I did not like the Odyssey by Christopher Nolan
Hello everyone
I'd like to share my (horrible) experience watching Odyssey by Christopher Nolan.
I want to see how different people are thinking compared to me. I'm always open to other opinions. What was Nolan's vision?
1.a Travis Scott appears and disappears. If he's in the banquet room, then he is not shown dead neither kneeling to the king.
1.b They could have made a goated movie by playing FE!N (by Travis Scott) during Agamemnon's entrance in Troy (just kidding but imagine the TikTok edits)
2.a Characters are not properly introduced.
2.b You only understand that Elliot Page's character (Sinon) is the kid that swapped his place in Ithaca, when the crew is in Hell.
2.b No one remembers the name of Robert Pattinson's character
2.c Only at the end of the movie, you learn that the name of Telemachus mentor is... Mentor...
3.a Too many cuts, some scenes or shots seem to be cut short. The scenes seem to be packed and condensed one after another. It's hard to think a guy rewatched multiple times the whole movie and said "perfect! We can send it to movie theaters"
3.b Those numerous cuts lead to temporal ellipsis, where no hints are given about what happened in between two scenes.
3.c The story is going forth and back, so the first scene is in fact one of the scenes that belongs to the end.
3.d the short scene where we see a guy saying something like "you won't like what you'll see next" just feels off and out of context
Ulysse shooting an arrow to the cyclopes after escaping the cave is pure rage bait. They could have found a better way than this to kill extra people.
Laestrygonians are depicted as heavy armored warriors. The entire scene from the encounter with the kid to the return to the boat feels just unnecessary. Literally they arrive on the island and run back immediately. Could be skipped or more developed.
Odysseus threatening to break the crow's neck if Circe slits his throat seems far fetched and she gives up on killing him quite quickly. It just feels rushed.
The scene of the guy taking off his wax ear buds and jumping in the water is unnecessary. The passage with the sirens seems to be 2 mins long and not really developed. Just show some sirens to see how they are interpreted in the movie.
Charybdis and Scylla scene feels so rushed. You see the guys being taken by the monster just in 0.5 sec each. It's difficult to properly identify its shape.
Helen has a scar on her face but it's not explained how she got it. So why having this detail shown?
The scene in Hell was pretty interesting and cool tho
The role of Athena in all of this? Just seems to be screen time for Zendaya
Eating lotus 🪷 with Calypso but the island seems to be dry and hot, whereas lotus might grow in tropical environments. How lotuses are collected in this dry environment is not shown.
No big works for the colorimetry
Dialogues could be deeper or more poetical to reflect the metric and the lyricism used in the source material.
The utility of the scene of the guy who got hit by a sword inside the horse? We never see him afterwards and there's no blood on the sword of the Trojan soldier?
The idea of the cyclopes having only one eye because of some sort of malformation is really interesting.