
It's always surprised me how big Ikarishipping is when Dawn and Paul have like 4 scenes interacting face-to-face
From the amount of ship warring and fanart, you would think it was Contestshipping (May x Drew) 2.0.
During DPPT, I was a big Appealshipper (Zoey x Dawn). I was confused about Ikarishippping. Their main interaction happened over halfway through the arc, didn't it? I at least understood Penguinshipping/Kenny x Dawn (childhood friends, Kenny's canon crush) and Pearlshipping/Ash x Dawn (mentor/mentee relationship, strong bond). Ikarishipping though? Eh...
Ikarishipping feels like a ship people like the idea of. They go together in theory, not in reality.
I'm a big Soulsilvershipping/Lyra x Silver and Redemptionshipping/Kris x Silver fan. I see the similarities. The dynamic is similar. The difference is that Dawn and Paul aren't rivals, though. Ash is first to Paul, not Dawn. So, the ships are written differently despite base similarities.
Edit:
Added brackets for simplicity's sake.