
A lot of people seem to have an oddly defensive attitude about the reboot
Yeah yeah, adding to the already giant pile with a dumbass screenshot to grab your attention, but I felt like talking about this.
So I saw the trailer (obviously), and without getting too deep into it: I’m mixed. Many aspects I like, many aspects I think are really grating. Probably ain’t gonna be for me but I’ll give it a fair handshake when it releases. That said, I don’t really care for the defensive attitude I’m seeing some people take in regards to criticism of the show. People with an equally offensive attitude I’d also criticize, but frankly I’m just not seeing enough of that to bother discussing it. What I AM seeing though is a lot of “well it’s a kids’ show, why should it appeal to you as an adult fan” or “you should be GRATEFUL that they’re doing this” or snarky “you’re shocked that a kids’ show has kid voice actors” comments when like. May I ask what the point of having an adult fandom is if we can’t criticize it as adults?
It just seems weirdly antithetical to the whole point of the fandom because that’s the exact same arguments I’ve heard my whole life from other people saying I shouldn’t like the show in the first place. So what, a grown-ass man like me can praise the new show for everything good it does and that’s fine, but when we criticize it, then “it’s just a kids’ show and IDK why you’re analyzing it like that lmao it’s not for you.” Obviously I think there are entitled fans who have ridiculous expectations for the show, the new Tommy Choo Choo show does not owe me, an adult man, crap. I think it’s immature of anyone to act any different. But I also see it as no more mature to blindly praise it and eat it up as a grown adult because then like. Why are you watching it if you think it’s just for kids?
Like, either it’s something that can be enjoyed by all ages and thus is worthy of criticism as such, or it’s just a baby show for the kiddos in which case I have to ask why you’re watching if that’s how you yourself view it. That’s how I view AEG, and that’s why I didn’t bother watching it. I don’t hate it, I don’t view it as an affront to Awdry and whine about it. I just see it as a toddler show that I obviously wouldn’t enjoy and ignore it. Either I think something is mature enough to be worthy of my viewership, worthy of my praise, and thus also worthy of my criticism when applicable, or sure. Maybe it’s “just a preschool show” that I’d be wasting my time criticizing, like AEG. But if that’s the case, then I ain’t watching it and I ain’t going to Reddit to praise a corporation for providing me with more cartoons for three year olds.
There are aspects of the new show I like. I think it has potential. But there’s also a LOT that I think are bad signs. I’m sorry, but I just don’t think child voice actors fit the series. The characters seem way too friendly and sanitized. The musical numbers sound dumb. The bouncing still looks bad, the faces look off, and some of the sets just look like toys rather than believable locations. I’d be happy to go more in-depth on why I feel that way, and I think so long as we’re calm and reasonable in said discussions, we should be allowed to make those criticisms. Cause otherwise, I think the attitude I’m seeing is kinda lame. Like if you think other people are immature for complaining about “just a preschool show,” how do you think you look by being excited for it? Outsiders to the fandom look at us the exact same way, no need to put each other down for simply voicing our opinions.