
Reasons to be Catholic vs Orthodox
I‘m at a fork in the road where i want to become either Catholic or Orthodox, but both seem to have good reasons. it would probably wine a while before I make an official decision, but maybe yall can help give some insight.
reasons i would be Catholic
-I’ve felt drawn to it ever since I was a kid. I always felt it was so beautiful and holy. that feeling currently will not go away
- it’s beautiful. the music, the icons, everything
-some of the best people I know are Catholic. now keep in mind I’ve never met an Orthodox person, but there’s just something about Catholics.
-they have more schools, hospitals, and other organization you can clearly see how they contribute to the world
-they’ve spread a lot of Christianity throughout history
-i feel more connected to their Saints and their stories.
-they have more organizations in the world (schools, hospital, etc)
Reasons I wouldn’t become one right now
- Papal infallibility. I just have trouble believing it that’s all
- they allow Jesus to be depicted naked. I get why, but it just feels disrespectful
- the Blood is not always taken during Communion
-annulments inst of divorces. How can they know what a person intended to di wh saying vows? maybe they did mean every word at the time but just messed up horribly?
-they whole mortal vs venial sin thing. who are we to decide which sins are worse than the others?
-There are churches that Paul wrote to in the Bible that are stoll standing. All except one is Orthodox. The only one not Orthodox is Rome
Reasons to be Orthodox
- more traditional beliefs
- both the Body and the Blood are taken during Communion
- more individuality
-https://theuncreatedlight.substack.com/p/11-practical-reasons-to-be-orthodox numbers 1, 9,10, and 11 seem valid
-solve disputes and beliefs in a more communal way
They take both the Body and the Blood at Communion
Reasons i wouldn’t become one right now
- i genuinely feel no connection to them consistent. Not like i have with Catholicism. Now i know that feelings arent always a great way to make serious decisions, I think it could be God leading me to Catholicism. Unfortunately it could also be something evil leading me away from Orthodoxy. I’ve been praying to not be mislead.
My views are likely heavily influenced by my surrounding. i love in the south of the United aststes where there aren’t as many Orthodox as there are Catholics. Everything i know about Orthodoxy is through the internet. I was also raised Protestant so that also shapes my view. That is one reason why i do not think i will be making a final decision anytime soon. I just want insight right now. I may edit with more reasons later.