I'm not sure why Luddite logic is being completely discredited
I feel like in pro ai debates the idea that there were those who protested the industrial revolution is a very common talking point. Saying that the people who had protested were surely neanderthals for attempting to halt progress. But they weren't inherently wrong. The pros we got from the industrial revolution were advances in healthcare, major economic growth, and obviously technology. But it came with massive harm to the environment, systemic worker exploitation, and created the building blocks that capitalism suffers from today. It was the hasty rolling out of a majorly tech focused innovation that caused issues for generations and we're just doing that again, ignoring the cons in favor of speed running growth and technology.
Like this just isn't healthy for a society, we no longer control the pace of innovation.