Avoid this Edit Hotel: Hotel Proper SF (a lesson learned about the edit)
Editing to say this was a more controversial take than I thought. It wasn't my personal best stay in SF. I preferred the palace or st Regis on prior trips. But TLDR maybe do a street view "walk" before booking to make your own call on this one because some people seem to love this place despite it not feeling like a typical edit properly to me.
Original but follows :
I should know better but I've gotten lazy about just booking whatever edit hotel has the best point conversion. This week I was in a rush an panic booked the Proper Hotel in SF for what felt like a "too good to be true" rate. And it is. The room & hotel are ok (not great - kind of lipstick on a pig imo) but it's right at the edge of the tenderloin. (historically not a great area) Would not stay or recommend this one.
So all that to say don't get sucked into the trap of thinking the edit is actually some sort of curated list. Too good to be true IS probably just that. And do your own research (duh).