Is 50% Higher Housing Costs for 1 More Bedroom in a Better Area Worth It?
"TLDR bRo" = Please see title and skim. Bolded the key parts
For context, married (2nd), 2 kids (50/50 joint custody). We live in the Crescenta Valley/North East SF valley foothills area of Los Angeles. After my divorce, and after getting outbid regularly by cash buyers on shoeboxes in my area, I found a great 2+2 renovated craftsmen to rent back in 19' and it's been very good to me/us. Front and back yards, gardeners & water included, well landscaped, nice neighborhood, character, lot of greenery, garage, driveway, off street parking, quiet, etc. 1300 sq ft. for currently $3100 a month. If we moved tomorrow, they could get $4200 for it, easy. The kids (girls) are 13 and 9 and are regularly complaining about sharing a room at this point. It's ongoing. The other wild card is they are currently LAUSD. While this has been ok so far, we'd like to move to La Crescenta/Montrose as the schools are top notch there and it's a nicer area. The high school they'd go to is better. For context, I/we are bound to this area due to separation agreement in divorce decree. So no, we can't "just move". All their friends are here, all they know is here and their mom and I co-parent well, we live a few miles apart and 5 min from their schools. No one wants to commute 90 min each day in LA traffic for school drop offs/ pickups.
We have been feeling like the place is getting cramped and the allure of the better schools and hood is strong. We make $230k HHI, and my net worth is around $850k. I still pay child support, because income disparity between me and their mother, despite joint custody. (Thanks CA divorce laws 🙄) The dilemma is this: if we tried to buy in the area, with $200k down, our monthly housing cost would still almost double. We have an agent, are pre-approved and haveve looked for over a year and the inventory is horrible. Now, to rent a 3+2 would be at least $1500 more a month. Currently housing is 1/4 of our income and I'm able to max out retirement accounts, fund their 529 accounts, brokerage, take some vacations etc. We have a decent life. I do not want to be house poor. Other thing is that there are zero single family homes in our price range. Really. Anything decent starts at $900-950k and that needs work for sure. Buying somewhere affordable means moving to the IE or something and that is not happening. So for rent, we're looking at $4500-5500 p/mo. And it's mostly condos and townhouses. This alone would be a maor quality of living downgrade. No more outdoors spaces or greenery, walking out to the garage in my boxers across the backyard, playing catch in the driveway, etc etc. Living on top and below people, people on all sides.
So the question is this: Having described what we have now, is it worth adding $1500-2500 p/month to our base housing cost for 1 more bedroom in a slightly nicer area (w/potentially worse house). Is it worth living in a crappier place for a better school district? Or do we tell the kids tough luck?