Artist who are notoriously bad at picking their singles with examples?
Besides the obvious that pop heads would normally name. Two artist who immediately come to mind for me is Xtina and Mariah Carey.
Xtina HATED Genie in a bottle and didn’t want to record it, but her A&R fought for the song and knew it was a hit. the song submitted her place as one of the top pop artist in the time and had a big legacy.
I also think some of the single choices in her peak Eras (Stripped, Back To Basic and Bionic) were odd.
How was infatuation not a single?! it would’ve been perfect for the summer, especially since the Latin cross over was big in the 90’s and 00’s. It’s also one her more catchier songs off stripped. And could’ve seen that being a big radio hit.
Mariah, I feel like her post Tommy era was hit and miss with picking singles too.
Mariah infamously hated Hero because she found it corny and she didn’t write it with herself in mind. But Tommy made her put it out and now it’s one of her signature hits and is a tribute song that impacted many lives.
Mariah also wanted to put out Say somethin as the lead for emancipation put her label told her to go back into the studio and work with JD for the chemistry and in hopes of getting a hit. That last minute sessions with JD generated it’s like that and we belong together. Two big records that sent Mariah comeback perfectly.
I also feel like Migrate was a missed single off E=MC2 and you don’t know what to do on the elusive chanteuse album.