Finishing a Mechanical Engineering PhD and struggling to get postdoc traction — am I approaching the search wrong?

I'm finishing a PhD in Mechanical Engineering in the US and expect to graduate around the end of this year. My primary goal after graduating is a postdoc, ideally in wearable/assistive robotics, rehabilitation robotics, biomechanics, human-robot interaction, or experimental robotics.

I've been applying to advertised postdoc positions through university application portals. When the PI is identifiable, I've also tried reaching out directly after applying to briefly introduce myself and express my interest. So far, neither the formal applications nor the follow-up emails seem to be generating much traction, and I'm starting to wonder whether the issue is my profile, timing, or how I'm approaching the search.

A quick summary of my background:

  • ~5.5 years PhD + 2 years MS in Mechanical Engineering
  • Research focused on wearable robotics/exoskeletons, mechatronics, controls, and biomechanics
  • Designed, built, controlled, and experimentally evaluated multiple wearable robotic/exoskeleton systems
  • Experience in mechatronic system development, including mechanical design, embedded systems, sensing, controls, system integration, and experimental validation
  • Experience conducting human-subject biomechanics experiments, including EMG-based evaluation and gait analysis
  • Some hands-on experience with ROS/ROS2 and machine learning, although neither has been a primary focus of my research or publications
  • 3 publications from my MS
  • 1 published first-author paper from my PhD
  • 1 co-first-author PhD manuscript close to acceptance
  • Another collaborative manuscript under review
  • Additional PhD work in progress that should eventually become another paper
  • Some conference/abstract work
  • Teaching experience as a TA for controls and mechanical design labs

My main concern is that after ~5.5 years of PhD work, my publication record may look relatively thin, especially compared with applicants coming from robotics labs that publish multiple conference papers every year. A lot of my PhD time has gone into designing, building, debugging, and experimentally validating physical robotic systems, so the publication cycle has been fairly slow.

I'm primarily targeting postdocs where the work is experimental and involves developing and testing actual robotic/mechatronic systems rather than positions centered primarily around theoretical controls, simulation, or ML. I'm also particularly interested in national-lab postdocs.

For people who have recently gone through the postdoc search or hired postdocs:

Does this sound like a reasonably competitive profile for robotics/biomechanics postdocs, or is my publication record going to be a significant obstacle?

Is applying through the official posting and then emailing the PI actually useful? Or do most PIs simply wait until they review the formal applicant pool?

I'm also wondering about timing. Is applying several months before finishing the PhD too early? Should I keep applying broadly, focus more heavily on positions where my hardware/experimental background is an unusually close match, or change how I'm contacting PIs after applying?

I'd appreciate candid feedback, especially from people in robotics, biomechanics, rehabilitation engineering, or related fields.

reddit.com
u/Party_Professor4349 — 2 months ago
▲ 4 r/roboticstackoverflow+1 crossposts

Finishing a Mechanical Engineering PhD with no industry/internship experience — what roles should I realistically target?

I'm finishing a PhD in Mechanical Engineering in the US and expect to graduate around the end of this year. I'm starting to get pretty anxious about the job search and would appreciate some outside perspective on how competitive my background actually is.

My background:

  • ~5.5 years PhD + 2 years MS
  • Research focused on wearable robotics/exoskeletons, mechatronics, controls, and biomechanics
  • Designed, built, and experimentally tested multiple robotic/exoskeleton systems
  • Experience in mechatronic system development, including mechanical design, embedded systems, sensing, controls, system integration, and experimental validation.
  • Experience conducting human-subject biomechanics experiments, including EMG-based evaluation of muscle activity and analysis of gait and human–robot interaction.
  • Some experience with ROS/ROS2 and machine learning, though neither has been a primary focus of my research or publications.
  • 3 publications from my MS
  • 1 published first-author paper from my PhD
  • Another PhD manuscript close to acceptance (co-first-author) 
  • Another collaborative manuscript under review at a 
  • Additional ongoing PhD work that should eventually become a paper but data collection still in progress
  • Some conference/abstract work
  • Teaching experience as a TA for controls and mechanical design labs

My biggest concern is that I have zero industry experience and no internships. I spent my entire graduate career in academia.

I'm currently targeting three types of positions:

  1. Postdocs, preferably wearable/assistive robotics, rehabilitation robotics, biomechanics, human-robot interaction, experimental robotics, or national labs
  2. Industry R&D/mechatronics/robotics roles — Robotics Engineer, Mechatronics Engineer, Controls Engineer, Robotics Hardware Engineer, Research Engineer, etc.
  3. Teaching positions — primarily full-time Lecturer/Instructor/Visiting positions in mechanical engineering, controls, mechatronics, or robotics. I'm not currently trying to become tenure-track faculty.

