As A Muslim, I'd Appreciate Honest Perspectives on These Concerns

You all might have seen how Muslims in India are treated. The Hindutva goons are doing everything they want to put us down. Our Mosques are being burnt and replaced with temples, homes are destroyed and even innocent Muslims are jailed. During the CJP protests you have seen how Junaid Malik was imprisoned along with his father despite the fact that he did a gesture of kindness by providing food and water to the protestors. The Mohammed Ali Jauhar University is also under the threat of being demolished and how is it still occuring because we are weak. I will say it without filter and it is true because if we had power than why we will be treated like this in the country where we were born.

The mistake many Muslims like us make is this: we keep arguing about ideas, metaphysics, Quranic reinterpretations, Hadith authenticity, while ignoring the elephant in the room: Power. The things which I mentioned aren't inherently bad and I encourage young Muslims to do but what I feel is that we should understand Islam in a better way and study our Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, classic Islamic scholars even if we don't agree with some ideas but at least we would be able to create our own opinions.

Islam today is stuck in idealism and moralism. We can write articles and create content as much as we want. We may be able to influence many people, but that would still not be enough. Our main enemy is the Far Right like the Zionists, MAGA and Hindutvas who spread poison against Muslims. Despite so much online activism for so many years, nothing significant has changed on the ground when it comes to challenging these powerful enemies. Without power, we can do nothing. We can argue with them as much as we want, insult them as much as we want but what is needed is the core understanding to challenge them. Our Islamic Economics system is developed in a halal way where we can improve not just our lives but the lives of every Muslim. Today you will see how the BJP government due to their influence in Bollywood is able to produce so many films showing Muslims as villains. They are able to do it without no one questioning because the Far Right ideology is too strong. Al Jazeera is by far the only media company which supports Muslims and other Muslim media groups showing out plight in a nuanced way are small and not that funded. Our Madhrasas are also always looked down. Even if a Muslim gains wealth than he won't invest in any media, any Madhrasa or University or even a financial institution which improves our lives.

Today we are divided and if we are told about our backwardness then we talk about our glorious Islamic history. As is say it again that isn't bad because our history is great no doubt but we are stuck in the past without thinking about making our past and future even better than our history. No Muslim has any excuse to be mediocre anymore. Everyone should be at 100% effort. It only takes a couple of generations, maybe three at worst, for this to pay off. By effort I mean both in the dunya and the akhira sense. People should be at the top of their class in university while also having enough Islamic knowledge to combat attacks from all sides.

reddit.com
u/Quietpebble9979 — 12 days ago

What We Muslims Are Really Supposed To Do

​

Brothers and Sisters, who else believes that Muslims need to seriously enter the worlds of business, education, media, finance, technology, and entertainment?

I genuinely believe that one of the biggest weaknesses of the global Muslim community today isn't a lack of talent, intelligence, or resources. It's that we haven't built enough large, professional, globally influential institutions of our own.

And I'm not talking about creating institutions simply to compete with or attack the West. I'm talking about Muslims becoming producers rather than perpetual consumers.

Three areas in particular stand out to me: finance, education, and media/entertainment.

  1. Finance — We need to understand and participate in capital

Look at companies such as BlackRock, Vanguard, State Street, Blackstone, KKR, and other enormous asset-management and private-equity firms.

These institutions manage or invest enormous amounts of capital and have stakes across major sectors of the global economy. They influence where capital flows, which companies receive investment, and which industries expand.

Yet when I look for major globally influential Muslim-founded financial institutions operating on that scale, there simply aren't many.

Obviously, Muslims don't need to copy the exact business models of these companies. Islamic finance has its own principles and challenges. But why can't Muslims build world-class investment firms, banks, venture-capital funds, private-equity companies, asset managers, and financial institutions that operate internationally?

Imagine a generation of Muslim investors who understand:

- Capital markets

- Venture capital

- Private equity

- Asset management

- Entrepreneurship

- Corporate governance

- Economics

- Accounting

- Islamic finance

- International trade

And imagine Muslim owned institutions investing in Muslim entrepreneurs, technology, infrastructure, education, healthcare, manufacturing, renewable energy and entertainment.

That would create something much more powerful than simply asking other people to invest in us.

We would become investors ourselves.

  1. Education — Knowledge is power, and Muslims need both religious and worldly knowledge

This is probably the most important one.

