I really wanted to like this game, but I feel mislead.
I really wanted to like this game, but I feel mislead.
I REALLY wanted to like this game.
Everyone kept bringing up P5-R as a must play, so I watched and read a lot of reviews before finally purchasing it. The “length” of the game was brought up a lot as a negative, but that didn’t phase me because I love games with lots of content to explore and am used to 100%ing and sinking lots of time. “Story heavy” games don’t scare me: I loved Witcher 3, Baldur’s gate 3 and E33 (lots of 3’s lol). But in reviews of P5-R, no one ever elaborated on what they meant by “length”, so I just assumed they meant there was lots of main story content. So I dropped the 60 bucks and bought it.
Once I started playing, everything seemed right up my alley at first: music and art style is great, creature creating and collecting immediately caught my interest, the idea of exploring Tokyo and doing life sim stuff in between seemed cool.
But pretty soon I started to wonder “hey, when am I going to be set free from this very on-rails tutorial?” Everyone online said after the first palace, but I’m way past the first palace and nothing has changed 😂.
It’s now become crystal clear to me that this game is more like 60% visual novel and dating sim, with about 20% actual gameplay and 20% life sim stuff, if that. I don’t think it’s an exaggeration at all to say the majority of the game is just clicking through dialogue scenarios and cut scenes.
I honestly barely consider it a life sim because every life sim aspect is literally just a cut scene (except for like 2 : the batting cages and crossword puzzle). Plus, the game very rarely gives you true “freedom” to make decisions about what you’re doing day to day. Like most in game “days” just fly by as cut scenes. Like what happened to the whole “morning,noon and night” idea?? The amount of time you actually have physical control of your character is hardly any time at all.
I’m honestly pissed 😂. Why does NO-ONE mention in any review how “visual novel”-esq this game actually is ?? I’ve tried to keep playing past the second palace but I just can’t do it. I don’t mean to trash a lot of people’s favorite game, the combat and palaces are awesome, but I feel so incredibly mislead about the gameplay loop.