I've been applying, but haven't gotten much traction yet, and it's making me question whether I'm aiming too high or marketing myself incorrectly.

For people who have hired PhDs or made a similar transition:

How would you evaluate this profile?

Would the lack of internships/industry experience be a major problem for robotics/mechatronics R&D roles?

Is my publication record too weak to be competitive for good postdocs?

And am I realistic in considering full-time lecturer/instructor positions with my current teaching experience?

I'm not looking for reassurance — I'd genuinely appreciate candid feedback about where this profile is competitive, where it isn't, and what types of positions I should prioritize.

reddit.com
u/Party_Professor4349 — 2 months ago
▲ 9 r/PhD

Finishing a Mechanical Engineering PhD with no industry/internship experience — what roles should I realistically target?

I'm finishing a PhD in Mechanical Engineering in the US and expect to graduate around the end of this year. I'm starting to get pretty anxious about the job search and would appreciate some outside perspective on how competitive my background actually is.

My background:

  • ~5.5 years PhD + 2 years MS
  • Research focused on wearable robotics/exoskeletons, mechatronics, controls, and biomechanics
  • Designed, built, and experimentally tested multiple robotic/exoskeleton systems
  • Experience in mechatronic system development, including mechanical design, embedded systems, sensing, controls, system integration, and experimental validation.
  • Experience conducting human-subject biomechanics experiments, including EMG-based evaluation of muscle activity and analysis of gait and human–robot interaction.
  • Some experience with ROS/ROS2 and machine learning, though neither has been a primary focus of my research or publications.
  • 3 publications from my MS
  • 1 published first-author paper from my PhD
  • Another PhD manuscript close to acceptance (co-first-author) 
  • Another collaborative manuscript under review at a 
  • Additional ongoing PhD work that should eventually become a paper but data collection still in progress
  • Some conference/abstract work
  • Teaching experience as a TA for controls and mechanical design labs

My biggest concern is that I have zero industry experience and no internships. I spent my entire graduate career in academia.

I'm currently targeting three types of positions:

  1. Postdocs, preferably wearable/assistive robotics, rehabilitation robotics, biomechanics, human-robot interaction, experimental robotics, or national labs
  2. Industry R&D/mechatronics/robotics roles — Robotics Engineer, Mechatronics Engineer, Controls Engineer, Robotics Hardware Engineer, Research Engineer, etc.
  3. Teaching positions — primarily full-time Lecturer/Instructor/Visiting positions in mechanical engineering, controls, mechatronics, or robotics. I'm not currently trying to become tenure-track faculty.

I've been applying, but haven't gotten much traction yet, and it's making me question whether I'm aiming too high or marketing myself incorrectly.

For people who have hired PhDs or made a similar transition:

How would you evaluate this profile?

Would the lack of internships/industry experience be a major problem for robotics/mechatronics R&D roles?

Is my publication record too weak to be competitive for good postdocs?

And am I realistic in considering full-time lecturer/instructor positions with my current teaching experience?

I'm not looking for reassurance — I'd genuinely appreciate candid feedback about where this profile is competitive, where it isn't, and what types of positions I should prioritize.

reddit.com
u/Party_Professor4349 — 2 months ago

Dating as a 30+ woman in Blacksburg

Firstly, there are hardly any men in Blacksburg. The few I do match with often don't seem to put much effort into holding a conversation. I'm not super hot, but I think I look pretty good for my age. Is it because it's a college town and men are more interested in younger women? What have your experiences been like?

At this point, I'm not even talking about serious relationships. They don't seem to put much effort into casual dating either. I keep seeing the same men on the apps year after year, and it makes me wonder if they even want to give dating a real try.

Just ranting, not looking for dates here.

reddit.com
u/Party_Professor4349 — 3 months ago

Was there anything wrong with my (30+F) prompt, or was the guy too creepy?

​

My Hinge prompt says:

> "My most irrational fear: Not really irrational, but serial killers. I have watched too many serial killer documentaries on Netflix."

A match (30+M) liked my photo and his first message was:

'Who's your favorite serial killer. Ed Kemper kinda resonates with me for some reason."

That immediately gave me the ick, especially the "resonates with me" part. I unmatched without replying.

Now I'm wondering if my prompt somehow invited that kind of response, or if he was just making a really bad joke.

I live in a small town where you occasionally run into people from dating apps, so I'm also slightly freaking out about that.

Was there something about my prompt that suggested I like serial killers? Should I be worried about his response especially the Ed Kemper part? Or am I overthinking?

reddit.com
u/Party_Professor4349 — 4 months ago