Muslim societies need strong universities, research institutions, schools, think tanks and vocational institutions.

And education shouldn't mean choosing between Islamic studies and STEM.

We need both.

A Muslim student should be able to study engineering, medicine, computer science, physics or mathematics while also having a meaningful understanding of Islamic history, civilization and intellectual traditions.

But we should also encourage people to understand things that determine how modern societies actually function:

Economics.

Finance.

Law.

Political science.

Psychology.

History.

International relations.

Technology.

Business.

Media literacy.

Knowing how markets work can be just as important as knowing how to build a machine.

Knowing how governments function can be just as important as knowing how to write software.

Understanding psychology can help someone understand human behaviour.

Understanding history can prevent us from repeating our own mistakes.

And understanding law can help Muslims participate effectively in the institutions that govern their countries.

The Muslim world has universities and educational institutions that produce excellent students, but we need many more institutions capable of competing with the world's strongest universities in research, innovation and intellectual influence.

We shouldn't just ask:

"Why doesn't the world understand Islam?"

We should also ask:

"What are we doing to educate the world about Islam?"

And there is another important point...

We shouldn't build these institutions because we are obsessed with defeating someone else.

That's the wrong mentality.

We should build them because Muslims have something valuable to contribute to humanity.

The goal isn't Muslim domination of every industry.

The goal is Muslim participation, excellence and independence.

If a Muslim becomes a successful entrepreneur, employ people.

If a Muslim becomes a filmmaker, tell meaningful stories.

If a Muslim becomes a professor, educate the next generation.

If a Muslim becomes an investor, invest responsibly.

If a Muslim becomes a journalist, pursue truth.

If a Muslim becomes a politician, serve justice.

If a Muslim becomes a scientist, discover something that benefits humanity.

If a Muslim becomes wealthy, create opportunities for others.

And perhaps most importantly, we need to stop thinking that every successful Muslim must individually escape poverty and become rich.

Institutions matter more than individuals.

One billionaire can disappear.

One company can collapse.

One political leader can die.

But a strong university can educate generations.

A strong financial institution can finance thousands of businesses.

A strong media company can influence generations of audiences.

A strong research institution can create knowledge that survives its founders.

That's how civilizations build lasting influence.

And this doesn't mean Muslims should isolate themselves from the rest of the world.

Quite the opposite.

Muslims don't need to fear excellence in other communities.

We need to develop our own excellence. Because ultimately, representation is important, but capability is even more important. We shouldn't spend our entire lives complaining that someone else controls the narrative. We should become capable of creating narratives ourselves. We shouldn't complain that someone else controls capital. We should learn how capital works. We shouldn't complain that our history isn't being taught properly. We should build institutions capable of researching and teaching it. We shouldn't complain that Muslims don't have enough influence. We should build things that are genuinely useful to humanity and allow influence to follow naturally.

And above everything else, we should remember that success isn't simply measured by wealth, political power or international recognition.

For Muslims, there is something greater than all of that:

Allah SWT.

We can plan, can work, can study, can build, can invest, can educate, can create.

But ultimately, we put our trust in Allah.

If Allah SWT is with us, we don't need to live in fear.

But tawakkul doesn't mean sitting around waiting for things to change.

Put your trust in Allah.

reddit.com
u/Quietpebble9979 — 12 days ago

Islamic Economics: More Relevant Today Than Many People Think

Whenever people hear "Islamic economics," many assume it's an outdated system that only belonged to the medieval world. But after reading about it, I think that assumption misses the point.

Islamic economics isn't just about banning interest. It's a broader ethical framework for how wealth should be earned, invested, and distributed.

Some of its key principles include:

• No riba (interest): Money shouldn't generate guaranteed profit simply by existing. Investment should involve sharing both risk and reward.

• Profit and risk sharing: Instead of debt-based financing, businesses can be funded through partnerships where investors and entrepreneurs share success and failure.

• Zakat: A mandatory redistribution of wealth to help the poor and prevent excessive concentration of wealth.

• No excessive uncertainty (gharar): Contracts should be transparent, fair, and based on real assets.

• No gambling or speculative wealth (maysir): Wealth should come from productive activity rather than chance or harmful speculation.

• Ethical investment: Businesses should avoid industries that are considered harmful or unethical.

What's interesting is that many modern discussions about ethical investing, financial inclusion, wealth inequality, and sustainable finance overlap with ideas that Islamic economics has discussed for centuries.

