My Dad Traded Me For A Better Son. I Can't Bring Myself To Blame Him (Part One)
The last thing I remember from my tenth birthday is seeing my dad standing beside the garage with a man I didn't know.
Dad looked like he had been crying. I remember wondering whether it had something to do with Mom. He was always sad around my birthday. I knew why by then, even if nobody ever really explained it to me. My birthday was the day that she died. Dad tried not to make that my problem, but children notice more than adults think they do.
So when I saw him standing there, I made the little okay sign with my fingers. I wanted him to know I was having a good birthday, and that it was ok for him to be sad. I can't remember where I had learned that sign. I just started doing it one day. I remember him staring at me, and it almost seemed like something shattered behind his eyes. Then his lips parted, and everything disappeared.
I woke up in my bed. Or at least what looked like my bed. It was dark, with only moonlight shining through the window blinds, barely lighting the scene before me. For a few seconds, I began to relax, thinking I was home. Then I noticed the blankets. They smelled unfamiliar, with the stale dusty smell of a guest bedroom nobody has ever used. I opened my eyes and stared at a ceiling painted a pale blue. There were little plastic stars stuck to it, with some glowing faintly. Just like in my bedroom. But a strange feeling began seeping into my stomach.
I sat upright. In the dim light the room looked like a child's bedroom, but it wasn't quite mine. There was a dresser against one wall, a wooden toy box at the foot of the bed and a desk covered in colored pencils. My room had all of those things, but not in the places I now saw them. A baseball glove sat on top of the dresser, but I had never played baseball. I looked toward the door, which was open.
"Dad?" I said, nervously.
Nobody answered. My throat felt tight as unease crept through my veins.
"Dad?" I said again, this time louder.
But there was still no answer.
I climbed out of bed. Clinging to my skin were the clothes I had been wearing at my birthday party. Jeans, sneakers and the blue shirt my aunt bought me. There was even a little dried frosting on my sleeve. I hadn't merely fallen asleep. I remembered that. I had definitely been awake. But then…
"Dad!" I yelled towards the door, expecting him to come running.
Finally, I threw off the covers and ran to the door. Still ajar, I pulled it open, and froze. The hall outside the bedroom stretched much farther than it should have. At ten years old I didn't have the words to explain exactly why that bothered me. I just knew houses weren't supposed to look like that; or act like that.
The hallway went left and right farther than I could see. There were doors on both sides, all of them different. One was white and tall. Another green and wide. There was one made of dark wood with a brass handle, and one that seemed to barely hang off its hinges. Farther down I saw one covered in stickers. There were ceiling lights every few feet, each one different. But none of them seemed bright enough. Wide fluorescent lights, like they have at department stores, flickered and buzzed. Every now and then there was a chandelier, some light bulbs but others with only candles. Some were floodlights, some gas lamps, and far off in the distance I could see a torch hanging from high up on the wall. The farther I looked, the darker the hallway became.
"Dad!" My voice echoed.
Then another voice answered.
"He's not here."
I spun around. The man I had seen standing with my dad earlier, from beside the garage, stood inside the bedroom behind me. I hadn't heard him approach. And I hadn't seen him there when I woke up. For one stupid second I felt relieved because he was an adult and adults were supposed to know what was happening.
Then he smiled.
I remembered him smiling at my father outside, but it hadn't looked like that. Something had changed. He still wore the gray jacket. His hair was still dark and combed neatly to one side. His face was thin, and he looked to be somewhere around Dad's age, maybe older. It was definitely the same man from before. But his smile was different.
It stretched farther than any mouth I had seen. His mouth didn't tear open or reach his ears or anything like that. It was simply wider than anyone would normally smile while looking at a frightened child. It was wider than a mouth ought to look.
His smile was disturbing, but looking at his eyes was worse. I couldn't explain what was wrong with them. Even now, I can't exactly. They looked normal at first. Brown, I think. Sometimes they looked gray. And at one point I thought they were blue. The strange part, however, was everything around them. When I looked into his eyes, I got the feeling that his face wasn't really part of him. Like someone could have put any face around those eyes and it wouldn't have mattered.
"Where's my dad?" I asked, meekly.
The man stepped into the hallway. "He went home."
My stomach twisted. "Then take me there too… please."
"No."
The way he said it frightened me. It wasn't angry or cruel; just a firm and confident no. Like I had asked whether I could breathe underwater.
"Why not?"
His smile widened slightly. "Because you don't live there anymore."
I stared at him. "Yes I do."
"No. You do not, child."
"That's my house."
"Was… your house." He corrected. “Well, now not even was, really.”
I backed toward the wall. "What’s going on?"
"Oh not much. I simply did what I was asked to do. By the man you once called father."
I didn't understand any of what he was saying. How could I? He walked closer to me, his steps seeming to glide his body along the floor. I moved away as he approached. He stopped, then continued speaking.
"Your father and I made an agreement."
