he has the power to free people from his crew; Jack could take Will's soul and free him to live.

Or is the option when you die at sea to either go to the afterlife or serve as the crew of the Flying Dutchman? Not to just go home safe and sound.

So, on a recent rematch, I asked myself the question: What if, during the argument, Will is able to get the key open, the chest, and well kill Jones.

So dose the crew know who killed him or are they going to try and get the whole group in for questioning just to see who did it. I mean, indont think Will would hide what he did, but are the members of the Dutchmans crew going to explain how the curse works to them.

Didn't know if this was me just thinking way to hard on this one.

I see this opinion put forward that Jack is essentially a side character in the first POTC movie and it really makes no sense to me. I mean, yes, it’s true he doesn’t have the character development of Will and Elizabeth, but that doesn’t mean he’s not the protagonist. Everything about the movie tells us he’s the main character.

First of all we have bog standard screen time. Jack gets 44 minutes compared to only 35 mins and 31 mins for Elizabeth and Will respectively. Then in terms of driving the plot he’s vitally important as it all ultimately trickles back to when he was captain of the Black Pearl leading up to Barbossa’s mutiny. Will and Elizabeth ultimately grow as characters because of Jack’s interjection into their lives. Will’s story is the classic hero’s tale, yes, like Luke in A New Hope. But Jack isn’t the Han Solo character who doesn’t appear for the first 40 minutes, he’s involved in the plot at the 10 minute mark. So I really don’t understand why people seem to think he only became the main character in the later films because the truth is he always was.

I’m watching for the first time and just saw the scene of them reuniting, she’s happy to see him and still loves him so I’m wondering why she didn’t go to him in human form earlier? Was there something I missed? I’m not talking about the reunion she missed at the beginning that caused all of this, but once she was bound to human form she could have still went to him. She easily found the Flying Dutchman in the 2nd movie for Jack and Will but maybe I’m missing something.

Universe 100 (Canon / Main)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Call of the Kraken (1530) (Davy Jones knows about Cortes and the Mao Kun Map mentions his locker which was made roughly after 1523, so Jones had to become captain around the 1500s)

Battle for Buccaneer Gold (1600s) (Only info on this is that it was during the Golden age of Piracy)

The Secret of Galileo's Diary (C. 1610 - 1751) (Roughly when Galileo starting journaling

Pirates of the Caribbean (2003 video game) (1630-1631) (States in Game)

New Orleans Square (July 24, 1688) (Year New Orleans was built irl)

Blue Bayou Restaurant (1688) (Was built with New Orleans Square in lore)

El Teatro Fandango (1690) (Stated in theatre itself)

Jack Sparrow: The Coming Storm (1706)

Jack Sparrow: The Siren Song (1706)

The Nosy Stranger (1706)

Jack Sparrow: The Pirate Chase (1706)

Jack Sparrow: The Sword of Cortés (1706)

Jack Sparrow: The Age of Bronze (1706)

Jack Sparrow: Silver (1707)

Jack Sparrow: City of Gold (1707)

Jack Sparrow: The Timekeeper (1707)

Jack Sparrow: Dance of the Hours (1707)

Jack Sparrow: Sins of the Father (1707)

Jack Sparrow: Poseidon's Peak (1707)

Jack Sparrow: Bold New Horizons (1707)

Jack Sparrow: The Tale of Billy Turner and Other Stories (1707)

The Compass of Destiny! (1708) (Jack was stated to obtain his compass 10 years prior to CoTBP this story is likely him obtaining it for Morgan)

Pirates League (1710) (Ties in with the Ride)

Pirates of the Caribbean (ride) (1710) (Jack after freeing the Rogue Pirates and escaping starting the rivalry with Barbossa and Hector hunted him down to Isla Tesoro)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Armada of the Damned (1713)

The Price of Freedom (1715-1716)

Legends of the Brethren Court: The Caribbean (1716)

Legends of the Brethren Court: Rising in the East (1716)

The Shanghai Tigers (1716) (Rising in the East states that Jack has to fight Sao Feng and Ching, this story has him fight Sao Feng)

The Dragon Tile (1716) (Rising in the East states that Jack has to fight Sao Feng and Ching, this story has him fight Sao Feng)

Legends of the Brethren Court: The Turning Tide (1716)

Legends of the Brethren Court: Wild Waters (1717)

Legends of the Brethren Court: Day of the Shadow (1717)

The Island of Fortune (1718) (Bootstrap is still apart of the Crew)

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (video game) (1718) (Shows the mutiny)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Isles of War (1718) (Is after the mutiny)

Pirates of the Caribbean (ride, Paris) (1718) (The Wicked Wench looks very identical to the Queen Anne's Revenge so this was likely during Blackbeard's reign on the seas)

The Black Heart of the Pearl (1728) (Jack is still searching for the Pearl)

Tales of the Code: Wedlocked (1728)

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (September 15th, 1728) (Stated on Jack's execution paper)

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Missing Pirate (During or before Jack’s arrival)

The Accidental Pirate! (September 17th, 1728) (During Jack’s sail to Isla de Mureta)