A modern application could include:

\- Islamic banks that finance businesses through partnerships rather than interest-bearing loans.

\- Sukuk (Islamic bonds) to build infrastructure.

\- Digitally managed zakat systems to reduce poverty.

\- Waqf (charitable endowments) funding schools, hospitals, research, and public welfare.

\- Strong anti-monopoly laws and ethical business regulations.

Would implementing such a system be easy? Probably not. Today's global economy is deeply integrated with interest-based finance, so any transition would require careful planning, strong institutions, and transparent governance.

But I do think Islamic economics deserves to be studied on its own merits rather than dismissed because of stereotypes. Whether someone ultimately agrees with it or not, it offers a distinctive perspective on balancing markets, ethics, and social responsibility.

A note to my fellow Muslims:

One of the biggest mistakes we can make is assuming that Islam has nothing meaningful to say about economics, governance, science, or society. Too often, we inherit our faith culturally without studying it deeply.

Studying Islam doesn't mean rejecting modern knowledge it means understanding what our own tradition actually teaches before judging it. Many people call Muslims backward while knowing very little about Islamic intellectual history, jurisprudence, economics, philosophy, or civilization.

We should read the Qur'an with understanding. Study the Sunnah. Learn from qualified scholars. Explore Islamic history critically and honestly. Whether you end up agreeing with every classical opinion or not, you'll at least be forming your views from knowledge rather than assumptions.

Knowledge has always been one of Islam's greatest strengths. We shouldn't neglect it.

reddit.com
u/Quietpebble9979 — 12 days ago

As A Muslim, I'd Appreciate Honest Perspectives on These Concerns

​

You all might have seen how Muslims in India are treated. The Hindutva goons are doing everything they want to put us down. Our Mosques are being burnt and replaced with temples, homes are destroyed and even innocent Muslims are jailed. During the CJP protests you have seen how Junaid Malik was imprisoned along with his father despite the fact that he did a gesture of kindness by providing food and water to the protestors. The Mohammed Ali Jauhar University is also under the threat of being demolished and how is it still occuring because we are weak. I will say it without filter and it is true because if we had power than why we will be treated like this in the country where we were born.

The mistake many Muslims like us make is this: we keep arguing about ideas, metaphysics, Quranic reinterpretations, Hadith authenticity, while ignoring the elephant in the room: Power. The things which I mentioned aren't inherently bad and I encourage young Muslims to do but what I feel is that we should understand Islam in a better way and study our Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, classic Islamic scholars even if we don't agree with some ideas but at least we would be able to create our own opinions.

Islam today is stuck in idealism and moralism. We can write articles and create content as much as we want. We may be able to influence many people, but that would still not be enough. Our main enemy is the Far Right like the Zionists, MAGA and Hindutvas who spread poison against Muslims. Despite so much online activism for so many years, nothing significant has changed on the ground when it comes to challenging these powerful enemies. Without power, we can do nothing. We can argue with them as much as we want, insult them as much as we want but what is needed is the core understanding to challenge them. Our Islamic Economics system is developed in a halal way where we can improve not just our lives but the lives of every Muslim. Today you will see how the BJP government due to their influence in Bollywood is able to produce so many films showing Muslims as villains. They are able to do it without no one questioning because the Far Right ideology is too strong. Al Jazeera is by far the only media company which supports Muslims and other Muslim media groups showing out plight in a nuanced way are small and not that funded. Our Madhrasas are also always looked down. Even if a Muslim gains wealth than he won't invest in any media, any Madhrasa or University or even a financial institution which improves our lives.

Today we are divided and if we are told about our backwardness then we talk about our glorious Islamic history. As is say it again that isn't bad because our history is great no doubt but we are stuck in the past without thinking about making our past and future even better than our history. No Muslim has any excuse to be mediocre anymore. Everyone should be at 100% effort. It only takes a couple of generations, maybe three at worst, for this to pay off. By effort I mean both in the dunya and the akhira sense. People should be at the top of their class in university while also having enough Islamic knowledge to combat attacks from all sides.

reddit.com
u/Quietpebble9979 — 12 days ago
▲ 28 r/PtjDiscussions+1 crossposts

Only Way PTJ Can Save This Arc

After the latest chapter the arc had gone completely downhill and some fans even stopped reading the manhwa. The arc was hyped up a lot from the beginning and the first chapter of the arc showed promise but the arc became extremely predictable with Gapryong overcoming everything with overcome.