"What agreement?"
"He wanted something."
I waited, expecting the man to continue. But he seemed to enjoy making me ask.
"What?"
"A son." He said.
I frowned. "I'm his son."
"You WERE his son."
Something cold moved through my stomach, slowly darkening my emotions, seeming to turn my skin brittle. I think some part of me understood before the rest of me did.
"I don't get it."
The man tilted his head. “Don't you? Your father gave you to me, child.”
I froze. My heart was racing. My blood turned cold. All of that. "My dad wouldn't..."
I couldn't finish. The man simply waited there, smiling at me.
I shook my head. "He wouldn't."
"Wouldn't what?"
"Give me away!"
The man's smile disappeared for a moment. Not because he felt sorry for me. He looked almost disappointed. But his smile quickly returned.
"He did ask what would happen to you, you know.”
I looked at him. That small sentence gave me a sick sense of hope. As difficult as it was to believe anything this man was saying. A part of me just felt like he was telling the truth. But Dad had asked about me. That meant Dad cared.
"What did you tell him?" I asked.
"Very little. It's no fun spoiling all of the surprises now is it?”
"What did he say?"
The man looked back toward the bedroom as if thinking.
Then he turned toward me again. "He said, 'Take him.'"
"You're lying!" I yelled.
"Possibly."
"My dad wouldn't do that."
"Then perhaps I am indeed lying."
"He loves me."
The man chuckled. “Oh now that certainly is true."
"Then why would he give me away?"
The man leaned closer. "Because loving you hurt him toooo much." He said almost playfully, elongating the word “too.”
My eyes filled with tears. "No it didn't!"
But I knew that wasn't true. I knew how badly my dad hurt, at least to an extent.
"You reminded him of his wife."
I said nothing.
"He wanted a child he could look at without seeing her."
I started crying. Immediately, I felt ridiculous and I hated myself for it. I wiped my face hard with both hands as the man watched me.
"Awww, poor little thing. He only wanted someone better."
"Shut up!" I screamed. My voice cracked and screeched.
"So I gave him one."
"Shut up! Shut UP!!"
I lunged at him. I don't know what I expected to do. Hit him I guess. Scratch him. Bite him. But I never touched him. The hallway quickly and suddenly stretched, widening the gap between us. The man had been three feet away. Then, without taking a step, he was twenty. I stopped, as he stood at the other end of the hallway smiling.
"Where am I?!" I screamed.
He adjusted his jacket.
"Here."
"What is this place?!"
"It is here."
"Stop saying that!"
He chuckled. Then he walked through one of the doors and it closed behind him. I ran after him, grabbing the knob and turning it. The door swung open, revealing a kitchen. I immediately felt an urgent sense of dread. Everything the man had said, which had sounded impossible, started to sound plausible. It didn't feel like I was in just one house. It felt like I was in many. The kitchen I had just opened did not seem to fit with the bedroom I had woken up in.
As I peered around the room, I felt like I was intruding. Like I had walked into a stranger's house without permission. There were yellow cabinets and white tile floors. Magnets covered the refrigerator and a calendar hung beside the sink. The man, however, was nowhere to be seen.
I walked farther inside. There was a table with four chairs, one smaller than the others. A child's drawing had been taped to the refrigerator. It depicted three stick figures standing beneath a yellow sun, and above each of the figures, respectfully, was written: MOM, DAD, and LILY. I didn't know anyone named Lily. But the name stuck with me. Everything about that kitchen was unfamiliar, and my sense of dread deepened.
The refrigerator hummed as I struggled to stay calm.
"Hello?" I called out, meekly.
In the absence of a response, I wandered toward another doorway, carefully looking behind me and from side to side as I walked. I reached the door, turned the knob, and stood there as the door swung open. It opened onto a playground, and for one, brief second I felt a sense of relief. A sense of freedom. But then I noticed that the sky above it was merely a painted ceiling. The walls equally lying to me as I surveyed the scene.
The playground had grass, trees and swings, but a sky blue ceiling stretched above everything. My cage expanding and yet shrinking at the same time. Fluorescent lights buzzed where the sky should have been. The trees grew directly into the ceiling. It all looked real, just encased within the building. If I was truly in a building.
I backed into the kitchen, and I screamed. It was too much for my ten year old brain. I screamed for Dad. I screamed for my aunt. I screamed for anyone. But nobody came. I didn't know where I was, or if I truly was anywhere at all. I was trapped within a nightmare come to life.
Eventually my throat hurt too badly to continue. I sat beneath the kitchen table and cried until I eventually fell asleep, too exhausted to continue my waking nightmare. When I woke, I was back in the bedroom. For a moment I thought the kitchen and the playground and the strange, terrifying man had all just been a dream. A sick, disturbing dream. I got back up and immediately went for the door. When I opened it, the hallway was there. If it was a dream, I had not yet woken up.
