Am I asking for basic emotional support, or am I expecting too much?
My (27F) boyfriend (28M) and I have been together for a few years, and lately I’ve been questioning whether I’ve been asking for too much or settling for too little.
My dad passed away from pancreatic cancer in November 2025, and grieving has changed me. I’ve realised that what I need most from a partner isn’t gifts or grand gestures—it’s emotional presence.
Unfortunately, that’s where we’ve struggled.
There have been countless times where I’ve been crying in another room and he’s either carried on as if he couldn’t hear me or only asked, “What’s wrong?” despite knowing I’m grieving. Sometimes I don’t need advice or solutions. I just want a hug, someone to sit with me, or someone to say, “I know this is hard.”
We’ve spoken about it more than once. His response has been that he does support me, but the kind of support I’m asking for is “too much” and that he “can’t do those things.”
Outside of that, I feel like I carry a lot of the relationship. He’s on my spousal visa, I let him use my car because he doesn’t have one yet, I’ve bought him a lot over the years because I genuinely enjoy being generous, and I often end up carrying the mental load at home too. He does contribute in practical ways, but it’s inconsistent. If chores don’t get done, I usually end up doing them because I can’t relax in a messy house. I even suggested hiring a cleaner, but he wasn’t keen, so the extra work still falls back on me.
Recently I suggested we have a relationship check-in after reading Keep Love by Paul Brunson because I wanted us to reconnect. He said he wasn’t ready and postponed it.
The same weekend, he made plans to meet a lifelong female friend for drinks after dropping off some parcels. I genuinely don’t think the issue is the friend. If he’d gone for drinks on another weekend, I probably wouldn’t have thought twice about it.
What hurt was that he wasn’t ready to spend time working on us, but he was ready to spend time socialising.
That made me realise this isn’t really about one evening. It’s about whether I feel like our relationship is a priority when things are difficult.
So I wanted to ask people who’ve been in long-term relationships:
How do you know the difference between someone who simply has a different way of showing love and someone who genuinely isn’t able or willing to meet your emotional needs?
Can people learn emotional support if they don’t naturally offer it, or is this usually a compatibility issue?