Which Pokemon game should I play based on my preference and experience?
I grew up with Pokemon, however, I lost virtually all interest and abandoned it after the first generation. I loved Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow, but that was it for the longest time.
When Pokemon X/Y came out, I decided to give it a shot again. I had an incredible time, I played X for months. I can’t really tell you what made it so great, it just felt like I was experiencing Pokemon for the first time again. I’m pretty sure I sold my 3DS before Sun/Moon came out so I never played or looked anything up on them.
I tried again during Sword/Shield, and I remember really disliking it. I can’t remember why but I just remember it feeling really shallow compared to the fun I had with X/Y. I’m not even sure if I ever beat it. Then with Scarlet/Violet, I gave it a shot, it just looked and played really bad, so I quit after a couple hours and told myself I’d come back to it when it gets fixed. I never went back to it.
So here’s what I want:
\* A game that’s at least somewhat difficult throughout the game, as opposed to only the ending. I distinctly remember how easy some of the games were. Something with at least a slight challenge would be nice.
\* A game that has the basic loop of Pokemon, but either executes it exceptionally well or mixes in some new mechanic or something that really makes it addictive. I want to keep coming back.
\* Not necessarily looking for something completely open ended, but something at least slightly less linear than the typical formula.
\* Definitely want something with some degree of side content.
\* I don’t care about carrying Pokemon across generations, I don’t care about battling others, I don’t care about following guides to find the perfect stat roll on a Pokemon and then equipping them with the ideal move set. I just what something that rewards natural curiosity and exploration.
Please don’t recommend me YOUR favorite Pokemon game. Recommend me the one that checks the most boxes based on my preferences.