
Would you keep reading after this dark epic fantasy prologue? (1,967 words)
Hi everyone,
I recently revised the prologue of my dark epic fantasy novel after receiving direct feedback about the rhythm, repeated imagery, frequent em dashes, and prose that sometimes felt overly cinematic.
The scene follows an aging shepherd who witnesses the arrival of something ancient and inhuman beneath a wounded sky. It introduces the larger threat of the series—and a glimpse of the man still trapped inside the monster.
The prologue is 1,967 words.
I would especially appreciate feedback on:
• Did the opening hold your attention?
• Did the POV transitions feel clear and intentional?
• Did the prose feel natural or overly written?
• Was the memory sequence emotionally effective?
• Were there any phrases that sounded unnatural in American English?
• Would you continue to Chapter One?
I’m not looking for praise, so direct criticism is welcome. English is not my first language, and comments about rhythm or unnatural wording are especially useful.
Here is the prologue:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/10-Cfxk-JbDXxsCw4tgQ84-FJNW933vMR/view?usp=drivesdk
Thank you for reading.