A Mysterious Light! (1728 September 18th) (On Rummruner’s)

The Sails of Doom (September 24th, 1728)

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Legend of Jack Sparrow (September 26th, 1728) (Flashbacks in 1720 and 1728)

The Guardians of Windward Cove (September 27th, 1728)

Smoke on the Water (September 28th, 1728)

Banshee’s Boon (September 28th, 1728)

Mother of Water (September 29th, 1728)

Revenge of the Pirates! (August, 1728)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Online (October 31, 1728 - June 15th, 1729)

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Legend of Pirates Online (June 16th, 1729 - ongoing)

Captain Jack's - Restaurant des Pirates (1729) (Jack and Angelica reunited after Jack regained the Black Pearl)

The Capture of Jack Sparrow! (January 1729)

In Jack We Trust! (February 1729)

A Revolting Development! (April 1729)

The Sidekick! (1729)

The Duel (1729)

Legend of the Aztec Idol! (1729)

Open Sesame! (1729)

Chain Reaction! (1729)

Going Overboard!

The Treasure of Shipwreck Island

The Trouble With Pirates!

The Dark Skull

Double Duel

Legends Lost!

The Star of the Seas

The Eye of Despair!

The Eyes Have It!

The Lost Sea

Pirates of the Caribbean: A Storm at Sea

Tears of the Goddess

Pirates of the Caribbean: Ghost Ship

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest (June 21st, 1729) (Seen on the papers of the arrest warrants and Weatherby's papers)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest (video game) (1729)

Breakout! (June 22nd, 1729)

The Escape of Pintel and Ragetti (June 22nd, 1729)

The Sleeping Island! (June 22nd, 1729)

Pearly Gaze! (June 22nd, 1729)

The Haunting of Jack Sparrow! (1729 after Jack's escape on Isla de Pelegostos)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Escape from Davy Jones (1729 before the end of DMC)

The Journey of Will Turner! (1729 is Will's journey to Isla Cruces)

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End (Video Game) (1728-1729)

Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End (August 1729) (Two Months after DMC)

The Challenge! (1729 the Crew's journey to Davy Jones' Locker)

The Secret Files of the East India Trading Company (1729)

Siren's Revenge / Shipwreck Shore (June 16, 1729-1749) (Gibbs captained this ship after AWE)

Quiet Life (1729) (No information on this on the Wiki)

Barbossa’s Bounty (1732) (Barbossa likely made this for Margaret)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales: The Brightest Star in the North: The Adventures of Carina Smyth (1740 - 1751)

A Pirate's Adventure: Treasures of the Seven Seas (1746) (This shows Blackbeard's hunt for Barbossa after Hector steals the treasure from Blackbeard)

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (mobile game) (1750)

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (1750)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Master of the Seas (1750) (Uses a OST Poster)

Trader Sam’s Tiki Bar (1750) (Jack visited this bar after OST but prior to DMTNT)

Tortuga Tavern (1750) (Has Blackbeard's Crew Roster)

The Beak and Barrel (1750) (Has a mermaid's tear and ships in bottles)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales (1751)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Tides of War (1751) (Dead Men Tell No Tales is mentioned in this)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Battle for the Sunken Treasure (1751) (Story can easily take place after Jones' resurrection)

Sea of Thieves: A Pirate’s Life (1751)

The Legend of Captain Jack Sparrow (1751) (Chalices of Ponce De Leon is seen)

The Return of Jack Sparrow (1751) (Jack has the Pearl, no Davy Jones and no Hector)

Pirate's Lair on Tom Sawyer Island (1751) (Davy is dead, Will and Elizabeth were here so it had to be after his curse was broken)

Enter… the Scarecrow! (1776) (When the Scarecrow book takes place)

Peter Pan / Hook (1904)

Castaway Cay (June 24 - July, 2006)

The Pirates' Guidelines (May 15-22, 2007)

Shipwreck Shore (June 16, 2016)

Universe-1718 (Non-Canon)

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (1728)

The Buccaneer's Heart! (Summer - 1728)

Story of this Canon: The Codex was set down in the third court by Henry Morgan and Bartholomew Roberts, with Morgan living longer with his alchemy before dying. Blackbeard would not study voodoo and would stay deceased.

Universe-182013 (Infinity-Canon)

Disney Infinity Pirates Play Set (1729)

Story of this Canon: Jack and Barbossa didn’t have a mutiny, and so COTBP did not happen. So Will and Elizabeth did not met Jack. Beckett did not gain the Dead Man’s Chest and so the Brethren Court was not summoned. Blackbeard has a fleet of ships. Jack did not make a debt with Davy Jones so the Black Pearl could still be sunk as Jack sails a new unnamed ship. This ship could’ve been the one he returned from the Locker from. The Kraken is taken by Jack and the Dutchman sinks.

Universe-13122 (Brickbuilt-Canon)

LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean (Sets and Game) (1728-1750)

Story of this Canon: The Films with differences

I have the months for OST, DMTNT, and SoT but not on me will update!!!!