I don't know how long I spent trying to find a way out. Days, maybe. There was never any sunlight, and none of the clocks I found counted time the same way, so I couldn't keep track of my sentence in that place. Sometimes I slept because I was tired. Sometimes I slept because I couldn't think of anything else to do.
Food would appear, but always in different places, never the same place twice. Once I found a plate of sandwiches sitting on a desk inside a classroom. Another time there was cereal waiting for me in a kitchen I had never seen before. I stopped eating for a while because I thought the man might have poisoned it. But eventually hunger won out.
Nothing really happened during that time. The man didn't reappear. The hallways didn't stretch again. I merely wandered, ate, and slept. The place, of course, was enormous. Or… maybe it wasn't. I still can’t be sure. I found houses inside houses. Hallways that opened into grocery stores. Bedrooms connected to school bathrooms. A staircase that led down for what felt like an hour before ending at the top of the same staircase.
Sometimes there were “outdoor” places. One door opened into a backyard with a swing set. There was grass beneath my feet and wind blowing through my hair. When I looked up, the sky was painted onto the ceiling. There were no windows, no vents, no life.
Another door took me into a forest. It had real trees, dirt, and leaves. I could peel the bark off and crush the leaves in my hands. It felt real, perhaps it was real. But something about everything always felt odd in a way I couldn't describe. I took off running between the trees. There was still a ceiling above me with flickering lights, it was simply farther above than most rooms. I didn't know what else to do, so I ran until my lungs burned.
Eventually I reached a road and began following it. Two hours later I found the same door I had entered standing by itself between two trees. When I opened it, I was back in the same hallway. The hallway I always ended up in, that led back to the bedroom.
I started marking my way with some markers I had found. But it didn't take long before I realized the markings sometimes changed. Arrows would suddenly be pointing in different directions. Some went missing entirely. Other times I would find markings ahead of me where I hadn't been yet. They looked just like my same markings. That's when I decided to start writing my name as a marker. But of course, they still changed.
Eventually, I had the idea to start carving my name into surfaces. I took a knife from one of the kitchens I passed through, and instead of just carving my first name, for some reason I thought that carving my whole name might be better. So every time I entered a new room, or periodically while passing through larger rooms, I would carve my name into any surface I could.
OWEN MERCER.
Out of paranoia, I also started carving my name into hidden surfaces, thinking that it was the man in grey who was changing them. I hoped he wouldn't find some. I carved behind things and under things. That's when I noticed another name carved underneath a wooden picnic table. It read:
MY NAME IS SARAH BELL.
Underneath that was another sentence.
DO NOT FORGET YOUR NAME.
I stared at it for a long time before moving on. I never found a Sarah. I never found anyone. But after that I started looking for other names; other clues. I did find more, and although there weren't many, it was enough.
MARCUS.
EMILY R.
DANNY COLE.
Each name I found was not out in the open. One simply said “I WAS HERE.” Another was scratched into the inside of a closet door.
MOM PLEASE COME GET ME.
I don't know for sure whether they had been children. I don't know whether they were still somewhere inside that place. I don't even know if the writing was real, honestly. The man could have put them there. It really did feel like I was being played with. Toyed with. I always had the feeling that he was watching me, but that could very easily just have been my paranoia and crumbling psyche. After enough time, I stopped trusting anything.
The first time I saw him, I was riding a bicycle. One second I was sitting on the floor of an empty living room, trying to pry up a floorboard with a screwdriver. Then I was outside. Dad was running behind me.
"Keep pedaling!" he yelled.
I looked down. My hands were gripping handlebars. They weren't my hands; but they were. They were smaller than Dad's, but different from mine. There was a scrape on one knuckle. But… they were mine.
"Don't let go!" I shouted.
Except I didn't shout it. Someone else did. I felt my mouth move as their voice came out of it.
Dad laughed, "I'm not letting go."
He did, however, let go of me soon after. I could feel it. The bicycle began moving faster, and I glided down the street with the wind in my face. Whoever I was began laughing. The sun bathed me. The SUN! I could see it, feel it warm my body. Then I was in the living room. I screamed and fell sideways, the screwdriver clattering across the floor. I sat there breathing hard.
"Dad?" I said to the empty room.
I could still hear his voice. I could still feel the bicycle beneath me. I quickly picked myself up.
"Dad!"
I ran through the nearest door into a bathroom. I pushed through the next door. A dining room. Then the next. The hallway.
"Daaaad!" I shouted down the torturous corridor.
But there was nothing. I began searching. I searched until I couldn't breathe. I didn't find my dad. But as I pushed through yet another door, panting, bending over with my hands on my knees, I looked up and saw the man in grey. He was sitting at a little table in a room that looked like a daycare. He sat in a tiny plastic chair with others just like it surrounded him.
A tea cup sat in front of him. He seemed to have been drinking from it, but wasn't as I looked at him. He looked up, fixing me with those unnerving eyes.
"Hello, Owen."