Finally Recognized!
I kind of can't believe it.
After starting this ~4 years ago, applying 2.5 years ago, and the whole minor-issue-oops-jk-not-issue, I've finally been recognized.
Also wanted to confirm that if you're outside of Toronto and in Ontario, you can still apply through your local vice consulate (I've never been to the Toronto consulate even though they processed my application!). You cannot apply through them if you live in Toronto.
If you decide to apply through them please be kind and remember that they are working unpaid positions.