Let’s Talk About Rule 4, All Things Housing, and the Moderators.
Let's talk about rule 4, all things housing, and the moderators.
--
There is clearly some appetite among patrons of r/gwu to post about all things housing. Throughout the year, this subreddit sees posts for:
- University students seeking to swap rooms with other university students.
- University students seeking roommates for off-campus housing.
- University students seeking information about on-campus housing.
- Individuals unaffiliated with the university seeking housing in the area.
- Individuals unaffiliated with the university advertising housing in the area.
...and more, I'm sure.
There are some problems with the existing setup right now.
Rule 4 states "no room swap posts: please use the master thread when making room swap posts. Failure to do so will result in the removal of your post." However, as many individuals have observed and pointed out, such a master thread does not exist. This serves as a little bit of a point of confusion, but more than anything else renders rule 4 toothless: university students seeking a room swap simply... ignore it and post anyways!
One could argue that all of this is relatively harmless; after all, r/gwu is dedicated to discussing all things related to The George Washington University by and for any member of the university community. The problem, however, is that these threads are numerous, 'clog' up the subreddit, and bury more productive threads. Importantly, none of any of these threads ever get any significant engagement; despite all of the appetite for posting about seeking roommates or room swaps or advertising off-campus housing, there's no evidence that there's anyone 'buying' what any of the people posting are 'selling.' To that effect, rule 4 is highly necessary as a means of mitigation against these fruitless posts.
It's important for me to note that I view r/gwu as more than just somewhere for people to make posts asking questions or having discussions about all things related to the university. To me, one of the most important functions of reddit (and r/gwu by extension) is to act as a repository for information. How many of you have had a question about something, related to the university or otherwise, and consulted some reddit thread that someone else posted asking your same question? I know I have. This is part of why I'm so active on the subreddit and make such an effort to share what knowledge I have in response to people sharing their problems or questions: I'm confident that someday, somebody else will have the same problem or question and that person is not unlikely to check our subreddit as a source. Similarly, I believe it's important that 'productive' threads remain visible on the subreddit's front page and not be buried by housing-related posts that get no engagement and, at best, will only serve to help OP.
I've already pointed out that rule 4 is effectively useless considering the lack of this 'master thread' that the rule says people should be posting on. However, the problem is larger than that. I opened this post listing the five main categories of housing-related posts that seem to plague the subreddit, but rule 4, as it stands, only addresses room swaps. That's a glaring blind spot, and rule 4 should be amended to restrict the other four categories I described as well. More importantly, though, a bigger problem looms: the moderators of r/gwu.
Some of you may have noticed that the moderators of r/gwu are quiet, to say the least. I believe I can count on one hand the number of times I've seen any activity from a moderator's account or any instances of moderator powers being actively used on the subreddit. In fact, around three days ago u/Jonahdog posted this thread drawing attention to the unclear guidance posed by the current incarnation of rule 4. The lack of any kind of response by or guidance from a moderator is a deafening silence. I, myself, have at times messaged the general r/gwu moderator inbox and never received any signs of life in response. Many of these accounts have not interacted with r/gwu in years. Some of these moderator accounts have had no activity anywhere on reddit in years.
I do not know whether or not the moderators are monitoring this subreddit anymore. That being said, the lack of any action on housing posts that violate rule 4 (unclear though it may be), the lack of any guidance in response to multiple people expressing being confused by rule 4, the lack of response to messages to the moderator inbox, and the lack of activity not just on this subreddit but across reddit as a whole by many of the moderators, altogether, do not inspire confidence.
I believe we need to see:
- "Rule 4" reform.
- More visible moderators.
- More active management of the subreddit.
... so that's my manifesto.
--
I am making this post because I want us to talk about all of these things as a subreddit community. I would love to hear anyone's thoughts on any of these points that I have raised and any suggestions anyone has on how to tackle these issues and move forward. Any input?
Thanks,