PTJ can show Shingen entering Japan to invade it and he takes on everyone with his strength, skills and of course Yamazaki genes. But, Gapryong fights Shingen and loses to him. Gapryong finds that his overcome didn't work on Shingen at all and other lieutenants of Shingen Yamazaki are introduced like Shintaro and his third lieutenant. Gapryong after the loss realises that he was doing everything wrong this time and he thought that saving the world was more like an adventure and fun to him other than genuinely thinking of saving people. Shingen's forces cause heavy catastrophe in South Korea and no one is able to stop them. Elite plays sides thinking that Gapryong won't be able to defeat the Yamazakis. The only people who stay by his side are Jinyoung, Tom Lee, Baekho and Bakgu Noh. Gapryong starts taking things seriously and trains his body and starts understanding his power better. He starts uniting the gangs of South Korea in order to fight the Yamazakis which is a united force.

The only reason why fans are hating the arc is because Gapryong's victories seem very easy and the arc isn't delivering the hype which PTJ promised.

You all can discuss other theories and plans in the comments.

u/Quietpebble9979 — 15 days ago

Are There Any Writers In The Sub?

I am currently a student but I am also an amateur writer who is working on some stories to depict Islamic tradition in an authentic way although I haven't written them yet but I was also wondering whether there are any writers here in the sub.

u/Quietpebble9979 — 20 days ago

What Are Your Opinions On The Current Arc?

Honestly the arc had a good start but feels very boring to me but what do you all think about it?

u/Quietpebble9979 — 22 days ago

Islamic Economics: More Relevant Today Than Many People Think

Whenever people hear "Islamic economics," many assume it's an outdated system that only belonged to the medieval world. But after reading about it, I think that assumption misses the point.

Islamic economics isn't just about banning interest. It's a broader ethical framework for how wealth should be earned, invested, and distributed.

Some of its key principles include:

• No riba (interest): Money shouldn't generate guaranteed profit simply by existing. Investment should involve sharing both risk and reward.

• Profit and risk sharing: Instead of debt-based financing, businesses can be funded through partnerships where investors and entrepreneurs share success and failure.

• Zakat: A mandatory redistribution of wealth to help the poor and prevent excessive concentration of wealth.

• No excessive uncertainty (gharar): Contracts should be transparent, fair, and based on real assets.

• No gambling or speculative wealth (maysir): Wealth should come from productive activity rather than chance or harmful speculation.

• Ethical investment: Businesses should avoid industries that are considered harmful or unethical.

What's interesting is that many modern discussions about ethical investing, financial inclusion, wealth inequality, and sustainable finance overlap with ideas that Islamic economics has discussed for centuries.

A modern application could include:

- Islamic banks that finance businesses through partnerships rather than interest-bearing loans.

- Sukuk (Islamic bonds) to build infrastructure.

- Digitally managed zakat systems to reduce poverty.

- Waqf (charitable endowments) funding schools, hospitals, research, and public welfare.

- Strong anti-monopoly laws and ethical business regulations.

Would implementing such a system be easy? Probably not. Today's global economy is deeply integrated with interest-based finance, so any transition would require careful planning, strong institutions, and transparent governance.

But I do think Islamic economics deserves to be studied on its own merits rather than dismissed because of stereotypes. Whether someone ultimately agrees with it or not, it offers a distinctive perspective on balancing markets, ethics, and social responsibility.

A note to my fellow Muslims:

One of the biggest mistakes we can make is assuming that Islam has nothing meaningful to say about economics, governance, science, or society. Too often, we inherit our faith culturally without studying it deeply.

Studying Islam doesn't mean rejecting modern knowledge it means understanding what our own tradition actually teaches before judging it. Many people call Muslims backward while knowing very little about Islamic intellectual history, jurisprudence, economics, philosophy, or civilization.

We should read the Qur'an with understanding. Study the Sunnah. Learn from qualified scholars. Explore Islamic history critically and honestly. Whether you end up agreeing with every classical opinion or not, you'll at least be forming your views from knowledge rather than assumptions.

Knowledge has always been one of Islam's greatest strengths. We shouldn't neglect it.

reddit.com
u/Quietpebble9979 — 22 days ago